I'll put this response here for everyone:

The Court made a decision. All we can do is speculate about why. Eventually we may know why they elected to proceed in this manner.

Like everyone else, I can speculate on why they proceeded this way, but I refuse.

I predict they'll nix the idea of immunity.

That's different from speculating on what happened in a closed meeting.

(Maybe, as a defense lawyer, I am accustomed to courts not doing what I want them to do or think they should do.)

@Teri_Kanefield I'm glad I'm not seeing people melting down over this. Seems to me that not only is cert a minority decision, but I could easily imagine justices who think immunity is a nonstarter wanting to take the case in order to settle the question with some degree of finality.