Annotations for *Star Trek: Khan* 1x08: “Original Sin” - Star Trek Website
The story on the tapes jumps ahead to five years after McGivers’ death, around
2273. The exile started in late 2267, 4 months pass bringing us into 2268,
McGivers becomes pregnant, dies, Kali is born late 2268, five years later brings
us to 2273. Lear refers to tapes CA5-47-31M, CA5-49-2P and CA5-39-17U. How the
naming convention is organised is not clear, although the “5” could indicate the
year of exile. Lear notes that Kali’s maturity and intelligence at 5 were
consistent with a child twice her age. Advanced development in children in
science fiction is a common trope (see Alexander Rozhenko), but at least her
Augmented heritage accounts for some of it. In CA5-53-12K, Khan encourages Kali
to quote from Kubla Khan (“The shadow of the dome of pleasure / Floated midway
on the waves”) while Kali wants to read more Shakespeare, showing good taste for
a child her age. CA5-61-3P says that Paolo, Kamora, Joachim and Delmonda were
selected for the rescue mission. It was established in the last episode that the
ship could only hold four people. Tuvok searches the entries from Day 1800-1900
and plays the last entry, which would be approximately 5.2 years into the exile.
Khan quotes from William Butler Yates’s 1919 poem The Second Coming: “Things
fall apart; the centre cannot hold; / Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world” and
references the last two lines of the poem: “And what rough beast, its hour come
round at last, / Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?” Yeats was contemplating
the aftermath of World War I, the start of the Irish War of Independence and the
flu pandemic of 1918-1919, which explains the poem’s apocalyptic imagery and its
sense of the end of one era of history and the instability that accompanies the
birth of another. Ursula and Madot have broken up due to the death of their
unborn child in the previous episode. Kali packs a copy of the Complete Works of
William Shakespeare. In the cargo pod Chekov encounters in ST II, there is no
copy of the Complete Works seen, but there is a copy of King Lear, Shakespeare’s
play of a king’s descent into madness. Kali references the sinking of Sea
Venture as her inspiration for naming the rescue ship Venture. Sea Venture’s was
part of a supply fleet to Jamestown in Virginia in 1609. It got separated from
the fleet and was wrecked on the then-uninhabited island of Bermuda. It is
believed to have inspired Shakespeare’s The Tempest. That play in turn also
inspired the 1956 science fiction film Forbidden Planet, which also influenced
Star Trek. Khan corrects Kali, who believes the wreck also inspired As You Like
It, by pointing out that the play was written in 1599. There is a bigger problem
here, though, as while several of Shakespeare’s plays have shipwrecks, As You
Like It is not among them. Kali may be thinking of The Comedy of Errors (1592)
or even Twelfth Night (1601-1602), if we’re sticking to comedies, although those
also predate the wreck of Sea Venture. Once the ship leaves, the caves will
collapse and be uninhabitable, which explains why Khan and his Augments were
living in the cargo pod in ST II. The ship uses a “spatial compression drive”,
which sounds similar to the coaxial warp drive that could fold space in VOY:
“Vis à Vis” or the spatial trajector of VOY: “Prime Factors”. Khan alludes to
Starfleet not checking back on them in the five years since the exile, a
question that is as yet unanswered in this series. The question of what
destroyed Ceti Alpha VI, however, is resolved. Delmonda explains that when the
power that allows the drive to bend space and time was about to lose
containment, he chose to vent the energy out of the Elborean ship’s forward
ports, and that destroyed Ceti Alpha VI. T This actually connects to one risk of
the Alcubierre drive (which also bends spacetime), which is that everything that
is caught at the leading edge of the Alcubierre “warp bubble” gets accumulated
and carried along. Once the bubble stops at its destination and collapses, all
that accumulated energy/debris would be released with devastating effect. I
emphasise as I have always done that Star Trek warp drive is not the Alcubierre
drive.
[https://www.reddit.com/r/DaystromInstitute/comments/w89sh3/why_star_trek_warp_drive_is_not_the_alcubierre/]
Delmonda’s replies to Khan as the latter offers to part as friends, “I have been
and always shall be yours.” This is, of course, what Spock says to Kirk in his
room in ST II and then paraphrases of when he dies at the end of the movie.
Tuvok dates the crash of the rescue ship at 21 years prior. Give my sums above,
this would place the time of the framing sequence in 2294, although the first
episode started in 2293. The dates are a bit fuzzy here because Lear and Tuvok
are on the surface of Ceti Alpha V twenty-six years after the exile, which would
be consistent with the 2293 date but not 2294. Possibly Excelsior was in orbit
for several months after that, which might explain Sulu’s impatience.