This is another example of what I mean when I say you should not be as concerned about Nazis and fascists, as you are about the white folk you have around you when the Nazis and fascists show up. DeSantis says European history is OK for Florida students, but Black history is verboten, and this is the response? To neuter the course until it's acceptable to racists?

https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/ap-african-american-studies-course-rejected-florida-undergo-revision-c-rcna67327

The college board's crime is greater than DeSantis'. A racist system cannot effectively educate Black kids.

AP African American Studies course rejected by Florida to be revised, College Board says

The College Board said it would release a new framework for the Advanced Placement course in African American Studies blocked by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis.

NBC News

But then when the fascists come for women's reproductive rights, these people will beg the very same Black people that their system has miseducated to "stay in line!" And "vote like our lives depend on it!" because "democracy is on the ballot!"

This one-way solidarity is getting old.

@mekkaokereke i feel like world war 2 taught us that shooting fascists is more effective than voting
@ariadne @mekkaokereke It's not either/or, though. We can vote AND punch Nazis.

@mekkaokereke amen!
They’re always a catch…
Especially, w/ ā€œRich, white, racist, Christian Nationalistsā€.
Which as it regards…Gov. Deā˜ ļøSantis…

If it looks like a ā€œšŸ¦†ā€ā€¦

@mekkaokereke This is what MLK was talking about in his letter from Birmingham jail, why white moderates could be even worse than the open racists.

@mekkaokereke

Someone tell the jerk DeSantis that all his racists comments will always be on You Tube.

@mekkaokereke
I continue to be stunned the first impulse orgs have is to roll over when an ignorant fascist opens his mouth.

Also, where are the civil rights lawyers on this? Telling black kids African american history has no educational value HAS to be discriminatory under title vi, right??

@DeliaChristina @mekkaokereke
Ben Crump is on the case…
As I believe, is the NAACP
@DeliaChristina @mekkaokereke fuck, telling white kids the same just purpetuates the problem. Wish I'd had more of a critical mindset and questioned things as a kid. The fact that I needed an HBO series (Watchmen) to even *discover* history I was never taught makes me ill. I honestly was "wait‽ What‽" and had to look it up. It was never covered in 16 years of schooling, and that's atrocious.
@DeliaChristina @mekkaokereke Suits filed by the ACLU and other civil rights lawyers (the first one was filed minutes after it was passed and tried to block it before it even came into effect) have gotten it blocked in companies and colleges, but failed to get it blocked in k-12 schools. I think that trial is in April, well before the AP could even change the course, which means the AP is being unnecessarily evil by announcing the changes already.
@mekkaokereke absolutely disgusting. I don't know what more to say. I could go on about my ancestry being all northern US and Canada, but... It doesn't matter. Just... It disgusts me to not teach/learn about how horrible history actually *is*, and how complicit so many people throughout have been. Tritely, those who don't know the past are doomed to repeat it. And I don't want to repeat it.
@mekkaokereke A racist system cannot effectively educate ANY kids, but not all of them will be discomfited by this fact. šŸ˜”

@mekkaokereke And also, now DeSantis is damaging more than his own state.

Took until about the 20th paragraph to try to guess what they are changing , too. Really badly written article.

ā€œexpected the removal of content about topics "that violate our laws," including critical race theory, Black queer studies and intersectionality.’

@mekkaokereke

i would argue that DeSantis is both a Nazi and a fascist, but i have long argued that the Trumps and DeSantis of the world are not the problem, its the folks who vote for them, our good upstanding white Christian neighbors

@mekkaokereke They're going to compromise the course materials, but Florida still isn't going to accept the course.
@mekkaokereke I'd modify that to say a racist system cannot effectively educate ANY kids. The victims of racism don't need the education nearly as much those who perpetuate and reinforce white supremacy. Black History, civil rights history should be REQUIRED, not just an elective AP course.
@mekkaokereke The College Board should be opening an online version of the course up for any student, and offering the exam free of charge. How do we get that to happen?

@mekkaokereke Exactly. And, White Americans who hate what he is doing can’t simply hit the favorite or like or share buttons on social media and expect no onus to rest on their shoulders. A lack of action & spoken words is a green light for him and his racially & religiously bigoted base.

Also, he’s an Ivy League educated revisionist. With his legal knowledge & crooked maneuvers + the backing of the CNP’s Federalist Society, he’ll revise European History, too. https://masto.ai/@JennaWright/109718323578693732

Jenna Wright (@[email protected])

@[email protected] @[email protected] No doubt that he’ll reframe the Holocaust and require it taught as he chooses, like how he taught as he wanted on the Civil War, which was that it was not about slavery, rather, it was about 2 competing economic systems. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/05/us/desantis-high-school-teacher-georgia.html

Mastodon

@mekkaokereke Hold up, I can't have read this right. Florida bans teaching how gender, race, class, and sex bigotry join up to form SuperBigotry. It extra special bans teaching queer racism. It bans "Critical Race Theory" which it defines as "anything that makes white folk look or feel bad." And the AP's response is to take those things out of the African American Studies test nationwide??? My kids in California learn that stuff in their AP AAS class. I super duper want them to learn that stuff. They are in the tiniest intersectional "minority" in their high school: blue-eyed, blonde-haired CisHet (at least one of them - the younger is mum about that) males. They know they play the game of life on easy mode, and want to learn what the other 99% of the school deals with.

