~1919: global pandemic
~2019: global pandemic

~1920: Dr Thomas Tuttle's life is threatened for mask mandates
~2020: Dr Anthony Fauci's life is threatened for mask mandates

~1922: roaring 20s
~2022: we are so back!

~1923: Beer Putsch - attempted coup by fashy Germans
~2021: Jan 6 - attempted coup by fashy Americans

~1920s work on Autobahn begins. Fash hate the infra projects
~2020s Biden's infrastructure bill starts. Fash hate the infra projects

~1924: Hitler indicted
~2023: Trump indicted

I guess what I'm saying is...

1) History doesn't repeat. But it sure does rhyme.

2) A conviction doesn't mean what you think it means. You still have to oppose fascism directly. There is no way around that.

The same way that Trump will claim credit for Biden admin Infrastructure Bill improvements in about 10 years, is how people to this day still think that "Hitler made the trains run on time and fixed the roads." Hitler did not do that.

We are still on a not great path.

Everyone knows Mein Kampf is a terrible book that did, and still does, so much harm. But fewer (US) people know where Hitler was when he wrote it (jail!), or why he was in there (he flubbed his Jan 6th moment too). šŸ¤·šŸæā€ā™‚ļø

We need to get off this ride. It's not headed to a good place.

We keep thinking we've escaped the danger, but it's like a Final Destination movie. We haven't broken the curse yet.

@mekkaokereke I hear what you're saying, but hitler was like 45. Trump is 77 and in pretty marginal health.

not that I plan to let my foot off the gas on beating these fascists or that Turnip is the only threat, but it's not a straight comparison.

@qkslvrwolf @mekkaokereke it is incredibly naĆÆve to think this is going to end with Trump the man. The problem is Trumpism, and there are *many* people that are smarter and more dedicated to that idea than Donald J Trump.

@jonathankoren @mekkaokereke

"not that I plan to let my foot off the gas on beating these fascists or that Turnip is the only threat, but it's not a straight comparison."

Right in the post, my dude.

@mekkaokereke he also used the court case to start building public support, which is why he had an audience for when mein kampf was published. good to keep that in mind as the GOP talks about cameras in the court proceedings.
@jmsdnns @mekkaokereke this is also something that's nettlesome: Trump might be an old fascist dick, but he's also charismatic and a gifted entertainer, being on camera is what he wants.
@mekkaokereke eery parallels, but what makes it weird is that Agent Orange is already in his late 70s! struggling to imagine a "billionaire" octogenarian's prison diary ("Bigly Unfair"?) resonating quite so much this round

@natevw

I think it will resonate even better.

Because his writing will be shorter, disseminated faster, people will get it for free, and just like "The Constitution," people that make it their religion and whole personality, won't even bother to read the whole thing. šŸ¤·šŸæā€ā™‚ļø

@mekkaokereke @natevw It’ll be on fucking YouTube and Fox News clips. Or written for him. Or the machine will just manufacture a new demagogue. We’re really fucked if they find someone functional.

@mekkaokereke quite important difference:

hitler 1924: 35 yo
trump 2024: 79 yo

@mspro @mekkaokereke exactly this, but it’s still a hope, not a plan
@mekkaokereke honestly I can’t imagine Trump reading a book let alone writing one.
@osmanthus @mekkaokereke Oh, Hitler didn't actually sit down and write Mein Kampf in a structured way. He just dictated (yes) his ramblings to an assistant. The thing is a mess.
@mekkaokereke
And this is why I always refer to the riot at the Capitol on 6 January 2021 as a ā€œputschā€.
1) Because it was one.
2) The word brings to mind the famous Beer Hall Putsch. Which hopefully leads to comparisons. For instance, the Beer Hall Putschists were given light sentences. Within 10 years they were running Germany.

@mekkaokereke Difference is, Adolf was a skinny 30something vegetarian, Donald is an obese 70something who lives on junk food. It took Adolf years to get there and Donald doesn’t have ’em.

Pardon my looking on the sunny side.

