My experience so far here is not terribly different from Twitter, to be honest. I'm here because most of the people I care about moved. But a substantial fraction of my mentions are people interpreting my every word as uncharitably as possible and telling me what an awful person I must be.

When blocking them gets too exhausting, I'll probably just drop off, and you'll have to tell me how awful I am via email or USPS. In person by appointment only,

It's entirely possible this is happening because, in fact, I'm really awful, and people are simply reacting to my awfulness. In which case, I'm sorry I'm ruining this place for you, and I'll try to do better.

But really, I think it's scale. At peak, I had about 90K followers on Twitter. Here I already have about 12.5K. At that scale, people want you to fit their expectations.

That said, the Nazis and election crazies aren't here (yet), and that's really nice.

Just to be clear: While I appreciate your support (*blush*), I know that there are people who enjoy what I have to say - and I enjoy interacting with you, too! And I also have friends in real life.

I'm just trying to explain what the experience here looks like from my end, and the ways it's a bit broken for me.

@mattblaze

I don’t think that it’s bad that there’s a tension between “what was” and the expectations of the influx of new users. This is how things evolve.

One can’t want an existing open, federated social media experience to win out against closed systems without answering the question “if network effects draw more people here, what does that mean?”

Time will tell.

@bplein @mattblaze A somewhat relevant factoid may be that 'tone policing' is specifically against the CoCs of some of the servers I've checked (at semi-random, based on Matt's interactions with the tone police depts here). And Matt, for the record and as a positive marker, I appreciate both your thoughtfulness and snark.

@mattblaze Well I always appreciate what you have to say.

Mastodon feels like a fleet of vast empty spaceships that millions of people fled to from a war-torn planet. The ships are apparently running on automatic but nobody’s managed to get into the ships’ respective bridges yet to find out for sure. So we just walk around like dazed refugees, trying to figure out who’s here, communicating with people on other ships, looking for things to do, and wondering where we’re all headed.

@mattblaze Glad that you are here Matt. Now if I could just convince HotelZuluLima to come here too...

@mattblaze If and when they do, start tap dancing on the report button. It'll get taken care of.

More folks have your back around here than you might think.

@mattblaze I've really been enjoying your posts here. I hope those jerks don't scare you off.

@mattblaze I think the main benefit with Mastodon is that a lot of the crazies will find themselves on their own individual crazy islands as admins of instances block them/remove them.

Sure, some will still make it in, and you can't scrub the world clean of nut cases but in the long run I feel like Mastodon will be an easier platform to avoid a lot of that type of stuff.

@RRaven85 I think I'm optimistic that that will mostly happen.

@mattblaze I am just glad that Mastodon currently feels... quieter than Twitter has especially over the last few years.

Who knows what will happen if/when the crazies finally start coming over here because their favorite punching bags left their swamp. But yeah at that point I think having a good admin team will be big for sure.

@mattblaze

I almost hit 'unfollow' after you sent me down the rabbit hole of "prominent locksmiths"

Like, are there banquets with awards and stuff?

(You're giving me flashbacks to interviewing the 'escape artist' side of Randi's life.)

@kims They do, and I almost got beaten up at one. Fear and Locksmithing in Las Vegas.
@mattblaze I think it’s more a status thing — someone (usually male) wants to increase their status by taking on a perceived silverback. It’s stupid, but I see it happen all the time to my well-known friends.
@mattblaze you're mostly not awful IMHO. I like getting your perspectives on topics I care about, photography, and radio nerditry.
@mattblaze well, if you have an audience big enough, you'll ever find someone willing to fight you, I guess
@mattblaze I don't know you or what you talk about, but yeah, scale is a factor. But more than that, if you have 90k followers, then you are obviously saying something interesting. And in social media, interesting often means you have a strong opinion on something controversial or polarized. So it follows that a lot of people probably love you and a bunch more probably hate you.

@mattblaze
Scale is huge. Let's say only 0.1% of people are the sort to have this kind of knee-jerk uncharitable take. If you have 1000 followers, that means you'll have one comment along those lines for every post. If you have 10K, that means ten. Ten negative and unfair comments on every post is A LOT, even if they're mixed with many decent ones. Humans weight negative experiences much more highly in memory and emotional reaction. Ten is enough to feel like you're constantly being piled on and everyone is against you.

