In the US, hospitals are confident enough to print ‘39.95’ on the bill for holding your newborn

They are so sure about their system they don't mind explicitly spelling out that they charge $40 for literally handing over the baby and waiting for a few minutes

Because they don't even consider that absurd anymore

I got news for you.. it’s ABSURD!

@stux and then insurance companies, who I have no love for, push back and are like we’re not paying for all of this and the hospitals say “see how evil they are?!” It’s fun.
@stux Seems like hospitals are starting to bill like Lawyers. But instead of "billable hours" its "billable minutes" :)

@stux
As a nurse, I find the US healthcare system morally repugnant.
I could never work in a hospital in a country where this shit happens. Where people go bankrupt or are literally not treated if they don't have the money or correct insurance. Where machines are turned off because of money. Where they take your insurance details before treating you.

I think it's against the Hippocratic Oath.

@BintyMcFrazzles @stux it is obscene and just because the Americans go along with it doesn't make it right.
The Tories in the UK have been trying to force this on the nation since forever, they want us to suffer like the Americans do.
@Lazarou @BintyMcFrazzles @stux Pity ppl can't see what's going on!
@CableSt @Lazarou @BintyMcFrazzles @stux I've been using those in hospitals using NHS branding for a few years now and I was born here. The future you're worried about is already here for those of us with niche healthcare needs. ☹️

@zeska @CableSt @Lazarou @stux

If anyone with those machines or bills came to chat with my patient or their family about paying, I would firmly ask them to leave (the admin staff, not the patient, obvs).
I'm in charge of my patient's welfare.

@BintyMcFrazzles

I imagine the contract you've signed with the hospital is vastly different than those in the US.
@zeska @CableSt @Lazarou @stux

@stux are you sure this isn’t photshopped? I mean, this is too…. Absurd?

@jlapoutre

Nothing is too absurd in the US health care system. I was charged $200 for "physical therapy" that was really 15 minutes of some guy "teaching" me how to use crutches before I left the hospital after knee surgery.

@stux

@Catmama @jlapoutre @stux My insurance only covers the brand version of my thyroid meds, one of the most-prescribed medications. $128 for 3 months. Some would dream of that price (low for many drugs), but, buy it off-label and it's $18. You only know that if you have the equivalent of the nice and patient guy at Costco who helped me save $110.

@MHowell

I had a similar situation with one medication. It's all one big scam.

@jlapoutre @stux

@jlapoutre @stux It's not the first time or the first person I've seen such bills shared on social media. Multiple attestation.
Yes, Hospitals Actually Charge New Parents for Holding Their Babies

As a practicing OB-GYN physician in the Bay Area, I’m no stranger to the holistic birth movement. From being asked to cut the umbilical cord over a...

Slate

@jlapoutre @stux

EVERYTHING is absurd about the U.S. healthcare system. I've received enough hospital and doctor bills to attest to that. Meds that I already have, they wouldn't allow me to bring in even though I carry my weekly pillbox in my purse; not when they could charge me upwards of USD 1,000 for each day of the same pills... and that's just the beginning.

Triage in the ER can be a joke depending on who's doing it. I was sent to the back of the line in favor of treating a baby with diaper rash (people often use Emergency for Primary Care and I could hear them in the next cubicle) even though I had what turned out to be a potentially life-threatening condition. I'm not a cute little baby, but I needed emergency abdominal surgery, resulting in a humongous bill that I'm still paying for.

And yes, the billing manager is very often the first person you see. Show your insurance card, prove you can pay, or leave. 💰 🤬

@stux

I'm surprised they didn't give the baby an opium addiction to get them started in the USA healthcare system.

@jebba @stux That's what the educational system is for.

@stux At least illness isn't the #1 killer of children in the US!

(It's firearms... at least for ages 1-18. Followed by motor vehicles.)

@stux Bloody hell. Do they charge to hand the baby to the mother to be breast fed? Whatever next. Thank gawd I don’t live in the US. I’d be locked up for protesting about the insanity.
@Caledonia @stux isn't that ... the next line item on the bill?
@draNgNon @stux They consulted with the mother about breast feeding? Then charged her? Wouldn’t surprise me. (I hadn’t read the rest of the invoice).
@stux Whomever conceives of these charges are a bizarre and inhuman lot.

@stux

There must be more to it.

@stux OK, I looked into it. After a C-section, the mother is still drugged, and another nurse is brought into the room to supervise the holding so that nobody gets dropped.

Of course, health care should be provided for free here, like it is in other countries.

@rjblaskiewicz @stux there's a tiny bit more to it, but still absurd https://slate.com/human-interest/2016/10/hospitals-charge-new-parents-for-skin-to-skin-contact.html

In Sweden the cost of delivery (c-section or not) and staying a few days at the hospital costs about as much as just holding the kid in 'murica. For non citizens without permanent residence it might go up to the equivalent of $2k (unless there's serious complications – then it might reach ~$10k).

Yes, Hospitals Actually Charge New Parents for Holding Their Babies

As a practicing OB-GYN physician in the Bay Area, I’m no stranger to the holistic birth movement. From being asked to cut the umbilical cord over a...

Slate

@Mabande @stux

My uncle was hospitalized while vacationing in... I think it was Belgium. He paid out of pocket (or possibly his insurance paid the cost) but the bill was low and the hospital provided translators. Really a good experience, I mean except for being in the hospital. :) It makes sense that someone who does not pay into the system should not receive its full benefits, but he was so impressed by how little paperwork there was compared to here.

@Mabande @stux In the 1990s, I worked in my dad's office (OBGYN), and the cost of 9 months pregnancy and normal delivery was a flat $10,000.

