Mastodawn

RE: https://mastodon.social/@kottke/116647849282379563

The thing I don't get here, is how?

I understand that AI hallucinates papers, it's very annoying and one of the reasons I don't use it for research.

But you're supposed to go read the paper before you cite it. Evaluate the paper, even. And you can't even skim or uncritically read just the abstract of a paper that doesn't exist.

So a huge number of published academics don't even read what they cite?

It's concerning that there's a higher standard asked of students than professionals.

#academic #academia #AI

Show thread

Keira (She/Her)

I mean, I know people look at them uncritically. I was researching something for uni recently, and most of my source papers quoted the same paper regarding childhood malnutrition linked to adult diabetes.

So I went and read the paper. And found it doesn't say that at all. The results found what looked like a link, but the discussion clearly says they *couldn't* establish a link because there were far too many confounders. There was an older, larger study that legitimately did, but the pressure to cite more recent studies (and laziness?) meant most people were citing them anyway.

Show thread

Su_G 1d ago

@keira_reckons
Strange research that cites papers that don’t exist or papers that don’t contribute. 😐 Seems like a giant waste of time. Why is it rewarded at all. [I guess this is a rhetorical question; maybe a better question is: why do ‘research’ if this is all it is? I.e. where is the drive to fake it or do this fake research coming from?] 🤔

#researchIntegrity #research #citations #fakeResearch #reconnectingConsequencesToCauses

Show thread

RaymondPierreL3 1d ago

@keira_reckons
Literature reviews are a fundamental part of any research and writing reseach papers. Given that almost all scientific/academic research is based on, or builds upon precedents. I don’t understand how we got to where we are today. Maybe the way #managerialism has corrupted many fine institutions with the ensuing #NeoLiberalFailures resulting in a lack of public funding and a scurrying for non-public funds (a potentially corrupting actor in any research) is the prime cause.

We;ve failed our #Scientific and #Academic Institutions and continue to fail them with each successive neoliberal govt.

#TaxTheRich #noBillionaires #PublicFinding #Education #Research #ResearchPapers