A word about left-wing conspiracy theories.

Yesterday I sent about 10 people to this page because they were saying the same untrue things about Merrick Garland that I disproved here with facts:

https://terikanefield.com/can-democracy-work-in-america-part-iii-an-msnbc-cnn-conspiracy-theory-and-the-perils-of-legal-punditry/

That's when I realized a new Merrick Garland conspiracy theory had taken hold.

My initial reaction was pure irritation.

A knew what it would take to disprove it. . .

1/

Part 3: The Perils of Legal Punditry - Teri Kanefield

The Misinformation-Outrage Cycle This is Part 3. It’s generally best to follow the advice given to Alice and the White Rabbit in Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland: “Begin at the beginning, go on to the end, and then stop.” But if you must read out of order, here are all the links: Part 1: There are […]

Teri Kanefield

A friend of mine, the lawyer I mentioned, @StephanieJones (who isn't here yet) did the work of laying out the arguments, so I wouldn't have had to do that.

But it is so much work to tamp down this misinformation.

I spent literally dozens of hours writing this series: https://terikanefield.com/can-democracy-work-in-america-part-1-there-are-no-yankees-here/

Before I wrote that, I spent dozens of hours tamping down misinformation when I wrote this:

https://terikanefield.com/criminallawfaqs/

I have spent 5 years tamping down left-wing misinformation

2/

The Misinformation-Outrage Cycle, Part 1: "There are no Yankees here!" - Teri Kanefield

This is Part 1. It’s generally best to follow the advice given to Alice and the White Rabbit in Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland: “Begin at the beginning, go on to the end, and then stop.” But if you must read out of order, here are all the links: Part 1: There are no Yankees here. […]

Teri Kanefield

I cannot do it any more.

I asked Stephanie where it is coming from and she thinks it's the "TV celebrities."

I spent some time yesterday on Twitter, not addressing the latest bit of misinformation, but explaining how it happens.

It's really easy to throw out what I call a rage-inducing simplification.

It takes hours to explain why it's wrong.

One observation about Twitter: It has become a true left wing misinformation echo chamber.

3/

This is a literal comment that came to me: "We just want justice and I guess we're never going to get it."

Notice the plural.

They all follow the same big accounts. Many are lawyers but many are not.

One person argued with me and told me that the people he listens to are "former prosecutors from major schools."

Me: So everything he says is true?

These "former prosecutors" are the same ones who I've been debunking for years.

It is sad and crazy

4/

Yesterday on Twitter I tried to explain why these TV celebrities are enraging them with what I'll charitably call "rage inducing simplifications."

1) If you are expected to constantly offer hot takes on complex legal issues, you simply don't have time to do the thinking and research.

2) First responses are usually more emotional, so they resonate more with listeners.

5/

3) the way to be popular is to reflect back the fears and anxieties of the audiences and many have succumbed to the ego trip of being dubbed an expert on all things.

Some of them were probably good lawyers, but that meant that they went into court prepared. Some had teams of lawyers checking their briefs for accuracy.

A few of the former prosecutors I know from reputation were lousy. They did the same things in court.

6/

A few of them are making bank. They're not going to stop. They found the formula and they're adored in a way that practicing lawyers are not adored.

Psychologist explain how even smart people fall victim to conspiracy theories when those theories play on your biases and fears.

And of course we are in a media disruption and people do not have access good neutral news.

7/

Seeing the misinformation take hold among Democrats and liberals scared me because who will hold on to truth? Obviously the right wing is mired in lies.

Someone has to hold on to the truth for it to survive.

Now I take comfort in two things:

1) The echo chamber is fairly small and limited to people on social media and cable news talk show viewers.

Most normal people have no idea the Attorney General is demonized.

2) Conspiracy theories need a target. Better the AG than Biden or Harris.

8/

I am now out of the business of tamping down the latest nonsense.

It's a game of whack-a-mole.

I can see what happened on Twitter:
The people who are left pulled together. They all follow the same "experts" who echo each each other.

"We just want justice and I guess we'll never get it."

It's literally groupthink.

And very sad.

Stay out of it if you can.

9/

@Teri_Kanefield Besides the fact that you do your research, what makes your feed so valuable is that you’ve never devolved into hyperbole. The #farL discovered Negative Partisanship and embraced it with gusto, but instead of directing it at republicans deploys it inter-party. Phrases like corporate Dem etc, are used to divide the party. Big pushes to demonize specific Dems like Nancy Pelosi, Biden by proxy when attacking the AG he appointed, Harris directly via Susan Sarandon.etc.
@Pineywoozle @Teri_Kanefield It’s directed internally for two general reasons: one, that anyone on the right is past the point of no return so talking to them is futile (to an extent I agree, in that I see more value in empowering the left than in seeking converts) and beneath them, and two, that left-of/liberals are far easier to debate/bully than centrists because the views are generally the same, it’s more a willingness to upset the general order for mere possibility.
@WhiteCatTamer Upsetting the general order is the goal. They can’t win an election, so the hope as Sarandon pointed out is to make it so bad it speeds the revolution. The problem is there will be no glorious revolution, just persecution, austerity & needless suffering and death for far too long if Fascism wins. @Teri_Kanefield
@Pineywoozle @WhiteCatTamer @Teri_Kanefield a relative who grew up in a conservative religious environment hating Democrats moved rather seamlessly to a Bernie supporting leftist who hates Democrats. Also believes various conspiracies (DNC rigged against Bernie in 2016 and 2020, rotating villain means Democrats deliberately don’t accomplish their goals, both parties are the same, etc.). They have moved further left and spend all of their time attacking Democrats for their imperfections.
Matt Ferrel (@[email protected])

Attached: 1 image Far too many on the Left spend most of their time blaming Democrats for the actions of Republicans instead of doing anything constructive to make progress on the issues they claim to care about #uspol #uspolitics

Mastodon @ SDF

@MattFerrel @Pineywoozle @WhiteCatTamer @Teri_Kanefield

Looks like #MurcsLaw which assumes that #Republicans are toddlers who have no control over their own behavior, and #Democrats are the only adults in the room. So when the #GOP does bad stuff, everyone blames the #Dems for not controlling the GOP.

But the GOP are adults (even if they don't act like it) and the Dems have no real control over how Republicans behave. So its irrational to blame the Dems for GOP behavior.

#Meme

@ZhiZhu @Pineywoozle @WhiteCatTamer @Teri_Kanefield yep, I have a version of this pinned to my profile. I may borrow this one too.
@MattFerrel I think Murc’s law lets them off. They know if they informed America it would inform the vote but they make money from the horserace and from Republican tax laws. @ZhiZhu @WhiteCatTamer @Teri_Kanefield