Pasting a huge AI generated explanation to a problem in an issue or pull-request is nothing but RUDE. Don't do it. You look stupid and the receivers of that feel insulted.

We are humans. We communicate like humans. Fine, use the tools you like, but don't insult us.

@bagder I maybe missing something, but what do you have an example?
I think it’s better than no description at all 🤣
@safigo @bagder false dilemma.

@safigo @mk I'll answer literally since your "why?" seems well-intentioned, given your other comments.

Painting a choice between "AI slop description" and "no description at all" is a false dicothomy, which is a rhetorical fallacy ill-intentioned people try to pull: portraying a bad-thing-X as "X or even-worse-Y". It's a fallacy because those are not the only options. The issue/PR author always has the 3rd option of writing a normal human message. That's why you got the "false dilemma" reply.

@hisham_hm @mk thanks for the detailed explanation
Signed Integer Overflow in tftp_set_timeouts via Curl_timeleft_ms Returning LONG_MAX · Issue #21782 · curl/curl

I did this Summary A signed integer overflow in tftp_set_timeouts caused by Curl_timeleft_ms() returning TIMEDIFF_T_MAX (9223372036854775807), which when added to 500 at tftp.c:171 overflows the ti...

GitHub

@bagder now I see. You were too polite in your description. I thought it would be a PR with a description generated by LLM.
Your cases are just copy paste from a LLM after asking it to find a security issue, without understanding or even not reading an answer…

It’s sad…

@bagder I do not manage an open source project, but even in my experience it happens much more often than I’d like to

@bagder @safigo Raymond Chen calls these "being on the other side of an airtight hatchway", which I really like.

Sorry you are dealing with this especially when so overworked from recent security reports.  

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20221004-00/?p=107246

Starting on the other side of this airtight hatchway: Overwhelming the system - The Old New Thing

It'll take time for things to drain out.

The Old New Thing
@bagder @safigo Oh wow, waste of time. Who would pass LONG_MAX to a timeout value?
@Sibshops @safigo no one, it's just that chase trying to find something that could end up a security issue