R. Daniel Kelemen

1.7K Followers
338 Following
179 Posts

Does freezing #EU funds work?

KIM LANE SCHEPPELE and JOHN MORIJN evaluate the variety of #ruleoflaw conditionality tools used against #Poland and #Hungary.

https://verfassungsblog.de/frozen/

Frozen: How the EU is Blocking Funds to Hungary and Poland Using a Multitude of Conditionalities

After years of inaction, the European Commission and Council jointly acted to freeze EU funds totaling more than €28.7 billion for Hungary and more than €110 billion for Poland at the end of 2022, citing rule-of-law violations.  Surprisingly, the decisions were taken not just (or even primarily) using the new Conditionality Regulation designed for that purpose. Instead, they used a variety of other legal tools to which rule-of-law conditionality was attached. It remains somewhat mysterious, however, precisely which funds and what proportion of those funds have been suspended, and how those suspensions have been legally justified. This post, a shorter version of a SIEPS paper that will be published soon, describes what we know about the complex set of funding suspensions intended to make EU Member States pay for their rule-of-law violations.

Verfassungsblog
Professional News: I am thrilled to share that I will be joining the faculty of Georgetown’s McCourt School of Public Policy this fall as the newest McCourt Chair! I look forward to working with the amazing faculty and students at McCourt! #HoyaSaxa
https://mccourt.georgetown.edu/news/daniel-kelemen-mccourt-chair/
McCourt School welcomes Dan Kelemen as a McCourt Chair - McCourt School of Public Policy

Dr. Kelemen brings to the McCourt School deep expertise in comparative politics and public policy.

McCourt School of Public Policy

RT @[email protected]

🇭🇺🇪🇺⚖️💶Last minute pre-Xmas update from the Commission on the payout of funds for Hungary with some critical caveats (highlighted in red by some fly on the wall in Berlaymont - many thanks!).

🐦🔗: https://twitter.com/J_Jaraczewski/status/1605926948928196609

Jakub Jaraczewski (@[email protected]) on Twitter

“🇭🇺🇪🇺⚖️💶Last minute pre-Xmas update from the Commission on the payout of funds for Hungary with some critical caveats (highlighted in red by some fly on the wall in Berlaymont - many thanks!).”

Twitter

RT @[email protected]

Wow. @[email protected] now moves to block all (!) 22 bn euros in cohesion funds for #Hungary. Same reason as vis-a-vis Poland: #Orban gvt. not adhering to Charter of Fundamental Rights. #RuleofLaw @[email protected] @[email protected] @[email protected]

🐦🔗: https://twitter.com/MarkusBecker/status/1606211902379524096

Markus Becker on Twitter

“Wow. @EU_Commission now moves to block all (!) 22 bn euros in cohesion funds for #Hungary. Same reason as vis-a-vis Poland: #Orban gvt. not adhering to Charter of Fundamental Rights. #RuleofLaw @daniel_freund @moritzkoerner @katarinabarley”

Twitter

RT @[email protected]

Hungary’s “child-protection law, serious risks to academic freedom and the right to asylum” still hold up EU cash. This will elevate tensions between Budapest and Brussels again for sure. https://twitter.com/elisaferreiraec/status/1605858220450406401

🐦🔗: https://twitter.com/mdunai/status/1605878579513827329

Elisa Ferreira on Twitter

“It’s a wrap!📢The last 21-27 Partnership Agreement is adopted! €22 bn from #Cohesion will support Hungary’s sustainable development. This is 🇪🇺 solidarity with 🇭🇺 people. 11 operational programmes with concrete priorities for fairer, greener & smarter 🇭🇺 are also adopted. 1/3”

Twitter

Little doubt, that Viktor Orban is the most expensive Prime Minister in the EU.

First, he makes EU billions disappear in corruption.

Now, he's losing EU billions because unwillingness to comply with fundamental rights.

There's the #BoldTruthAboutHungary

And then there's - well - actual facts.

Seems like the @[email protected] finally understands:

For someone who systematically demolishes the rule of law and violates fundamental rights - like Viktor Orban does - there is only ONE appropriate answer:

100% suspension of EU-funds.

But we did it! There are now 6.3 billion euros of EU money to the Orban government frozen - another 5.8 billion from the Corona Fund are also being withheld. The reason: massive violations of the rule of law in Hungary. /2
This is a groundbreaking success. And it was a gruelling political struggle that I was able to accompany as a Green member of the European Parliament's negotiating team. /3