"What Starmer should say is that asylum seekers are not merely an administrative processing concern, but a human rights one. That the UK has obligations, and moreover, values and convictions, that necessitate looking fairly and humanely upon the resettlement needs of those fleeing war, persecution and the devastation of their countries.

He will not, because, well, in the U.K. it feels like heresy just to have typed the above."

Nesrine Malik

#UKAsylumPolicy

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/aug/19/riots-keir-starmer-racist-anti-immigration-narratives-truth

After the riots, Keir Starmer should tell us the truth about our country. This is why he won’t

The violence exposed racist narratives based on lies. Yet where is the counter-argument, asks Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

The Guardian

"This is Britain. We don’t live in Gotham City, waiting for a mayor to clean the streets of villains. We are not just atomised individuals running our own public limited companies, but part of something bigger, part of a nation that has miraculously expanded, absorbed and assimilated people from all over the world, one that has manifested the best and most natural of human impulses – to get along and make a common home."

Nesrine Malik

#UKAsylumPolicy

"This truth must be said not just by Starmer, but the entire government, consistently and unflinchingly, without fear of what that will unleash. Because what is the cost of saying it? Will it, maybe, bring angry thugs on to our streets? Will it provoke people so much that they will attack the police, mosques, businesses and individuals? Will it trigger even more invective from the rightwing media and claims of treachery on the part of the Labour government? No – that is the cost of silence."

The 'British' should read every last word of this by Nesrine Malik, Including and especially Keir Starmer. We need the truth to be told about immigration. The real truth.

"The real truth is that Britain is a nation that has miraculously expanded, absorbed and assimilated people from all over the world, one that has manifested the best and most natural of human impulses – to get along and make a common home."

#UKAsylumPolicy

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/aug/19/riots-keir-starmer-racist-anti-immigration-narratives-truth

After the riots, Keir Starmer should tell us the truth about our country. This is why he won’t

The violence exposed racist narratives based on lies. Yet where is the counter-argument, asks Guardian columnist Nesrine Malik

The Guardian

The other inconvenient truth about immigration to the U.K.

It puts a strain on public services. We need more housing, health and education.

It's just a numbers thing. It's nobody's fault, certainly not the immigrants. It's the government's job to manage the increase and make sure there is enough to go round. It's the hard work they need to be doing.

It's their failures that leave the rest of us blaming each other.

Why don't they tell us this truth?

#UKAsylumPolicy
#UKImmigration

@ProjectFearlessness
Why don’t they tell us the truth? For me, the jury’s out on the present Government but the Tories, enthusiastically aided by most of our pathetic #media and client so-called #journalists, deliberately did all they could to keep the fires of [illegal] #immigration and #asylum seekers burning. Why? IMO because they needed a scapegoat, to distract us our from their manifest failings; and corruption.
@UnholyOrdnance
Yes, that's how I'm feeling about the new government, the jury's out. They did make some very unimpressive noises about immigration during the election that seemed to be directed at wavering Tory voters. I'm waiting to see how they deal with it, soon, after the noise of the riots die down.
@ProjectFearlessness what a ridiculous comment to say it puts a strain on public services. An increase of one percent or 2% of the population makes absolutely no practical difference to an already strangled health service. Blaming immigrants for health service cuts is the worst possible kind of racism.
Edit: furthermore, the people who move here are not the sick and the elderly. They are young healthy people who have no need for the health service at this time in their life.
@peterbrown
No. You missed my point. Read it again.
I say this as someone whose children had real difficulty getting a school place as it was at the time when Poland entered the E.U. and there was an influx of Polish families into my inner city area.
It was a real problem. My attitude then was that the government should do the work and make more school places available. I didn't for a second think of having less Polish kids here.

@ProjectFearlessness well I’m afraid I still think you’re playing with fire. “No room in this country” is the siren call of the extreme right and it’s what gets people out on the street to protest against Immigration.

The inadequacy of the school size was not caused by the nationality of the pupils but by the lack of provision, and including their national origin in the description merely feeds xenophobia.

@peterbrown
No. There was zero racism or xenophobia involved. I was just talking about the realities of how a population increase stretches public services and how we have to stick together and make sure we blame the government for the lack of adequate provision, and not each other.
It's just a reality, something we have to deal with in inner city Manchester.
I notice you live in the Hebrides, so it's probably a bit more of an abstract problem for you.
@ProjectFearlessness I know there are many immigrants work in the NHS. So, in some sense they are helping the UK health care.
@onthewings
That's a good point that should be made more often. If you look at the polling on this, it shows the U.K. public are massively in favour of having immigrants as health workers.
@ProjectFearlessness this does need to be said. Whilst I was pleased with the speed in which the riots were dealt with, I was sad to learn that Starmer apparently took advice from Tony Blair to still go with the border control trope. The racists don't really care about controlled immigration, they just hate anyone who isn't white. Pandering to their racism isn't going to change their minds.
@Annekin
Exactly. It's a touch more positive when we look at what the new government have done. They stopped the Rwanda plan, are closing Bibby Stockholm, expanded the Afghan refugee scheme, and are prioritising the asylum case backlog.
So they are moving, slowly, towards more fairness and compassion. I just wish they would match this in the way they speak and stop being so cautious and pandering to the worst of the racists among us.
@ProjectFearlessness I remember when New Labour were in power & my dad (who was an avid Labour supporter) would get so annoyed that they would in public often tow the populist line, but in private they would make positive changes to those areas most in need (Sure Start for example). He could never understand why they didn't advertise their caring side (so to speak). I suspect that was to do with their courting of the Murdoch press. So I really hope Starmer hasn't sold his soul in a similar way.
@Annekin
Dads are always right. They're so annoying. What they're doing and what they're saying about immigration and asylum is not matching. Maybe when we get through this rioting atmosphere we will get more sense of where they really are. I'm withholding judgement, for now.

@ProjectFearlessness

Our local #NHS hospital organised coffee mornings free for all staff and volunteers as a gesture of - I can’t think of a better word - ‘solidarity’ after the unpleasantness of the riots.