Lately I keep thinking our biggest problem is that we confuse intelligence with loudness and arrogance, when really it's the opposite.

Intelligence is humility. It's listening and paying attention. It's understanding there's stuff you don't know or understand.

Fuck the Smartest Man in the Room.

@charliejane I remember reading that confidence is more highly correlated with the difficulty in reversing a decision than it’s correctness, because the brain is trying to justify what can’t be undone. Confidence is a thoroughly worthless signal for evaluating intelligence.
@charliejane The person who thinks himself the smartest man in the room rarely is, unless he’s utterly alone.

@charliejane

He who knows not, and knows not that he knows not, is a fool; shun him.

He who knows not, and knows that he knows not, is a child; teach him.

He who knows, and knows not that he knows, is asleep; awaken him.

He who knows, and knows that he knows, is wise; follow him.

- Confucius

@charliejane Susan Cain’s “quiet: the power of introverts in a world that won’t stop talking” covers a lot of how and why the “loudest” “wins” even if everyone knows what is being said is wrong. Worth a read.
@charliejane @Jaden2 The smartest person in the room is vastly unlikely to be the one announcing that they’re The Smartest Man In The Room.
@charliejane agreed, and definitely not the way corporate culture thinks.

@charliejane

It's so very bizarre, how the social meaning of "intelligence" is so fluid and inconsistent and has nothing to do with the actual definition. And not just the meaning and usage of the word, but whether it is something to strive for or something that is socially shamed.

@Frances_Larina @charliejane it's effectively used as a means of supporting the delusion that we live in a meritocracy, as a means of justifying the exclusion of other perspectives, & as a means of justifying the denial of autonomy.

As it's used, the concept does not exist. There is no numerical value one can assign to rank intelligence & correlate it to their value, impact, & contribution to society (one's connections & net worth will always have a higher correlation). As such, the purpose of measuring people's problem-solving abilities must be different than the purported meaning of intelligence/IQ (which people seem to use interchangeably). It seems to just be a lie embedded into our language to reinforce support for hierarchy & imperialism.

@charliejane the smartest person in the room probably would be the last person to tell you they're the smartest man in the room
@charliejane if you think you're the smartest person in the room, you're in the wrong room

@charliejane

sigh…

the things i do for $country…

**unzips skirt**

@charliejane Unfortunately this is not always included in university science curricula.
A neuroscientist explains why stupidity is an existential threat to America

It may sound like an insensitive statement, but the cold hard truth is that there are a lot of stupid people in the world, and their stupidity presents a constant danger to others. Some of these people are in positions of power, and some of them have been elected to run our country. A far greater nu...

Alternet.org
@charliejane The problem is we too often fail to understand that there is a difference between the smartest man in the room, and the biggest mouth in the room.

Trump is without question the biggest mouth in the room, but he is comically ignorant, cartoonishly delusional, alarmingly deranged, laughably in awe of the person he believes against all evidence that he is.
@charliejane People conflating confidence and competence is just the root of so much.
@charliejane Yep. A great deal of bulldust is spoken very authoritatively.
@charliejane Always good to not be the smartest person in a room, you learn a lot.

@charliejane Re that quote by @pmb00cs
"it's better to be thought a fool than speak and remove all doubt"

While it's a valid perspective, it can limit discussions.

I'm often the first to ask questions of a speaker - This may sound foolish but ...Ask for information about topic to clarify my understanding ...
I've often been thanked by people who didn't know either but who didn't want to look stupid.

@charliejane maybe intelligence is not what we should even be looking for, but rather wisdom that is intrinsically tied to humility and the ability to be intellectually flexible with new information, while intelligence is relative to the having the correct answer/solution regardless of whether or not the question/problem is the most helpful to be answered/solved.

Give wisdom a chance, and let's stop letting smart fools hold onto the levers of power.

@charliejane As a rule, I don't trust people who say things confidently, because whether or not they THINK they're right isn't the important question.
@charliejane ignorance is effortless. We’re surrounded by uncertainty and with it fear. It’s readily available, simple and easy to exploit. Assumptions shout loudly, prejudice silences questions. Understanding and knowing with confidence and certainty is difficult challenging work that is never complete
@charliejane I'M SMART AND I DISAGREE </s>

@charliejane

He who seeks knowledge begins with humbleness.

@charliejane That's wisdom. (Wisdom is experience and empathy.)
@kithrup If intelligence doesn't involve curiosity, then I don't want it.