Nilim DuttaNov 11, 2019
Why do I even waste my precious time by seeking to explain to useless liberals how you cannot defeat fascism by electoral politics and certainly not by pinning your hopes on parties who are little different than the BJP? Like I said before, it matters little whether the shit is warm or cold when you are in it up to your neck.
Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019

@NilimDutta I am curious to know your take on this article by the Deshabhimani CPI[M] mouthpiece in Kerala.

https://www.deshabhimani.com/articles/p-rajeev/832976

The challenges posed by Maoism; In countries where parliamentary systems exist, the struggles must be exercised

The post is in Malayalam but if you're on chrome you can right click on the page and translate it to English right then and there.

The post was written in the wake of a Police killing of a Maosit in Kerala.

മാവോയിസം ഉയർത്തുന്ന വെല്ലുവിളികൾ; പാർലമെന്ററി സംവിധാനങ്ങൾ നിലനിൽക്കുന്ന രാജ്യങ്ങളിൽ ആ സംവിധാനത്തെ ഉപയോഗപ്പെടുത്തിയാകണം സമരങ്ങൾ

ക്യൂബൻ വിപ്ലവത്തിന്‌ ഫിഡലിനൊപ്പം നേതൃത്വം നൽകിയ ചെ ഗുവേര എഴുതിയ ‘ഗറില്ല യുദ്ധം’ ഏറെ ശ്രദ്ധേയമായ പുസ്‌തകമാണ്‌. ബാറ്റിസ്‌റ്റയുടെ നേതൃത്വത്തിലുള്ള അമേരിക്കൻ പാവ സർക്കാരിനെതിരായ വിപ്ലവ വിജയത്തിന്റെ അനുഭവങ്ങളുടെകൂടി അടിസ്ഥാനത്തിലാണ്‌ ചെ ഗുവേര ഈ പുസ്‌തകം എഴുതുന്നത്‌.

Show threadNilim DuttaNov 11, 2019
@Koshy (1) If you are a Communist/Marxist, your fundamental ideological responsibility is to overthrow the *ruling class* and I have not heard of that happening through electoral politics. Anywhere. Ever. 1/n
Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019
@NilimDutta I would also like @pratheesh to weigh in on this thread.
Show threadpratheeshNov 11, 2019
@Koshy @NilimDutta : I think the point P. Rajeev is trying to emphasise in the article is not justifying parliamentary opportunism, however, to make use of parliamentary systems for the struggles. I am agreeing with @NilimDutta in one point, though. Fascism cannot be defeated by parliamentary opportunism or electoral politics. It has to be defeated ideologically. Congress is incapable of waging that war.
Show threadNilim DuttaNov 11, 2019
@pratheesh @Koshy The fundamental responsibility of a Marxist is to be unwaveringly committed to a revolution to overthrow the ruling class. You may use the opportunities Parliamentary democracy offers to build your party's strength but should never for a moment forget what the eventual goal is.
Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019
@NilimDutta @pratheesh What is the eventual goal?
Show threadNilim DuttaNov 11, 2019
@Koshy @pratheesh Why did I even write so many sentences if you have to ask me this again? 😆 What is the fundamental ideological responsibility of a Marxist? THAT !
Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019

@NilimDutta @pratheesh

Thank you for taking the time to respond to my question. I will stop if you don't want to take anymore questions.

I'm no communist nor am I an expert on communism. So excuse my ignorance on the topic.

"What is the fundamental ideological responsibility of a Marxist?"

From this I imply

Your taking about a communist revolution?

Does a revolution necessitate ending parliamentary democracy?

Show threadNilim Dutta
@Koshy @pratheesh My time is precious. Let me be forthright about it. Too many critical battles being fought on the ground. I will take questions. No problem. But follow my responses closely. The fundamental ideological responsibility is to overthrow the *ruling class*. And a Marxist can't remain stuck in the kind of politics which would not make it possible.
Nov 11, 2019 at 4:20pmWeb
Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019
@NilimDutta Thank you for responding, I won't take up anymore of your time.
Show threadNilim DuttaNov 11, 2019

@Koshy @pratheesh //Does a revolution necessitate ending parliamentary democracy?//

The kind of fake democracy we have now? Absolutely ! The dictatorship of the proletariat would be exercised through the party and there can be no other party. Democracy would work in the manner as to how one would get elected into party positions and positions in the government.

Show threadKoshy GeorgeNov 11, 2019

@NilimDutta Ok, I can't resist, some more question.

So, like China. Are you in agreement with the current Chinese system of governance?

Show threadNilim DuttaNov 11, 2019
@Koshy Will answer tomorrow.