I've been reading the last few days about opportunity hoarding, especially amongst White self-identified Liberals in the US. It's very fascinating stuff, but it indirectly reminds me of something I think of a lot when I read a subset of liberal and leftist political discourse.
I'm sure she probably doesn't even remember telling me this, but a good friend and philosopher once said to me (paraphrasing, it was years ago):
"We should be immediately skeptical - not completely close-minded, but skeptical - of any moral or political claim that is made that involves a lot of changes and sacrifices for many people but conveniently none for the people making the claim in question."

#philosophy #ethics #sociology #politics #opportunity #whiteliberalism

@pjw That's a great quote. It gets to the heart of why one should be sceptical of, for example, the Nordic countries as models of green economies. Geography made them accidentally 'green', not any political will.
@Loukas 100%
@pjw "everyone should just give up cars" [person who lives in dense city]
@pjw Can you recommend an article/paper in opportunity hoarding? Thanks.

@jenniferdeseo Happily!

There is a nice popular level book on the issue by Richard Reeves called "Dream Hoarders: How the Upper Middle Class is Leaving Everyone in the Dust"

The classic scholarly source is Charles Tilly's Durable Inequality, chapter 5.

You can also find tons of stuff on Google Scholar if you are looking for a particular metric of hoarding (race, gender, geographical, clan, etc.)

Enjoy!