One of the things that grinds my fuckin' gears the most about "AI" boosters is how much they chastise the rest of us for "refusing to engage".

I am not refusing to engage! When i yell at the top of my lungs about how shitty and destructive this shit is, i am engaging! This is what engaging looks like, because every new technology is first and foremost a site of struggle!

What the cultists are trying to insist we do isn't "engage", it's "concede".

@adrienne If LLMs worked, didn't destroy the environment, and were 100% accurate I think they'd have an actual product.

Unfortunately that isn't reality and they are generally awful. And once their investors realize it's snake oil they'll be sold to nothing.

@matoakit Also if they weren't made entirely by stealing and plagiarizing.
@adrienne That too. It's soul theft

@matoakit @adrienne

The false analogy with human learning is particularly insulting. (Plus the implication we should respect a fucking LLM like if it was a conscious mind. Anthropomorphization is one of their surest rhetorical weapons.)