Unless you actively cull and prune followers to get that down to 0.01% or less -- which is a lot of work with rapidly diminishing returns -- this is gonna happen. It's not the platform so much as it's just the scale.

It's why I never want to have that many followers. On twitter I was at nearly 6K and it was beginning to feel uncomfortable. Glad to be back around 1K here.

@mattblaze no mate, it’s not you, I’m extremely uncomfortable with Mastodons business model.
Peoples thoughts are their own & we should all be treated as adults.
If people don’t like it they are free to move on.
This Mastodon predilection for protecting an unknown demographic from bad words is the extreme opposite from Elons let her rip & promoting of fascism.
Where’s the rational middle ground🤷
@mattblaze oh, they are. It's just the loudest and angriest tend to land on servers that have been defederated, and should be fairly quickly kicked from federated instances if they start making trouble. There's a fairly large defederated chunk of the #Fediverse which has plenty of them.
@mattblaze My expectations are that you will post things that you want to post. Please continue. If people don't like what you post, they should just not follow you. Or block you. Or maybe that would just be too simple. 🤷
@mattblaze I’m sorry that everything is so shitty.
@kataclyst Perhaps if I were less awful it wold be.
@mattblaze Naw. It’s clearly not you.
@mattblaze smoke signals. We should just go back to those. Federation and gossip protocols built in.
@ben @mattblaze No way. Someone would propose voting by smoke signals and then blame Russian wind for the election results.
@mattblaze I never used Twitter but I've been enjoying following you here. I hope they don't run you off. Gotta find some way to just ignore them I guess, it's not like anyone else takes them that seriously outside maybe this site.
@pell Block block block. And more block!

@mattblaze I hate that any of us have to go through this sort of thing.

I do gotta say though, my horrible brain read that last sentence and instantly thought "Some peoples hatred of Matt might one day ensure the USPS stays relevant once Amazon stops using them"

@RRaven85 Hey, I'm good for something at least!
@mattblaze Well that’s disappointing. Hope it gets better for you here.
@mattblaze where’s the calendly link?
@mattblaze also, I’m joking. Sorry you’re targeted with this sort of nonsense
@mattblaze not everyone here feels that you are an awful person.
@spacerog @mattblaze agreed. He is at least "pretty okay-ish" in my books.
@mattblaze @DaveMWilburn @spacerog acceptable human material, certainly
@hacks4pancakes @DaveMWilburn @spacerog Even that's a stretch for me.
@mattblaze @hacks4pancakes @DaveMWilburn @spacerog Would "reasonably decent" or "reasonably okay" be acceptable?
@hacks4pancakes @mattblaze @DaveMWilburn @spacerog Yes, I think. At least worth seeing what he has to say.
@spacerog I appreciate that. But a lot of people sure do.
@mattblaze Thank you for confirming that obscurity is my best policy. 😭 🤣 😭

@pro well I said it was my best policy, not that I followed it perfectly! 😁

But it's not like LAD is a hot seller. I think I've been mostly obscure to most of the trolls. So far. With luck.

@mattblaze thanks for being here . For “less famous” folks like me the experience is better, and is improved by having you here
@mattblaze So here's a positive mention - I've been following your publications since the mid-90's and very much appreciate your take on everything from crypto to election security. Don't let the vocal minority drown out the silent majority who appreciate your content.
@mattblaze Sorry, if you leave I would miss you. To me, Mastodon has seemed much more charitable than Twitter.

@mattblaze Thanks for being here. You're one of the voices I appreciated on Twitter.

And I can't go back to a site that considers hate speech acceptable.

@mattblaze This is what they want. They want you to leave _their_ platform. They want to dictate how it's used and by who. The Fediverse can be just as toxic as Twitter. The only difference is who the bullies are.
@mattblaze How in the world do you manage to attract that attention? Did the whiners follow you over from the other site?
@wendynather It's different whiners, who believe I represent everything they hate about newbies and Twitter.