Apparently the all-knowing Bluesky knows what's best for everybody and everything, and I have no right to criticize because I'm not making anything as cool and amazing as AT protocol.

These Bluesky Kool-Aid drinkers are too much.

I dislike fanboyism.

I hated when Apple fanboys defended that incredibly awful butterfly keyboard.

I hated when Tesla fanboys dogpiled whenever questions the self-driving capabilities.

I hate it when someone claims the amazing Bluesky team is the arbiter of what makes for a good decentralized protocol.

Hell, I can't even stand it when Mastodon fanboys tell me that everything on the Fediverse should depend on Mastodon because it's "the standard".
“This is the coolest thing ever.” Ugh! Try harder.
@atomicpoet
Beholden to none. How about people just not be fanbois or fangirls of anything. It never ends well in this fallible world of imperfect humans.

@atomicpoet “I hated when Apple fanboys defended that incredibly awful butterfly keyboard.”

People defended that?

In the Apple fanboy media/blog/podcast ecosystem, at least, what felt like hundreds of hours were cumulatively spent excoriating Apple for it. They seemed pretty universally reviled or — at best — tolerated.

I’m arguably fanboy-adjacent and, honestly, those keyboards were awful.

@jeff There's Apple fans who know when the company goes wrong.

And then there's fanboys for which any criticism is seen as an attack on Apple. Boy, have I met quite a few of them in real life.

@atomicpoet Oh, yes, they certainly exist. That is for certain.

I may just be lucky, having not seen many defend the butterfly keyboard specifically. I’d just assumed it was so bad that even the fanboys could manage no better than silence. Looks like I was just lucky.

Not many plausible arguments in favor of a keyboard that frequently fails to type.

@atomicpoet isn't bluesky centralized?

"For now, Bluesky has set up one main server that everyone is on, but in the future, people will be able to customize their own algorithms and feeds using Bluesky’s underlying technology."

When it transitions into a decentralized platform then it should be called that, but not a moment sooner

https://www.vox.com/technology/2023/4/29/23702979/bluesky-twitter-elon-musk-jack-dorsey-chrissy-teigen-aoc-dril-decentralized

Bluesky, the Twitter replacement that AOC and Chrissy Teigen just joined, explained

The invite-only, decentralized new social network.

Vox
@Sean Right now, it is centralized until it federates.
@[email protected] will I have to implement ap in this hellhole of mine? who knows

@atomicpoet Seriously, #BlueSky is just trash and I hope they'll face the same #ForeseeableConsequences as all the hategroomers on #Gab, #Poast and other trash instances:

Universal Defederation!

@atomicpoet They aren't really building anything tho aren't they? Isn't it just really walled garden social media nonsense with an option to federated? Seems just like a simpering copy of something that will ultimately take over and leave them irrelevant.
This is an attitude problem. Everyone of these techies seem to claim only they know everything about everyone, and only they are the omniscient subspecies of humans. I haven’t got an access to Bluesky (not that it matters), but if these people were to come over and check out Calckey.social for instance, they could learn a thing or two about design and administration of a decentralised application, but it may be too much of an ask, 🙂
Firefish Social

Welcome to Firefish, a federated, decentralized, privacy respecting, free to use, and fun social media!

Firefish Social
@atomicpoet
This is all going sideways faster than elon broke twitter

@atomicpoet

That's how we do it.

hXXps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QADa13NoNtg

@atomicpoet It's churlish to judge software based on the users, but some days it's a challenge not to.

I am optimistic about Bluesky, and in many ways we SHOULD be on the same side, promoting a non-centralized social web. Which one wins is immaterial, if they can live up to that promise.

That promise has yet to be manifested, though. Have TWO nodes, at least. They haven't earned their stripes until they demonstrate federation, and not before I can personally spin up an instance.