@timbray @mekkaokereke he might still live 20 more years, which would be more than the entire existence of the nazi party.
@mekkaokereke One important difference: Trump is already old. Maybe we'll be lucky and his time will come before we get to the worst parts of the story.
@mekkaokereke Education plays a major role here. For most people, Germany went straight from surrender in WW1 to Hitler being named Reichskanzler. If they are lucky. Their education might have also gone straight to the attack on Poland. They simply never learned that the NSDAP never won the majority in an election, or that Hitler was put in power by the conservatives.

@mekkaokereke Details aren't important when you are selling a story which is exactly what the system is doing... it's not just one person, it is an institution of them... Trump/Hitler were always interchangeable but the path one takes (this be a bad one) and the system that puts you there is way more important...

Like you said we are in a bad way because once you build it, any interchangeable figure head will come.

@mekkaokereke Yes. But I’m less worried specifically about Trump as I am the next guy who’s been watching and learning and is actually competent.

@swilliams @mekkaokereke

There's a large reactionary/fascist regressive-right structure funded by wealthy elites intent on consolidating their political power. That includes undermining democracy and the administrative state.
That structure will continue to spit out new Trump pretenders to follow the likes of DeSantis, JD Vance, Josh Hawley, etc.
https://mstdn.social/@joeinwynnewood/110890860085362542

Grassroots Joe (@[email protected])

This is a long piece that is well worth the time to read. It brings to light both the insanity and the danger presented by this batshit crazy, misogynistic, fascist, regressive-right billionaires funded outfit. The Claremont Institute: The Anti-Democracy Think Tank | The New Republic https://newrepublic.com/article/174656/claremont-institute-think-tank-trump

Mastodon 🐘
@swilliams @mekkaokereke not Yes. It's No.
Europeans don't credit Hitler for tge trains running on time or fixing the roads. You're missing the point of the cynical jokes about WW2

@swilliams @mekkaokereke Please do keep in mind that fascists are never competent.
Hitler wasn't either.

They're all just in it to line their own pockets, the atrocities are basically just to keep their hateful angry middle-aged men voters happy.

Those fucks just love "harsh solutions" for the sake of harsh solutions, espeically for non-problems.

@mekkaokereke Sidebar: FWIW, it was Mussolini who claimed to have made the trains run on time, and tl;dr, they didn't, actually, but no authoritarian worth his (and it's almost always his) salt ever let facts interfere with the narrative.

EDIT: Mussolini was also a major source of inspiration to Hitler, who idolized Il Duce, and the Beerhall Putsch took its cues directly from the March on Rome.

@mekkaokereke You left out part of the story: Hitler was tried for treason in 1924 but succeeded in turning the trial into a propaganda circus. He was given a fairly short prison sentence, which he spent writing "Mein Kampf." Eight years after he got out, he was running Germany.
@mekkaokereke I don't know where you get this idea about Hitler but we don't think of him that way.
The notion of trains running on time because of Hitler is not meant literally. It's meant as a cynical joke about the deportation on the Jews. Same goes for the roads in reference to the invasion.
@mekkaokereke And the US needs to clean up now, because it won't be Trump who will push the US into fascism, it will be power hungry billionairs. When Trump is gone, they'll find a new puppet.
The US needs to split capitalism from state.

@zeemeermin

I'm talking about US people.

There is a belief that Hitler's authoritarianism was good for getting large infrastructure projects done on time, and that fascism ensures high productivity of labor.

The US is a car obsessed and freeway addicted culture. Here's our mythology:

* The Autobahn was the first, and still the best freeway.āœ”ļø
* It's a visible monument to German engineering.āœ”ļø
* It was created by Hitler.āŒ

So yes, this is of course a trash take. We're good for those.šŸ¤·šŸæā€ā™‚ļø

@mekkaokereke That's a misconception on the part of Americans. We Europeans don't think of Hitler or Nazi-Germany that way. If we think of Hitler we think of destruction.
The highway system was build after the war, in the rebuilding period. We refer to it as such.

@zeemeermin

Yup.

Americans misconceive how racist Ireland is (not very compared to the USA). So "Irish" people in Boston are *much* more racist than real Irish people in Ireland.

Americans misconceive how Germans feel about Hitler. So American politicians routinely say "pro-German" things that would be illegal in Germany.

