The cynic in me believes that Fediverse integration only exists so that Zucc can show regulators that they care about open source software.
But that doesn’t really matter. Federation is coming. It looks like it will be a slow, drip feed, ratchet effect. The switch is more like a dial, with the end goal being “Federation on”.
My opinion is that most people on Threads won’t care, don’t know, or don’t care about Federation. After all, the option to do so is buried in the app settings, and looks like it’ll be opt-in.
Regardless of all of Zucc’s shitty actions, which includes genocide (I seriously cannot stress enough about this genocide thing), my main issue with threaderation is that we will get a flood of users who are at best ignorant and at worst hostile to our norms. They will see our posts and they will break the sanctity of our community — where the marginalised, disgruntled, and alternative make their home.
At the moment, the Fediverse is a niche – a popular niche, but still niche. What happens to our culture, and our way of life then?
Defederation from Threads is NOT being closed minded. It is not being against “the open Web”. It is about protecting those of us who live on the Fediverse who are on the fringe of existence IRL.