Penn Jillette has renounced libertarianism, having apparently been pushed over the edge by anti-maskers

https://www.cracked.com/article_40871_penn-jillette-wants-to-talk-it-all-out.html

> Many times when I identified as Libertarian, people said to me, “It’s just rich white guys that don’t want to be told what to do,” and I had a zillion answers to that — and now that seems 100 percent accurate.
> [...]
> I’m going to vote Democrat, maybe that’s all you need to know. I will not vote for a third-party candidate.

Penn Jillette Wants to Talk It All Out

The outspoken magician/comedian/writer talks to Cracked about leaving behind Libertarianism, why he’s worried about the future and how Trump is even worse than you think

Cracked.com
@bascule Oh, wow! Glad to see that he's gotten better on that front. I've been a fan with an asterisk for a while due in large part to that.

@unlambda @bascule

This isn’t surprising if one listens to Penn’s Sunday School.

Seems clear to me he’s been shifting more visibly towards a progressive position for a while.

@Aphrodite @unlambda @bascule I wish Progressives hadn’t hijacked a word they don’t live up to. I’m never sure at first if some one means actual progressive thought. Progressives are the only other group reliably throwing away their vote on 3rd party or protest votes. He’s shifting toward realistic, roll up your sleeves do the fucking work get bills passed Dem politics not a yell loudly blame the Dems and get almost no actual work done “progressive” position. #farL #PennJillette #Vote #VoteBlue
@Aphrodite @unlambda @bascule The closest major candidate to the libertarian (not the Libertarian Party) position is Bernie Sanders. So yes, progressives see guys like Penn as one of them, because, as a libertarian, he IS.
@bascule oh hey look at that the one Libertarian I have some respect for is no longer a Libertarian, imagine that.
@gothodile yeah, same. Where I disagreed with him, he still always seemed actively interested in basing his positions on evidence and reasoned argument, and being the kind of person who could be convinced otherwise where he was wrong, and this is a great example
@bascule if I remember right didn't he have a few Bullshit! episodes where he went back and pointed out where he got it wrong?
@bascule to be fair, not wanting to be told what to do is relatable
@anjune @bascule
I refuse to relate with this

@bascule My flatmate in the late 90s/early 2000s was a rather large figure in digital rights and freedoms. He was someone who had struggled due to his insistence on sticking to principle over convenience, and really worked for the greater shared public good.

But he self-identified as AnCap, back then. I had a hard time with this, but his work in civil liberties made me stop and listen (even if I still vehemently disagree with some of his positions on measures meant to repair equity after the fact). I won't name him, as he still has a Wikipedia entry for his work, and I haven't really spoken to him in over a decade now. Times have changed and I don't know how he has, given all that.

He was vegan, and ultimately I realised everything he believed was because he was pacifist to an extreme. And that was the real political ideology he espoused: pacifism. I think if you scratch the "one good Libertarian" you knew, you'll find out that they're more of an old-school Anarchist with strong pacifist convictions.

So roll on fellow-feeling and mutual aid. We can disagree about power structures, but let's kick the selfish racist conspiracy nutters out of the bar either way.

@spacehobo now anarchists I can get down with, although ancaps seem more like another flavor of Libertarian
@bascule Yeah, but I think the late 90s were a time of "Welp, looks like Communism was an absolute bust. Time to really *explore* in the other direction!" and we forgave a lot more fuzzy thinking and categories.
@bascule It was also a time of real self-doubt on the left, like "oh gosh well I guess we got thoroughly debunked and have to face facts". But even the right has its Kronstadt moments.
@bascule "I got an email during lockdown where a person from a Libertarian organization wrote to me and said, 'We’re doing an anti-mask demonstration in Vegas, and obviously we’d like you to head it.' I looked at that email and I went, 'The fact they sent me this email is something I need to be very ashamed of, and I need to change.'"

@bascule libertarianism is fun til the fascists show up.

Fight for democracy, dammit.

@bascule Since the Mises Caucus gained significant power, the Libertarian party has lost all potential to be good in any way. It's just a subordinate to the Right Wing agenda. Not that it was ever clear of that territory, but it had its moments. Good on him for moving in the right direction!

@bascule

>> if you use the word “we,” and you’re not talking about eight billion people, fuck you

Fantastic interview. Thank you

@bascule @danilo — This restores a bit of balance to the Force.
@bascule What a relief to see a guy in his demographic get cooler and more empathetic with age. There are a lot of rich, but B-list or not quite as famous as they used to be, celebrities that turn to being grumpy old fascists with fever dreams of how they are victims of cancel culture. No, it's the kids who a wrong! Whenever I click on an interview with a guy of his demographics and stature, I brace myself for disappointment.
@skweetis @bascule I’m basically Penn’s age (about a year older), and I find myself moving in that direction as well. Sometimes it happens.
@davewordnerd @bascule Oh, I'm 50 and while I've always been lefty serving side-eye to libertarians, I find myself hurtling to the left at light speed. I really do think there's something to being or having been *almost* hugely famous that sends people careening into right-wing grievance. Like, what do Chachi or Frasier have to complain about? Then you have the people like John Cleese who thinks he's shaking his fist at the clouds just the *right* amount.
@skweetis @bascule I have become much better off in old age than I was in my youth, and I have become much more of a lefty as I've aged. Not all us old fucks become FYIGM types as we get older :)
@bascule Yay! Now please tell the millions to do the same!
@bascule he was the only Libertarian I respected, because he at least had principles
@bascule Libertarians are just Republicans smart enough to spell Libertarian.
@bascule The ideas of Libertarianism and Communism (as defined in a dictionary) are well meaning. The way they manifest in reality is what fucking sucks. They both manifest with tyranny because humanity without at least some rules is anarchy.

