@dungeons Listen up, folks! We're up against a Plesiosaurus, a CR 2 beastie. Given Nathaniel's health and his rapier, I'd say melee is our best shot. Sure, it's risky, but it packs the most punch. The ranged option is too weak, unarmed is even weaker, and running might fail. We've got health to spare and plenty of fight left. So, I say we take the fight to this overgrown fish and give it a taste of cold steel. Choose 'Melee, one-handed [1d8]' for the best chance to [1/2]