Finished reading: Malleus Monstrorum Slipcase Set
As someone who loves both the Mythos and a bestiary, these books unfortunately kinda show the limitations when both are combined. Mythos entities encountered alone are horrific and gross and cool. Combined they run together in a kind of protean slurry of gore and tentacles and “unpronounceable” names, and the seams where multiple authors over the century have stitched in their own additions result in something that is somehow both too samey and too thematically incoherent.
Also, just . . . times have kinda moved on? Hence the quote marks around “unpronounceable,” since combinations of syllables that seemed “foreign” and “strange” in 1926 are significantly less so in an age where your average English speaker has encountered half a dozen loanwords before breakfast. (Or possibly at breakfast; the fact that “Shak’shu-ka” could be a Mythos god being kinda illustrative of the point.) Not to mention some of the monster designs feel a bit uninspired in a world of Bloodborne and Silent Hill, though Loïc Muzy’s illustrations punch above their weight as usual.
All that being said, none of that is the fault of these books specifically, which are a great resource for what they are, with all the relevant crunch and fluff and cool illustrations. Also, props to the writers for updating some of the more, y’know. Cat-named (if you get my drift) elements, particularly the distancing of Mythos entities from any one ethnic group or set of religious/spiritual beliefs (Ithaqua, looking at you, buddy).
Anyway. I don’t regret buying these, and they did sate my lust for tomes of tentacled bad bois. And I guess that’s the important part.
#books #booksRead #ttrpg