@stux

This is the horrendous system #Starmer and every other Tory wants for Britain.

They are deliberately hobbling the #NHS so they can usher in their friends' companies and grow rich on the profits from a worse healthcare system that charges for things like HOLDING YOUR OWN NEWBORN CHILD.

fuck me

#ToriesOut #ProtectOurNHS

@stux It's near impossible to go to a US #hospital without a lawyer and an accountant by your side 24/7. I was charged 400.00 a day, for 4 days, for "hospitality". Ridiculous.

@stux

and the tory scum in the UK want to move Britain from its current free hospital service to something resembling the utterly appalling system that is current in the USA!

@stux Brings back horrible memories,asked for itemized bill,took several pages of the bill, and sat in billing department going line by line for over an hour (with crying baby). I didn't have any medication, the kid didn't have any oxygen. I didn't ask for any tissues, I'm not paying for that either.
@stux I’d be pissed at being charged for a “Lactation consultant”; also, and I can’t emphasize this enough, this is a rhetorical question, why is there a quantity of 2?
@real_jamescain lactation consultants are trained professionals who have to be paid for their work. The 2 is 2 consultant sessions. Because not everyone needs one it’s not folded into the non-itemized bill like floor nursing services are.
@amaditalks This message brought to you from Big Milk.
#rhetoricalquestion

@real_jamescain rhetorical questions asked in bad faith deserve and require the illumination of same provided by a legitimate answer.

Don’t mock crucial things you don’t understand and won’t ever apply to your life or wellbeing is a good rule to adopt.

@amaditalks Elucidation shouldn’t partner with condescension.
@real_jamescain you do not get to argue about the tone of your education when you could have kept your snarky nonsense to yourself to begin with.
@amaditalks I specifically said “and I can’t emphasize this enough, this is a rhetorical question”, and now you’re coming at me like the joke and tone police. I love how keeping your nonsense to yourself only flows in one direction.
@stux In Finland that whole thing would be 38.10 € in total (about 41 dollars). Without any absurd breakdowns like that.

@rolle @stux After C-section the mother is kept in hospital for few days. About 40€/day so it's more like 120-160€.

But that can include full upkeep (private room, three hot meals per day, snacks as much as needed, hot showers, baths to newborn, etc.) and all medical stuff needed (medications, lab tests, etc.) to the whole family: mother, newborn and father. Well, father might not get lab tests or nice drugs...

@stux For the low, low price of only $39.95, you too can hold the newborn that doctors have just surgically removed from you 🙄

Our for-profit medical system is out of control.

@stux we have a medical system where "guess I'll die" is normal
@stux That's bad, very bad.

my brain though is stuck on a loop truing to work out "Delivery C section, quantity 79"

That person had 79 C sections? 🫤

@stux

If anybody is wondering why right-wing governments in jurisdictions like Ontario, Alberta and the UK are trying so hard to privatise public healthcare, it's right here. ⬆️

A goldmine for their funders.

@stux

Greatest country on earth. 😏

@stux alright I hate to be a reply guy but as the father of two c-section babies I feel like I can explain this a bit.

People who have c-sections are heavily medicated through the procedure. My wife could barely stay awake through all of it, both times.

Skin-to-skin after a c-section means that the nurses have to stay with mama to basically ensure the baby isn't dropped by a mother that passes out. It also means staff has to stay in the OR longer. So it actually costs quite a lot.

@rodhilton @stux

There are other solutions for this. I had a c-section in Austria. The nurses did not stay with me, I was simply provided with a bassinet and told that I should NOT carry the baby myself.

Also the entire cost was... zero. Giving birth is free in Austria, even if you don't have health insurance (which is rare). If we can do it, other rich countries can do the same. Giving birth should be free, it's hard enough as it is, and it's in the public interest. It should be paid for by all tax payers.

@Mab_813 @stux Not carry the baby where? You can't even stand up after a c-section. That sounds more like what mothers are told in the days after a c-section, not the first few seconds after delivery which is when skin-to-skin contact happens, in the operating room.

@rodhilton

You don't need to explain c-sections to me - as I wrote, I had one myself. Charging extra for what, some minutes at best, of skin-to-skin contact in the OP is completely and utterly absurd. There is really no excuse for this absurdity and other countries have figured it out.

@stux Apparently they need an extra nurse for safety reasons. Because they think the woman is going to be standing up after the C-section, and the anaesthetics give a good chance of dropping the baby.

At least they're transparent about that line. The bill still has a large quantity of generic levels 1 and 3.

@arem the extra nurse is not for safety reasons because they think someone who’s just had major open abdominal surgery is going to stand up. The extra nurse is there because someone who understands sterile field procedure is needed to handle the baby and get it to the father or partner.
@stux
$40 bucks? Naw, we good. You can hold it.
@stux "It's...some *bullshit*" as they might have said on The Wire.
@stux US health care is crazy.

@stux I sympathise, I really do. The US is a great country, which I lived in for years, but putting a price on holding your baby is what’s wrong with the healthcare model.

Meanwhile, in the UK, the bill for the entire process from the hospital, is £0 (that’s $0 at today’s exchange rate).

It’s also the reason why there’ll never be a British re-make of Breaking Bad!

@stux

For US$85 I can use a #Shovel for that...

I'll even #Supply #MyOwnShovel...

🧙⚔️🤖🐺🤖⚔️🧙 | ☕️🍪🍫🦄🍫🍪☕

@stux I'm more willing to die than to live a life where they might charge me for breathing if I go to the hospital. I don't care if it's an easily fixable issue, I would rather die than feed another cent into the US healthcare system