This series is not self-help, not a political program, and not spiritual consolation.

It is an attempt to understand what kind of problem a person is actually facing — personal, structural, moral, institutional, economic, or interior — so the response happens at the right level.

Read 👇
https://reviewsrantsandraves.substack.com/p/what-the-sandpile-knows-a-foreword

#WhatTheSandpileKnows
#SystemsThinking
#CategoryErrors
#PersonalEconomy
#WrongMaps
#StructuralBetrayal
#SelfOrganizedCriticality
#EconomicPrecarity
#LifeArchitecture
#CrisisAndRenewal

What the Sandpile Knows: A foreword on systems, survival, crisis, and the search for a more accurate map.

A foreword to What the Sandpile Knows: a series on wrong maps, category errors, structural betrayal, personal economy, crisis, and renewal.

Reviews, Rants & Raves

Fear and Loathing of AI (Part III): “Learn AI” Is the New “Learn to Code”

By Cliff Potts, CSO, and Editor-in-Chief of WPS News

There is a sentence that shows up in every technological cycle right before the disappointment phase begins.

“Just learn the skill.”

It sounds empowering. It sounds reasonable. It sounds like personal agency.

It is also a lie we have been telling people for decades.

The obedience script

“Learn to code” was never about opportunity.
It was about discipline.

It trained people to accept that:

  • structural failures are personal problems,
  • economic insecurity is an individual moral test,
  • and survival depends on constant retraining at your own expense.

When the promised jobs didn’t materialize—or paid far less than advertised—the story shifted seamlessly: you didn’t learn the right language, the right framework, the right stack.

Now the phrase has been updated.

“Learn AI.”

Same script. Same pressure. Same outcome.

Skills don’t collapse — markets do

Coding did not fail because people were lazy or incapable. It failed because markets flooded, tools commoditized, and labor lost leverage.

AI will follow the same arc, only faster.

The moment a skill becomes:

  • widely accessible,
  • easily automated,
  • and expected rather than rewarded,

it stops being a path to security and becomes a baseline requirement for staying afloat.

The reward for compliance is not prosperity.
It is continued participation.

Training as cost transfer

Here is what “learn AI” really means in practice:

  • You pay for the courses.
  • You absorb the time cost.
  • You shoulder the career risk.
  • You adapt repeatedly as tools change.
  • You accept lower pay because “AI makes you more efficient.”

None of that is accidental.

It is a system designed to push costs downward while extracting value upward.

The more often you are told to retrain, the clearer it becomes that training itself is the product.

The illusion of agency

People are encouraged to believe that mastery equals control.

But control does not come from skill alone.
It comes from:

  • ownership,
  • bargaining power,
  • regulation,
  • and collective leverage.

Without those, skill is just labor dressed up as self-improvement.

Learning AI may help you keep your job a little longer.
It will not protect you from the logic of the system deploying it.

What learning actually means now

This does not mean you should refuse to learn.

It means you should learn without illusions.

Learn AI the way you learn any tool:

  • to reduce friction,
  • to save time,
  • to extend what you already do.

Do not learn it expecting salvation.
Do not learn it expecting loyalty from platforms.
Do not learn it expecting the market to reward you for effort.

Markets reward leverage, not diligence.

The quiet truth

The most dangerous part of “learn AI” is not that it is false.

It is that it is incomplete.

It tells people how to adapt, but never who benefits.
It demands flexibility, but never offers stability.
It promises relevance, but never guarantees dignity.

We have seen this cycle before.

And it did not end with freedom.

It ended with exhaustion.

For more social commentary, please see Occupy 2.5 at https://Occupy25.com

#AISkills #ArtificialIntelligence #economicPrecarity #futureOfWork #laborEconomics #learnToCode #Occupy25 #platformCapitalism #technologyHype #workforceRetraining #WPSNews

i like the idea of #UBI but i don't think it is workable with our current model of ownership--private property. i have little knowledge of economics, so i can't argue vociferously for this opinion. i can just imagine that any UBI i might receive could be easily taken by a landlord raising my rent, or another corporate entity increasing costs for other necessary purchasing like groceries, medical care/insurance, or education.

i like the idea of #JobGuarantee better. it makes more sense to me and seems to provide a less-hackable, less-manipulable floor as UBI proposes. it guarantees a livable wage and avoids the precarity of unemployment and gig work. but, again, i'm no economist. though i did participate in the now defunct CETA program when i was a teen.

@pluralistic has highlighted #JobGuarantee in this week's link dump: https://pluralistic.net/2023/12/16/hotchpotch/#judge-not-lest-ye-be-bribed where he says...

"The best authority on the Job Guarantee is Pavlina Tcherneva. Her slim book on the subject is a fantastic explainer..." A Case for a Job Guarantee.

"No amount of growth can eliminate the job shortage that exists in virtually every country. Conventional policies have failed as well. The job guarantee is the landmark policy innovation that can secure true full employment, while stabilizing the economy, producing key social assets, and securing a basic economic right." [from https://www.jobguarantee.org/why/]

More information can be found at https://www.jobguarantee.org/faqs/

i'm interested in what people think of #JobGuarantee vs #UBI. i'm not confident in my ability to argue for one over another, but i would like to participate in or observe a discussion geared towards a better understanding. my preferred solution would be implementing anarchism rather than try to rescue capitalism, but at least a #JobGuarantee would attenuate the pernicious ravages of neoliberal capitalism--again, in my opinion.

#JobGuarantee #UBI #EconomicPrecarity #Unemployment #Neoliberalism #WealthInequality #Capitalism #Anarchism

Pluralistic: Linkdump Minkchump (16 Dec 2023) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow