If you have an 12th grader in your life who is applying to college give them a hug this was a rough week.

"Getting in to a good school" is harder than ever and I don't think many people over 35 get it.

The whole globe is knocking and the door AND there are more people, but not more spots.

It really ain't everything. Take that 4.5 GPA and perfect SAT get yourself a state school scholarship instead graduate with no debt. That's what I say.

(edited 11 to 12)

Also I strongly suspect early decision is more for legacy kids. I just don't know about it working out for many of the very much NOT legacy kids I've known with insane GPA and all kinds of fancy projects and test scores and stuff.

I can't prove it... but it feels like a way for with kids with two legacy options to signal which one.

... just a suspicion though.

@futurebird

I would have been a legacy (at a different Ivy than the one I applied to) for my early decision, but I do wonder if there was some reciprocal Ivy-to-Ivy shenanigans behind the scenes

I had a very strong packet, but also I was a sibling-school legacy from Georgia, not a 1st-generation college applicant from the Bronx

Not sure I would have gotten in if I'd been the other one.

And I can't imagine it's gotten BETTER in the last thirty years

"get yourself a state school scholarship instead graduate with no debt."

🗣️ 📣 LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK!!!

if there is one thing my ex-husband and i were militant about was for our sons to not end up with college debt.

once the pandemic hit, they totally got why we insisted on them going to SUNYs or CUNYs.

ever so randomly one of them will come to me and hug me after hearing their friends cry about student debt and say, "thank you for not letting me take out loans"

@futurebird

@futurebird Heck, I went to the community college down the street, then California State University, then University of California. You don’t HAVE to jump straight from HS to a major university.
@futurebird I am literally taking a screenshot of this so I can send it as a recurring reminder to certain high performing kids (and their parents).
@futurebird If you aren’t sure of what you want to be, put in two years at a community / junior college taking the core courses until you figure out what you want to do. It’s less expensive and the credits are transferable.
@futurebird There should be more spots.

@PeoriaBummer

Obviously. But they benefit from the scarcity. It's absurd to think only a few 100 students are "excellent" pure silliness.

@futurebird Yep. They set up this whole system to crush kids and parents for their own benefit.
@futurebird I graduated from state school, and had my college debt paid off basically as soon as I landed a career role. Watching kids role in $140-240k+ in debt to do the same job, was it worth it?
@futurebird
I attended a small liberal arts college that I would almost certainly no longer get in to.

@futurebird @Gorfram Many state schools *are* among the best. If I had an 11th grader I'd be prouder to send them to Michigan than to Harvard.

My father's a state school grad, and was the chair of his department for years. He took it from barely meeting accreditation to thriving. And he made the mistake of hiring someone from the Ivies. They were fine as teachers, but the only people they were recommending were also from the Ivies. My father asked him about this, and he said, to my father's face, that of course he'd only hire from those schools, not from *state* schools.

That's really what you're getting. Not necessarily a better education (that's up to the student). Just in-crowd networking.

@RaleighStraight @futurebird @Gorfram

someone could say that this is just the lie of meritocracy being extended beyond the schools that FAANGs decrees had enough merit (who already bought into the lie) so those who have an in are perceived as more meritorious than some nobody who needs to have built FTL and developed a cure for covid-44 before being noticed

which reinforces the elitism

but that’s just crazy talk. can’t be right. ignore this.

@futurebird It can take 50 years to overcome the bad ideas a student learns at a “good college”. The loan payments hit harder, alas.
@futurebird
Or learn German, college is free here and there are plenty of spots in Engineering open!

@futurebird That's what we're doing. He has managed to pay for his entire schooling with scholarships BECAUSE he is going to a good, but small engineering college in state.

He is studying electrical engineering. No need for ivy league.

@JenWojcik @futurebird My son was iffy on applying to any of the ivies, but due to on-campus events after 10/7 he def isn’t now.
@PamelaBarroway @futurebird Yeah. We didn't even consider it. No point, really. He wasn't interested in them, and neither were we.
@JenWojcik @futurebird There are plenty of schools just as good that cost way less and where AS isn’t (as much) of a concern.

@futurebird I graduated from a prep high school where it was drilled into me that “smart” people at least got into a top 50 school if not an Ivy. Going to a state school would’ve been equivalent to dropping out.

My biggest regret now is not taking my scores and going to an HBCU or state school for a full ride. Instead I came out with nothing. Be smart y’all.

@futurebird did this 25 years ago, 10/10, can recommend. The value proposition of a college degree is very different if you're graduating debt-free.
@futurebird Best school is now about lowest projected student loan debt balance at age 25 instead of "prestige", or "full college experience", or whatever it is schools are hyping themselves with now.
@futurebird
When I graduated from high school, the University of California guaranteed you a spot if your GPA was 3.3 (there were no honors courses then).
Yes, it's a bit different now.

@futurebird maybe slightly different as I am in the UK but fully behind this! Education should be free, trying to educate yourself and train for a career that will help GDP / the economy of [insert country name] should not begin with at least 30k of debt, and that's not including the rent for somewhere to stay, bills and food, that's just tuition fees.

I, as an older fella well above 35, feel so sorry for any kids today (I call my mid 20s children kids still!) trying to make something of themselves.

It was hard enough when I was a kid, I wouldn't want to swap places nowadays.

I hope they all understand that not all us older buggers are anti-youngsters, we are here to help and to listen. Shame governments don't try that now and again and sort the education systems out where ever you may be.

@futurebird I remember when I applied to Colleges. It was insane. The common application alone took me hours to do and I visited 2 schools before I decided on my College, Southern Virginia University. No regrets, but I hate the common application and just applying to College. I hope my future kids have it easier than I did.
@gocu54 @futurebird when I applied there was no common application. I’m glad that NYS schools shared the same application but I still had to enter the same info over and over again.
@futurebird
The USA is the wealthiest nation in the world ever. There is no excuse that higher education isn’t free.