And it's not like DeSantis will stop with this class. AP World History and American History have that stuff too, and even more stuff banned by Don't Say Gay. He'll ban those next. He'll ban AP Comp Sci for talking about how Turing died.

@mekkaokereke Not saying we should fight to save AP African American Studies to stop a racist Domino effect. We should fight to save AP African American Studies because it is the right thing to do. We should fight for reproductive rights because it's the right thing to do. And trans rights. And workers' rights. MLK fought to end poverty and plutocracy alongside racism. Solidarity for all those oppressed is the only way we win.

And voting for the Democrat at every level in every general election is part of that. I was pissed Biden won the primaries in 2020. I was pissed that when asked to pick a female VP, he picked the one who spent her career shielding killer cops, opposing legal pot, pushing a law that sent parents to jail if their kid skipped school, and trying to keep men in jail even if they were later found innocent. But I sure as hell worked to get him elected in November, and I'll do it again in 2024. And for Harris in 2028 if she's the candidate. But I'll work even harder against her in the primary.

@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke So, using a fascist right wing attack on Black people as a jumping board to vilify and attack one of the few Black women in a position of power.
@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke it's literally just the same old culture war playbook that's been used to deprive students the opportunity to learn since the daughters of the Confederacy wanted to control high school textbooks & probably before that.
@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke The new AP CS, CSP, actually specifically includes the topic of bias in ML, so I wrote articles about it for my Khan Academy CSP content, and very quickly got negative feedback in the comments about why I brought race/gender in. So yeah, he would have a lot of reasons (in his head!) to ban it. I wish we could ban him, we need this content everywhere.

@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke

we also need to talk about how AP courses are a financial racket

Many elite colleges don’t accept the credit but anxious parents still pay because of the perception you can buy your child upward mobility with these courses while defunding public education

@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke someone really needs to give Ron DeSantis the Mussolini treatment.
@karstenbondy @mekkaokereke it'll also effectively kill the course, since no uni would accept it for credit anymore. Collegeboard just showing it's values

@mekkaokereke It's nauseating we need to have this discussion; but since we do, can we please have some pushback from officials elsewhere saying they will not allow *any* of the College Board's AP History classes *at all* if the curriculum is altered to make white supremacists feel better?

I'm sorry students end up as pawns in this (like so much else), but the line needs to drawn here and now.

@mekkaokereke I can’t believe they are caving. 😳

@mekkaokereke Mighty DeSantis...

I recall a scene some time ago when DeSantis bullied high school kids in the stage behind him, pointing fingers at them and complaining because they were wearing masks. Terrified the kids. If one of those were my kid, I would have invited DeSantis to point that finger at my face. And then we would see how it would go.

@mekkaokereke While it doesn't look encouraging, I'll wait to see what College Board's actual changes are before concluding they are trying to appease DeSantis.

Florida will never accept any African American Studies course anyway, and I would think that College Board understands this as well as all of the rest of us do.

@forrcaho You can wait if you want.

The college board was asked point blank if they were making changes to appease DeSantis' hate based requests. They gave other statements, but gave "no comment" on that question.

The correct answer is, "No. We do not change our AP materials to appeal to attempts to hide either Black history, or the history of queer rights in America, at the behest of a vocal minority. We hope for the sake of the students in Florida, that the governor changes his mind."

@forrcaho cont'd "But in the meantime, students in the other US States and territories will receive the best course material that the educators and curriculum developers at the College Board can provide."

@mekkaokereke You make a very good point, but the headline is needlessly incendiary, and doesn't seem to reflect what's actually going on.

From https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/about-ap/how-ap-develops-courses-and-exams/pilot-ap-african-american-studies it's clear that this was a pilot project and the announcement it's being "revised" comes at exactly the time the material was scheduled to be revised based on the pilot program feedback.

Some poor spokesperson may have been caught out by a question and didn't feel authorized to make a statement with political repercussions.

Pilot – African American Studies

AP African American Studies is in development and being piloted in select U.S. high schools through 2024. 

@forrcaho

Unfortunately no, it's a deeper conversation, and one that has been going on for a very long time. Decades.

Texas used to be the battleground, but now Florida man has taken the lead.

https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/college-board-warns-against-censoring-its-ap-courses-for-college-bound-students/2022/03

College Board Warns Against Censoring Its AP Courses

The organization that runs AP courses reminds teachers of its principles, as more states pass anti-critical race theory laws.

