Please only respond if you identify as trans, thank you

"I am trans and..."

(Edit: removed boost request as poll is closed)

I love drag
15.5%
I'm ambivalent about drag
33.7%
I hate drag
10.9%
I have a complex relationship with drag
20.3%
Spiderman
19.6%
Poll ended at .
@aendra I find drag shows really triggering because they turn aspects of the way I look every day into a spectacle.
@aendra that said.. I don't think they should go away. I just don't want to go to them myself.

@aendra ...I/we really don't know enough about drag to be able to participate in the conversation.

- Packbats 🎒

@aendra do this poll again just for trans femmes tbh.

Personally I fucking hate it.

@aendra @aral I’m not trans, but I love Spiderman!
@bitbear Hey man, she literally said “please only respond if you identify as trans.” Not cool. If you want to help amplify it, please boost without replying.
@aral Sorry, but I didn’t actually vote. Boosted of course.
@aendra I'm cis (did not vote) and new to the platform; what is the implication of like 100 shares and no likes?
@aendra I don't have an issue with drag, I have an issue with cis people who equate performance with identity
@aendra boosted as I can’t answer this question

@aendra I'm trans and kinda mixed, I'm not a big fan of drag myself but I do know that I'm also not a fan of policing identities nor keeping up the "stay within the norm" fashion.

It really depends on how a person in drag acts and treats others, like if they're openly homophobic or transphobic then yea that's bad but most do it to support LGBTQ+ identity and I know there exists genderfluid people that do drag

@aendra I answered Ambivalent. And it's probably the most positive about it I've ever been. I used to think of it as basically our black and white minstrel show. In some hands it's used like that, as a weapon of ridicule.

but what we're probably thinking of now when we think of drag acts, and those story hours, etc... there's something else going on that's more positive, perhaps a reaching for a different way to be male. birds of paradise shining in the gloom of the forest floor.

@aendra I think drag is neat and also I'm glad it exists for people regardless of gender to use as a way to explore their relationship with gender.

@aendra I'm ambivalent about it. I think when I first came out I didn't like it, for some reasons that in retrospect I think were misguided.

These days, it's still not really my thing, but any and all breaking of gender norms is good imo, and has my unconditional support. Not to mention, lots of people who do drag are themselves also trans; there's some significant overlap in our communities, and the drag performers I've met are all really cool.

@aendra the histories of both are intertwined. likewise, the existence of high-profile transphobic drag artists parallels the existence of high-profile transphobic trans people. the great ones are the ones you don't see on TV, they're the ones using their performances in the pursuit of social justice

@aendra Trans people being upset about drag doesn't make sense to me.

Outside of internalized transphobia, I can't see why any trans person thinks that drag performers are stepping on their toes in any way.

No one owns masculinity, femininity, or any form of self expression. With respect to my own experience, I wear shorts, t-shirts and never wear makeup. How are drag queens at all making a mockery of me when trans women are as diverse as cis women in appearance, personality, experiences?

@aendra Is this "I hate drag on me" or "I hate drag on others" because I don't care what others do but I feel like drag on me is–

Oh nevermind, I'll just check "I have a complex relationship…"

@aendra to be fair, drag was by and for queer black people originally so i don't really care that much about what white people have to say about it because they are relatively new to the art form
@aendra Might be generational or regional, but every one of the (admitedly small number of) drag artists I've seen or met have been mysoginistic, transphobic and biphobic. They were also all gay, cis, white men.
This was some years ago, so hopefully things have improved a bit.

@aendra There was this awesome tumblr post by sexualbolshevism:

when a trans woman says they hate drag they're probably not talking about the history of it as an opportunity for trans women, especially twoc, to publicly celebrate their femininity. they're talking about white cis misogynist men wearing us like a halloween costume and spitting on our heritage and getting praised by cis liberals for being "progressive"

That's why I'm ambivalent about it.

@aendra i have to vote for spider-man every time to me he’s always gonna win

I'm ambivalent but probably should've chosen complex...

I don't really care for Paegents or how Drag has become debased through mainstream consciousness and for the reasons similar to @rhonda

That being said I fucking love the Ballroom scene

@Bubastis Oh holy fucking yes on ballroom. <3

Funnily, I'm participating at an All Queer Art event in two days, which contains a lot of drag. The initiative came from friend who is a drag king, and they invited me to participate with a poetry text of mine. I hope to get a little bit of glitter on my face backstage at least, so ... yay. :D

@aendra I could not stand, that when I came out publicly as trans, everyone seemed to be lined up telling me we should go to a drag show. None of them understood that being trans and drag were a completely different thing.
@aendra my main issue with drag is what you said in another comment. It is used by allies to check the trans inclusiveness box... I'm not a man in a dress....
@aendra I don’t really know how to feel in general..
I don’t think drag artists are out to get me, yet it still makes me feel.. dysphoric? I’m not sure. I don’t want the general population and cis people seeing drag and thinking “trans”.
That’s about how I feel I guess?
@aendra I love drag although I must admit I never have been to a drag show in person although I live in Berlin but seeing drag artists on Instagram twitch or YouTube has really helped me see what is possible expression wise
Because of drag I even used face paint on myself as a visually impaired and physically disabled person a few times at home because I have seen so many wilfully freaky make up styles that I thought it doesn’t matter if I am not able to draw straight lines and stuff
I wish I could learn how to be a drag performer but I’m afraid people in workshops could be ableist or don’t have the time to explain things a bit more detailed or show me things #drag #disabled
@aendra I can't vote, but you're welcome to the boost.

