pretty remarkable to see Coinbase making the argument that crypto is not like stocks, it's like baseball cards, American Girl dolls, or Beanie Babies

it's the future of finance! except when the SEC comes knocking, then it's just a harmless little toy, your honor

#crypto #cryptocurrency #coinbase

crypto is like beanie babies – coinbase, 2023
(this is from Coinbase's motion to dismiss the lawsuit from the SEC, document #36: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/67478179/36/securities-and-exchange-commission-v-coinbase-inc/)
Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion – #36 in Securities and Exchange Commission v. Coinbase, Inc. (S.D.N.Y., 1:23-cv-04738) – CourtListener.com

MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 35 MOTION for Judgment on the Pleadings . . Document filed by Coinbase Global, Inc., Coinbase, Inc...(Savitt, William) (Entered: 08/04/2023)

CourtListener
@molly0xfff So something that was overhyped and never really gained value after the fad passed, then? 😅

@RodentRachel @molly0xfff Beanie Babies were never widely used by drug cartels.

At least, they weren't that I know of. Although I am now amused to think, what if they had been....

@molly0xfff With ‘The Beanie Bubble’ being heavily promoted at the moment, you wouldn’t expect them to want that association!
@molly0xfff They even have cutesey names, like Beanie Babies.
@molly0xfff Guess coinbase forgot the case where one beanie baby collector murdered another collector over a deal he felt cheated over.
@molly0xfff I mean, I’d rather have a beanie Bitcoin than a procedurally generated ape cartoon
@molly0xfff it has never been future of finance for me, so that is where we agreed 😅
@molly0xfff i assume the prosecution’s entire response here will be just screenshot after screenshot of all the times Coinbase and coinbase execs pushed the service as a financial investment.
@molly0xfff Genuine question here: what part of this are you criticizing? Do you think Coinbase should not try to dismiss the lawsuit (presumably because you think they should lose), or that the metaphor they used for doing so was inappropriate?
@molly0xfff so the future of finance is beanie babies :)
@molly0xfff this is where I'm hearing them making the argument that the stupidly volatile and scammy collectibles markets should be regulated
@molly0xfff If crypto is a collectible, it would need to be taxed at the higher collectibles capital gains rate. It looks like collectibles would be taxed at 28% rather than the 15% capital gains rate that most people see on stocks/securities.
@LilahTovMoon @molly0xfff Clearly it can only count as a collectible if there's exactly one hundred hidden all over the world, to find them all you have to either buy a map for real money or look up a guide on the internet, and the only reward for finding them all is an achievement.
@molly0xfff other than NFTs, the regular crypto-«money» can be divided up - you can’t exactly do that with collectibles. Has Coinbase switched entirely to NFTs?
@toriver @molly0xfff All bitcoin outputs are non-fungible, for example look at ordinals and colored coins.
@molly0xfff And yet, "cryptocurrency is typically decentralized digital money", says Coinbase.
https://www.coinbase.com/learn/crypto-basics/what-is-cryptocurrency
@molly0xfff And wait, "Cryptocurrency trading firm [Coinbase] warns its customers could be viewed as general unsecured creditors" https://www.wsj.com/articles/coinbase-says-users-crypto-assets-lack-bankruptcy-protections-11652294103 [paywalled]
Coinbase Says Users’ Crypto Assets Lack Bankruptcy Protections

Cryptocurrency trading firm warns its customers could be viewed as general unsecured creditors

WSJ
@molly0xfff Ah yes, the famously reliable value storage system, Beanie Babies.
@fraying @molly0xfff That thing where I roll up to the Chipotle and dump 55 Beanie Babies on the counter to trade for a burrito bowl, we've all been there
@lmorchard @molly0xfff 55? What a deal! I had to fork over 150.
@fraying @molly0xfff Price jumped to 67 before they finished ringing me up 😅
@molly0xfff Nobody but us tulips in here
@molly0xfff Coinbase has “hidden charges”. I pulled most money out and got hit with transfer and transactions unknown to man! Twice. 2018 every transaction was cheap. Guess when you know you’re not legit. Lied to the World about being legit. Karma is coming. Grift what’s left? (I’m in a classaction lawsuit with Coinbase.)
@molly0xfff couldn't have seen that coming AT ALL no way not even a little bit
@molly0xfff that's not fair. I enjoyed playing with my Beanie Babies as a kid, and I'm sure other kids liked their baseball cards and American Girl dolls. Cryptocurrency has never made a child smile.