Education Week

@forrcaho

Forrest, I'm not upset at you, but I am going to point out a dynamic that upsets Black folk, so that you can be aware of it and decide whether you want to do it again in future.

1: Black person points out systemic racism
2: White person says, "Let's wait for all the facts to come out."
3: All the facts come out, and it's exactly as racist as the Black person said.
4: The white person says nothing. Silence.

@forrcaho

All the facts have now come out. It's as bad as we said it would be. And silence. I waited a day.

https://www.npr.org/2023/02/01/1153364556/ap-african-american-studies-black-history-florida-desantis

Florida students will not learn about Black Lives Matter, the largest civil rights protest in US history. Reparations is out.

If I hadn't prompted with this reply I doubt that you would have replied to say anything.

If you're not willing to make the effort to come back and do step 4, consider not saying anything in step 2? Don't make Black folk ask you for it.

@forrcaho

And now, they've finally made the statement similar to the one that I said they should have made at the start. QED.

https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/12/college-board-desantis-african-american-studies-00082447

I'll take "late arrival" over "no arrival." They got there eventually, so that's not nothing? šŸ‘šŸæ

But their curriculum still omits the important material, so it's still hot garbage. It's close to educational malpractice.

If they really wanted to make a great course, they could include a chapter on the conversation around the curriculum itself!🤯

The College Board slams DeSantis administration comments on African American studies

The new statement is the latest in a tense battle over who is responsible for the outcome of the new framework for the course.

POLITICO

@mekkaokereke Thanks for the update. That doesn't sound too much different from College Board's initial response to the NYT (http://web.archive.org/web/20230207203944/https://allaccess.collegeboard.org/how-new-york-times-got-it-wrong-ap-african-american-studies) but it sounds like Florida D of E has been crowing about their "victory" so they had to make a more forceful public statement.

As far as the content, I rather liked this op-ed (https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2023-02-02/ap-african-american-studies-florida-critical-race-theory) as it doesn't make any assumptions about College Board's motives. (I can't access that link now; I guess I've read my quota).

How the New York Times Got it Wrong on AP African American Studies – All Access | College Board

@mekkaokereke DeSantis is a deplorable fascist autocrat. He will never be POTUS bc he is patently unfit.

@Elmore1839

Every state that went for Trump in 2020 is likely to go for DeSantis in 2024. None of those are likely to flip. All DeSantis needs to do to win the presidency, is flip one of Georgia, Arizona, Wisconsin, or Michigan.

And again, everyone is looking at polls, and no one is looking at the significantly racist changes to election laws and certification process in those states that have already passed.

If in 2024, everyone tries to vote *exactly* as they did in 2020, DeSantis wins.

@mekkaokereke you'd be implying that there's a meaningful distinction to be drawn here, and I don't see one. Behind every loud Nazis are ten quiet ones.
@mekkaokereke Don't even bother with the tweaking. If the State of Florida is going to insist on teaching inaccuracy, it should be sued and prevented from teaching any history content until it has been verified as factually accurate. And those evaluations should be done by the State of California....
@mekkaokereke @JenX Desantis’ power is cut in half if he didn’t have people like this college board to implement his agenda. What’s the saying? ā€œIt’s not those that commit evil but those who sit idly by.ā€ This board is doing more than just observing though. Hope they get the shit sued out of them too

@mekkaokereke DeSantis is also going after Rocky Hanna, the superintendent of schools for Tallahassee, FL’s state capital, IOW DeSantis’s ā€˜home’ town. That’s not so important in the grand scheme of things, but it’s a potent way to make sure everyone in the FL state govt ā€˜gets the memo’ that showing any ambivalence about his policies will puts people at risk.

https://wusfnews.wusf.usf.edu/education/2023-01-27/florida-department-of-education-investigating-leon-county-superintendent-rocky-hanna

In the State U System of FL system (UF, FSU, etc) he’s gotten pushback from the leadership — not an outright refusal, which would be illegal, but more of a letter-of-the-law / work-to-rule approach. I’ve heard/seen scuttlebutt suggesting that, at least in some cases, his admin is trying to route around central admin leaders and approaching department heads directly for info. If so, that too will be effective because they’re, as faculty, they’re more vulnerable and more inclined frame their decisions in terms protecting their depts.

Leon County Superintendent Rocky Hanna is under investigation by the Florida Department of Education

Of the 12 Florida school districts that defied Gov. Ron DeSantis' ban on local mask mandates, only five have their original superintendents.

WUSF

@mekkaokereke

But that’s the opposite of his position.

Whether a person agrees with the argument or not, his stances is that some of the material in the course is obscuring Black history by spending course time and resources focusing on other issues like LGBTQ+ interests. He has pushed the College Board to revise the course to focus more solidly on the history of Black communities in the US.

You might reply that LGBTQ+ is part of Black history, and that’s fair, but it’s important to recognize that DeSantis is actually arguing. Not against Black history but against a course that he believes is insufficiently focused on exactly that.