@bascule

Penn Jilette was on The Apprentice - and should have won if shitbird had made the decision fairly based on ability - so he’s seen first hand what a piece of shit Trump is.

@bascule Good for him! I wonder if the folks at @desertbus finally rubbed off on him! 😅♥️
@bascule Today I learned Cracked.com still exists.

@bascule I read that interview earlier tonight, really good read.

I didn't know much about the guy prior to this.

@bascule

Penn wrote about Trump on Facebook back in 2016 before the election. This was in a thread that was started by a friend of mine and a bunch of libertarian leaning people participated.

He stated then that Trump was a bad person. And he further said this wasn't about his political positions, he's a bad person as a person according to Penn.

He was very emphatic and clear about it. Don't let Trump become president he said. He's bad news.

@bascule
"and now that seems 100 percent accurate."
Now? Penn, you just haven't been paying attention.
@bascule the whole interview is really fantastic. Never knew he was so wise.

@bascule The vast majority of people who describe themselves as "libertarian" in the US are not, in fact, libertarian, at all; in fact, they are the antithesis of libertarian, they are *authoritarians*.

"Liberty for me, but not for thee" is no Liberty, at all.

Real Liberty is and can only possibly be based upon Equality. We must be Free precisely because we are all Equal in Dignity. There is no other possible basis for Liberty. If you do not understand this, you are no libertarian.

@bascule Really pleased to read this.

I've never known a Libertarian who, at the core, wasn't just an overgrown version of a kid in a huff over not getting the first slice of cake at someone else's birthday party.

@bascule I've seen a P&T live show and I've enjoyed some of their TV work. I once exchanged a glance with him while I was sitting at a gate in SJC and he was having a discussion with the gate agent. I stopped following him when I learned of his libertarian leanings. This awakening gives me some hope.

@bascule

Pretty much exactly like me, and it was pretty much the same "anti-masking" straw that broke the proverbial camel's back.

Exactly why libertarians should support masking: "if I don’t wear a mask, the chance of fucking someone else up increase."

Then again, I don't feel like I belong anywhere else either since pretty much everyone else has stopped masking too (and it was the Biden administration that led the charge on declaring COVID over while it is still wildly contagious).

@bascule

Folks in the debunking trade are all too familar w/this asymmetry:

"Woodward and Bernstein are pretty sure the president of the United States committed crimes, and they work their asses off to try to prove that. But if you’re deep in the MAGA movement, you can just type that Biden went to China and set up a secret nuclear arsenal, and you get this incredible amount of praise with seven-minutes work."

It's a not a system where energy is conserved. Dark energy is endlessly available.

@bascule Well, I'm glad he finally came to his senses, but somebody needs to tell him he is not voting Semocrat, he is voting Democratic.

@bascule Huh, I guess he fooled us :-)

He is such a smart and articulate guy, I often questioned the libertarian leanings.

Now that so many billionaires seem to think that they don't need democracy, quite a few grass roots libertarians are realizing that they can't survive in the US on their own - or maybe they are just getting older and can't afford medical insurance.

@bascule just go left libertarian my dude.

LB: This is a delightful interview, but I was particularly struck by this quote:

"(Trump’s) basic idea that, in a transaction, someone wins and someone loses is the most deeply anti-American, anti-capitalist idea you can possibly have. The idea of winners and losers being said about capitalism is a gross distortion of what that’s supposed to be. The way Penn & Teller run (our) business is I want everybody to make money."

Like yes, obviously, that's how capitalism is *supposed to work*: everyone involved gets something they value more than the thing they gave up. "Winners and losers" is the failure mode of capitalism, not the ideal. And it's deeply weird that anyone would believe otherwise, much less think it desirable.
@rowyn the libertarians and market absolutists don't realize (well maybe Jillette does) that Adam Smith's laissez-faire, invisible hand etc. were egalitarian and pro-community pushback against big capital that had captured the state apparatus.
@ljwrites @rowyn we're taught to ignore the power of capital and just focus on whether a government has power or not, specifically so that robber-baron capitalists get to make bribery legal and make losers of us all. If we looked at the intersection of millionaires, corporations, government and average people at all in grade school we really would all be Marxists of some flavor because who in their right mind wants to live under the thumb of Exxon-Mobil and GM?

@bascule Good, that always disappointed the hell out of me.

Libertarians are housecats: fiercely convinced of their independence from complex systems which sustain them that they are utterly ignorant about.

@maxthyme @bascule Like many geek-ish males, I was libertarian as a teen/20-something but the more I saw how the world worked, the more I realized it was just a wordy attempt to justify a arrogant, but misplaced, selfishness.

@bascule one of his best observations in this interview:

“(Trump’s) basic idea that, in a transaction, someone wins and someone loses is the most deeply anti-American, anti-capitalist idea you can possibly have. The idea of winners and losers being said about capitalism is a gross distortion of what that’s supposed to be.”

The real idea is that both people are better off. Win-win. “Capitalism” and “libertarian” have been hijacked, and great examples of why I don’t trust labels.

@bascule

A libertarian who can open his mind to reality. What next?

@bascule finally someone who said “i’m leaving the nazi bar”

@bascule this is almost exactly how I left the Libertarian party. They sent me some damn literature on an anti masking demonstration and asked for money to support it.

I wrote back that I would have been less ashamed to be associated with them if they'd openly advocated drunk driving and that I never wanted to hear from them again.

Someone at I Got Mine, Fuck You Headquarters must have read it because I haven't heard from them since.

@bascule I do a lot of local government work, and I’ve never met a libertarian with a good drainage plan.