@molly0xfff
if they aren't collectibles how come i can trade them on Magic The Gathering Online Exchange

checkmate, regulators

(alternate joke: Coinbase presents: the Beanie Baby Roth IRA)

@molly0xfff those fuckers keep spamming on tiktok
@molly0xfff I don’t think stocks and crypto are comparable crypto and fiat maybe.
@molly0xfff Feels like “new” crypto is having its ruberhose attack meme moment.

@molly0xfff All of the examples they provide are tangible assets with (varying levels of) inherent value.

Crypto never provides anything tangible. It's treated like money, but without a government to make its value stable. It's treated like stocks, but there's no business that increases it's value.

I think regulators are having a difficult time because it's clearly a scam, but people are trading real money for something that doesn't quite fit existing definitions in regulations.

@Wbud @molly0xfff Baseball cards have inherent value?
The value of cryptocurrency is pretty straightforward: it's used as a secure medium of exchange over internet. crypto users pay for this value with transaction fees and inflation.

@fic8 @molly0xfff Baseball cards have intrinsic value by nature of being a physical object and they gain extrinsic value through social value (fans).

Security of crypto is dubious, as most technologies use a public blockchain where wallets are easily tied to individuals. And because the value fluctuates rapidly, by the time the transaction has been verified, one of the two parties will have lost value vs government backed currency. Which is important, because you still need to pay rent in $$$

@Wbud @molly0xfff the only intrinsic value of baseball cards (or cash) is that they can be recycled into useful paper.

baseball cards "gain extrinsic value through social value (fans)"? Sounds like how many treat crypto... even if they shouldn't.

The security of cryptocurrency is well-defined. Privacy, on the other hand...

As for price volatility, the receiving party typicially bites the volatility (for better or worse) in exchange for a small ~1% fee.

@molly0xfff crypto is stupid. Nearly everyone that knows about actual finance won't touch it with a 10 foot pole.

@molly0xfff

Drug cartels, narco states, and sanctioned rogue states don't launder their money using beanie babies.

They use Russian & Chinese state sponsored scams to do so.

@molly0xfff Their very existence depends on a winning argument, whatever that may be.
@molly0xfff But it's completely correct. Unlike stocks, there are no dividends (at least in "ordinary" cryptocurrencies like BTC, LTC, BCH, etc.)
@molly0xfff YES! Beanie babies *are* the future of finance. That's what I've been saying all these years!
@molly0xfff Would it be legal to do a pyramid scheme / ponzi scheme, if I tell everyone that that's what I'm doing and I say it's actually gambling?

@nicemicro @molly0xfff

The #crypto in-plain-sight Kansas city shuffle.

It's an out-in-the-open (OITO) scam where the people you sell it to know it's an OITO scam, but these people expect to sell it themselves OITO to others, and those others plan to.......

Everyone relies on the recursive loop, but even infinite loops eventually fail.

OIW, it's not a #Ponzi scam, until the very last step, but it's OITO so even then there's deniability.

"I thought it would work, and so did everybody else."

@molly0xfff "harmless little toy" are your (sarcastic) words, and reveal something about you, not Coinbase.

@molly0xfff @slightlyoff What I'm understanding is that Beanie Babies need more regulation.

I still have my collection, 25 years later. Their time is soon neigh..

@molly0xfff It's like collectables! That we make! Except you never actually get the collectables! And we hold them and your money for you! And we promise to exchange them for the money! Except we cash ourselves out first and leave you holding the bag!

Just like collectables!