Americans misconceive a lot of things. Most of us don't even know our own history, let alone anyone else's. šŸ¤·šŸæā€ā™‚ļø

@zeemeermin @mekkaokereke That aphorism is not a joke about Hitler, though, it is a variant of a serious comment made about Mussolini's Italy, as a _net positive_ of fascism; Hitler, meanwhile, was still in short pants chasing people around Munich with his chicote:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benito_Mussolini#Railways

Benito Mussolini - Wikipedia

@klausfiend @mekkaokereke It is in my country. It is a cynical joke about the depertations by trains in cattle wagons. We lost thousands. It's a national trauma to this day.
Mussolini wasn't big enough to have that kind of impact on the West of Europe and the Italian railway system is not that great.

@zeemeermin @mekkaokereke I literally posted a link to the origin of the saying.

And it's a weird take on Mussolini -- by definition, Europe's first fascist leader, a man Hitler revered, and a source of inspiration to Mosley, Pelley, and the rest -- as "not big enough".

It may not have been as brutal as the Nazis, but fascist Italy was the template for authoritarians everywhere, and even today, Mussolini-style fascism still sometimes gets a pass! (I guess by not being as rabidly antisemitic?)

@klausfiend @mekkaokereke You posted wikipedia.
But it is always great to have foreigners from overseas telling us how our language and culture works.

Thank you.

@zeemeermin @mekkaokereke You are not the only person on social media whose immediate family survived the atrocities of Europe under the Nazis.

But do yourself a favor, and check the citation:
https://archive.org/details/blackmagic00kenn

It's right at the bottom of pp. 109-110, where Roberts discusses the "miracles" of Italian fascism, including its ability to get the trains to run on time.

Black magic : an account of its beneficial use in Italy, of its perversion in Bavaria, and of certain tendencies which might necessitate its study in America : Kenneth L. Roberts : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

Internet Archive
@klausfiend @zeemeermin @mekkaokereke Late to the party, but I want to add that even the term "fascism" is Italian in origin: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces
Fasces - Wikipedia

@mekkaokereke You’re so correct. Democracy is always a work in progress. We must be invested in it or we run the risk of losing it.
@mekkaokereke Imani Barbarin has been pointing out that the last mass disabling event was just before the rise of fascism deeply invested in eugenics. I can’t find the TikTok but it makes sense that, since the right and left are both steeped in ableism, a pandemic makes bio-typical politicians go off the rails.
https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/2021/08/10645352/covid-19-and-the-pandemic-of-ableist-media
Death by a Thousand Words: COVID-19 and the Pandemic of Ableist Media

The COVID pandemic isn't the only threat; the ableist media is another pandemic putting everyone's lives in danger.

@akareilly @mekkaokereke

Yeah. The giant flu pandemic left a lot of people disabled, a lot like Long Covid. The Nazis were promising to get rid of that burden on society.

Not just the politicians, but also the voters, saw a chance to get rid of a lot of "dead weight" carrying people who were damaged by a pandemic.

The punishing agreement after WWI didn't do Germany any favours. But I think global Fascism was probably coming either way.

@akareilly @mekkaokereke To be fair, the politics of eugenics were pervasive until the end of WWII. Even "good liberals", like Canada's Tommy Douglas (founder of the socialist party and father of the national health care system) were proponents: Douglas' Master's thesis, "The Problems of the Subnormal Family", endorsed it.

Eugenics was an organic outgrowth of Darwin for thinkers like Malthus, and it took the Holocaust to disabuse most people of ideas like forced sterilization.

@klausfiend @mekkaokereke
They’re still pervasive.
Just look at the language around COVID-19. Politicians can say, without endangering their careers, that since only the elderly and disabled will die, you can all go back to normal. Parents who don’t vaccinate their kids would rather have dead kids than autistic kids. The word ā€œdisabledā€ is treated like profanity. Countries lauded for being friendly to refugees, like Canada, reject disabled immigrants.

@klausfiend @mekkaokereke and of course the causes and results of disability are entwined with racism. Environmental racism causes disabilities, people with disabilities and Deaf people are abused by teachers and police. Surveillance, the amount and the consequences, is worse when you’re disabled.

