@mjgardner A little less snarky an answer is that your framing is wrong. It's not that property is being "taken", it is that being part of a society includes agreeing to the rules that the society has. Some of those rules where I live include *giving* some of my property to support society by way of paying taxes. If, as a society, we decide that part of that support includes providing a UBI so people have access to basic things necessary for life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness (that are also considered rights, at least in the UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights) and agree that to be a part of the society, the folks who can will agree to contribute towards that.