As an #Emacs user who reads #Atom and #RSS feeds since the 90s on a daily basis to all users of #elfeed:

If you're using elfeed non exclusively, how do you sync the read-status of your feed subscriptions?

If elfeed exclusively: why aren't you reading feeds on mobile/tablet? At least for me, mobile is my main feed consumption platform.

I read feeds...

on my computer only (within elfeed)
61.8%
on mobile (how?) and Emacs elfeed
14.7%
on a web platform + elfeed
17.6%
other (add comment)
5.9%
Poll ended at .
@publicvoit RSS is one of those things where emacs just isn't the right fit for me. I want to use elfeed, and I have in the past, but the experience of using my phone is just better.
@publicvoit I'm curious to see the results of this poll. I absolutely loved elfeed, but realized I want to do most of my feed reading on my phone, so I stopped using elfeed and switched to inoreader.
@oantolin @publicvoit I think elfeed-protocol could work for you. I am not sure about the setup effort and how smooth it is, since I have not used it yet. You'd also have to live with different UIs, in Emacs, and on mobile.
@oantolin @publicvoit There have been some responses here that elfeed-protocol hasn't quite worked for them or had issues. The author of elfeed-protocol Fasheng has been responsive. I think he is willing to help fixing issues. I worked with them after I had changed some internal APIs of Elfeed, and when we improved the integration with additional hooks in order to avoid advices.

@oantolin @publicvoit

Miniflux is a great substitute, but the tradeoff is that you need to install and configure elfeed-protocol.

I read feeds on my phone + emacs and everything syncs (including feed tags [from miniflux] and whether I've read or bookmarked an article). Another tradeoff would be that miniflux is paid, although it's something like 15 schmeckles per year.

@publicvoit Miniflux and elfeed with elfeed-protocol works pretty well.
@publicvoit I use TheOldReader, and played around with `elfeed-protocol` in the past, even trying to write my own integration, but it never quite 100% worked, so I don't use elfeed anymore. I would be interested in doing it again though :).

@publicvoit

on a laptop & android tablet, although there is no guarantee we will be able to run #emacs on #android this time next year

i don't sync the feeds, laptop is more focused on #rubylang #julialang & the more techy aspects of #emacs

the android feed is more general science/emacs news/ sports / slashdot

the laptop is used in the evening @ home while the tablet, which doubles as a phone & runs my #orgmode #agenda goes with me during the day.

@publicvoit Nextcloud News as RSS aggregator, synched to Elfeed. Best combination: read via browser on Nextcloud (including mobile), and via Emacs. Reading status is in sync, and I can add feeds via browser.

#emacs #nextcloud

@EFLS @publicvoit I've not used Nextcloud News. What does it mean to be synced to elfeed? Does that mean you point elfeed at Nextcloud rather than the original feed? Marking read in elfeed marks it read in Nextcloud?

I guess that's what an aggregator does, but I don't use RSS much, so it's not obvious to me. Thanks in advance 😃

@pabryan @publicvoit Yeah that’s it. elfeed-protocol receives the RSS updates from Nextcloud News and syncs read status and whatnot. So I can read RSS either in Emacs or via the Nextcloud web interface
@EFLS @publicvoit thanks, that sounds pretty good. I guess any aggregator will do the same thing. I do have a Heztner Nextcloud instance for cloud storage though. Time to check if Hetzner supports that app!
@publicvoit I moved from Inoreader to Elfeed because I was rarely reading any of my feeds on mobile and the Emacs experience was just so good. The ideal situation for me would be to be able to sync Elfeed with a feed aggregator for the few times I didn't have my laptop available.

@publicvoit hmmm, I've got a Nextcloud setup and have used elfeed-protocol via FreshRSS. I should look into moving from FreshRSS to Nextcloud News.

I've been working towards using elfeed exclusively, but I really do like having the option to do that consumption on mobile.

@publicvoit I run a freshrss service on a minipc "server". I access feeds from there primarily using elfeed + elfeed-protocol.

I can also access the freshrss service via a web interface (works fine on mobile), or using 'Capy Reader' app (FDroid) - both over a wireguard tunnel when away from home.

This is not a perfect solution, as only unread items are fetched by elfeed/capy clients. I've been meaning for some time to try the other servers supported by elfeed-protocol.

@publicvoit Another slight limitation is that YouTube feeds need to be subscribed directly in elfeed (i.e. not in freshrss) for 'elfeed-tube' functionality to work.
@shimeike I am looking forward to what you're going to find out regarding the perfect self hosted rss service. I wonder what you mean by only unread items are fetched. Doesn't it fetch all and only synchronize the unread tag?
@publicvoit

@minad That would definitely be the desired behaviour.

There is a note on the elfeed-protocol readme about freshrss servers specifically and the lack of an entry ID server-side. I've therefore only ever followed fasheng's advice to configure to configure the emacs side to only fetch unread items.

Interestingly, the android client that I use has the same behaviour without specific configuration.

Anyway, you now give me further motivation to more fully investigate alternatives!

@publicvoit

@publicvoit

Love this poll. The results surprise me somewhat. The golden implementation to me has been something like miniflux taking care of the polling and keeping me from missing posts (some feeds have a window).

At the same time, I do dip in and out of elfeed as it gets a little inundating to constantly be drinking from the firehose.

Maybe I should go back to infrequent polling from within elfeed?