Then the activist communities you turn to about these issues? No masks, no ramps, no access. Unless you’re talking about the Black Panthers.

https://behearddc.org/police-violence/

https://youtu.be/KB9bu483Odw

Police Violence - HEARD

HEARD has been working tirelessly to bring an end police brutality against deaf/disabled people. HEARD created this English & Spanish Log of Police Violence Against Deaf People, and we are looking to collect more stories of police brutality against deaf/disabled people. If you want to add your or another person story to this list, please email us

HEARD -

@klausfiend @mekkaokereke

https://disabilityhistory.org/2021/12/19/the-504-protests-and-the-black-panther-party/
and mentioned in Crip Camp, delivering food to protesters despite police interference was just one way the Black Panther Party sustained disability activism.

The 504 Protests and the Black Panther Party – Disability Social History Project

@akareilly @mekkaokereke Yeah, I heard some of that language from family members, and it was unbelievably revolting. FWIW, Canada is a "better" country, but as you note, not without its dirty secrets; it was also still forcibly sterilizing people (mostly indigenous women) into the 1970s.

And that's not even getting into the failure to implement really any of the Truth & Reconciliation Commission's recommendations, or the ongoing, comprehensive inaction regarding the MMIW crisis.

@akareilly @mhoye @klausfiend @mekkaokereke I hadn’t heard about the disabled immigrants issue and can’t find anything about it with a quick check online. Can you direct me to info about it?

@reay @mhoye @klausfiend @mekkaokereke

https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/inadmissibility/reasons/medical-inadmissibility.html#excessive-demand

ā€œdisability rights immigration $country_nameā€ in a search will bring up more.

it’s important to note that the family member exception is tricky in case of marriage - disabled people don’t have marriage equality because of loss of life-sustaining benefits.

Medical inadmissibility - Canada.ca

There are 3 possible reasons for medical inadmissibility: danger to public health, danger to public safety, and excessive demand on health or social services.

@akareilly @reay @mhoye @klausfiend @mekkaokereke yep, i couldn't immigrate to canada unless i suddenly became independently wealthy bc my meds alone cost the US govt $300k USD to keep me alive.

@klausfiend @akareilly @mekkaokereke

Malthus's ideas on overpopulation actually influenced Darwin, not the other way around.

I think it's important to note that the pseudoscience (Malthus) did not grow out of actual scientific discovery but out of desire.

Liberals and fascist alike were grasping for ever greater levels of control over society and people.

Also just the mainstream acceptance of eugenics in the era cannot really be overstated. Compulsory sterilization was upheld by the US Supreme Court in an 8-1 decision. No dissent was written, and Pierce Butler, the lone dissenter, was dismissed as holding to Catholic superstition.

@dagnymol @akareilly @mekkaokereke Thank you for sharing this! I stand corrected.

@akareilly I appreciate and understand the sentiment. Eugenics (supremacy in general) definitely plays a role in the rise of the Nazis, but it had more to do with the failure to prosecute (war) crimes by fascists (particularly Ludendorff, but really a great deal of Germany’s ruling class) than the pandemic.

When we look the other way when people in power commit crime they get the signal that they have the right to commit crime.

@EdSanders
you can not separate eugenics and fascism.
it's a comforting thought for ableists to separate the two, social darwinism and eugenics were pervasive in the late 19th and early 20th century.
the idea that a human has worth according to their usefulness to the fascist state dovetails too well to be dismissed. by the time of the Putsch it was already baked into the Nazi agenda.
@mekkaokereke Hitler didn't do any of those things, but the Great Depression ended on his watch, unintendedly thanks to his military spending which did what the doctor (Keynes) ordered. One reason he got away with so much.
And BTW it was Mussolini who made the trains run on time.
@mekkaokereke please stop this century I want off this ride
@mekkaokereke '29 is looming too, with commercial real estate on the brink of collapse, AI probably not going to do what people promised, and general interest in new tech waning from people being lied to so much from blockchains to NFTs to AI
@NireBryce @mekkaokereke imo "probably" is being overly generous here 😃
@klausfiend Unfortunately, it's possible it does the perception of the correct thing while still being horribly wrong, so it's less optimism and more cynicism