@aendra

In short:
- I don't have anything against drag
- I think the drag scene have been an ally to trans people, and contained/contains some trans people too, but I'm not really good at history, this leads me to have a positive feeling towards drag
- I'm not personally interested by drag
- I hate that the transphobic society mixes up drag and transidentity, and use the hate for each one to hate on the other
- That drag=trans feeling was even more present in the past, and was all I could see when I was young, so in my head it was like that too. Only way later I discovered what transidentity really is and that I could, in fact, be a woman as I wished I was. I have a small irrational resentment towards drag for that but rationally I know that the society is at fault, not drag.
- I feel like mainstream drag shows like Ru Paul's kinda perpetuate that drag=trans feeling, or at least spread some disinformation about trans people, I'm not sure because I never watched them, but I have a somewhat negative opinion/prejudice of them

I answered "complex relationship", overall it would be a rather positive feeling, but I have negative feelings about drag but that are not really the fault of drag itself.

@aendra Having seen most of the public eventually come to figure out the difference between drag and trans, and see the haters hate anyhow, plus having drag queens be, like, really nice to me when I really needed it, on top of doing my makeup for my glamour shoots in the 90s, plus carving out the strange pageant system that was a safe haven for trans folks in the 90s as well, it's hard for me not to be really partial to the people even if I don't often frequent the art form. ❤
@aendra I think it is problematic. I notice after the latest shooting incidence there was mainstream confusion about if woman was a trans woman or drag artist. I don’t think there’s any confusion on our side of fence, but plenty on the other side…
@aendra Drag is not my aesthetic nor genre of humor but I don't care what others do in their spare time. I think claiming that it harms the community is respectability politics and should be rejected. If drag shows didn't exist, they would make other excuses to genocide us. For reference, I am a gay trans dude who has been to plenty of shows.
@aendra I’m straight female and I love drag. It’s an art form.

@aendra i have yet to meet a cis drag performer who wasn't extremely transphobic

and plenty who were and who were very often elevated by the cis gay community

@aendra Wasn't sure what to put, so I went with complex.

I'm neither enamored with it, nor hate it. It's art. I know there are trans people who have done drag (or still do), found support, or figured themselves out as a result. In the wider queer community, I think people usually know that. In the wider world, the complexity of stage performance vs identity can get lost.

I want unity, & mutual support across the board. I also want people in & out of the community seen as who they are.

@aendra my mom loved drag, she is super into musical theater and showtunes so she went to a lot of shows with those themes. I've never been into it but I think it's a cool art form :)

I'm not sure if visual-kei crossdressing or glamrock count too or if that's outside the specific culture

@aendra you be you and live your best life.
@aendra fwiw you can simply say "if you are trans", the "identify as" wording isn't doing any work
@aendra I accept people earn a living from drag. It’s not my thing. My life and drag queens do not intersect.
@aendra I don't really have any particularly strong feelings about drag either way, but that's not an option on the poll so I'm saying it here
@aendra I do feel very strange about the connection people are making between men doing drag and trans women. I feel like it's an intentional connection that is made by conservatives. Do trans people hang out with drag queens? Sure, mainly because LGBT+ positive spaces are the few safe spaces for trans people. Are they similar? Eh, not really. I'm ambivalent to drag. I won't argue about its validity as an art form or fun activity but I also don't relate it to my experience in any way.
@aendra It's not my thing but I'm not opposed to other people enjoying drag if it's their thing, so that rules out "I like it" and "I hate it." I have no real opinion about drag, so I went with Spiderman.

@aendra I chose "hate" as the closest answer but that doesn't mean I think there's anything objectionable about it*. It makes me uncomfortable but that's a "me" issue. I'm 100% in support of drag artists doing their thing, and I appreciate the long history of drag queens fighting for both gay and trans rights.

* Not as a rule at least.

@aendra d'oh, and drag kings of course.
@aendra is it done primarily for a cis audience? if so, I probably hate it
@aendra i responded before I read. I saw spiderman so I clicked spiderman, I am not trans, please dont report me to spiderman
@aendra Shame there isn't a result button :( I'd love to see the votes
@aendra I can respect the origins of drag performance, but the way it's often the main thing at very big queer events these days makes me super-uncomfortable as an (intentionally) un-feminine trans woman. I feel like we just barely escaped the horrible era of the 90s-00s where cis people often believed trans women were cis men merely putting on a skillful performance.
@aendra aaaaargh! Why did you make such a fun pop-quiz!!! So tempted to answer… but I will not… I understand the rules! Also… please share results when vote is over! 🫣

@aendra
Not trans so not voting, but just wanted to say that I'm married to a lovely trans person.

Love is love!
@ItIsRosie

@aendra "drag" could mean all sorts of things. within one show each performer can be different. And it's easy to misinterpret what someone is expressing.

Here's a video about Lengger Lanang, in Indonesia.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c2Ry8oZT5Qg&t=141s

Lelaki Ayu Primadona Jawa: Lengger Lanang

YouTube