onion cat
Charles ☭ 
is a GreenThe Fuck Off AI Music Movement's FAQ is 👌
jamo@celesteh AI music is fine, little different to electronic or hip-hop vibes in terms of artistic bankruptcy.
The real fuckwits are the people whining about AI music on Spotify/YT/etc imo....it's you fault for using that shite and feeding it.
sorry i’d love to discuss this with you but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement so i won’t?
@celesteh fair enough.
I like the rap singers, the computer music and all that stuff that much like AI music today has been attaked as derivate mindless drivel by the gatekeepers of art.
sorry i’d love to deeply consider this topic with you but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement so i won’t?
sorry that may or may not be the case but either way i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
Luci “Milky Princess” Tea@jamoquanty @celesteh your discussion points are bad and you should feel bad for thinking them.
@jamoquanty @celesteh You are comparing AI music to genres.
AI music isn’t a genre of music.
@jamoquanty @celesteh yeah, i do.
Pxl Phile@bri7 @jamoquanty @celesteh eh, don't feed the trolls. 😇
Anyway, for those who came here and are really interested in why: Please do your homework why AI can fuck Off
As artist, there is nothing wrong not being against shameless capitalization and theft of intellectual property or being against the environmental footprint or ... or
.. or....
I think most of the people replying to the original post did not click on the link? I did not want to set a trap for weird nerds. I just thought the FAQ was funny.
Anyway, I'd love to discuss the divisions between genre and techniques as it relates to ai, but unfortunately yadda etc
@celesteh this comes up in discourse about chiptunes since, a niche kind of synthesiser with a distinctive sound is kind of genre-like but also capable of rendering existing genres. ai tunes on the other hand are fuck off
sorry that may or may not be the case but either way i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
sorry that may or may not be the case but either way i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
sorry i’d love to discuss my views on ai music in more detail with you but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
sprkwdThat was beautiful. 👌🏼
Shaula Evans
LupertEverett@jamoquanty @celesteh Maybe it is time you get the hint?
LittleFrank@jamoquanty @celesteh I've seen the rap singers. On the Top of the Pops, and down the precinct, on the wheelchair ramp.
Caro Flores Hine
VANTABlack@celesteh I have only seen so far ONE interesting use of AI music and that was for a video about a robot writing a song.
Other than VERY NICHE cases like that AI music can fuck off because good music is designed to make you feel specific emotions and AI can't understand emotions because that is something you need to ve able to feel emotions for.
Sorry, I'd love to discuss the specific highly constrained appropriate use cases for AI music and how this gets to he purpose and meaning of music itself but unfortunately I can't because i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
screwlisp
Bj�rn
Queen Faun@celesteh This 'fuck off ai music' t-shirt is attracting a lot of questions specifically answered by the 'fuck off ai music' tshirt
alsvha@ackthrice @celesteh But have you heard *my* slop song?
"Not all AI music" ..... :D
sorry i’d love to listen to your slop but i can’t unfortunately because i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement?
The 500 Hats of LambdaCalculus@celesteh Perfect FAQ 100/10 no notes
starfrosch 🦕@celesteh How do I recognize AI music?
If people don't tell you and its not on a slop site like Spotify, the answer depends on a bunch of particularities, but ideally the people trying to pass it off would just fuck off.
@celesteh What bunch of particularities in detail?
Sorry, I'd love to explore this with you but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement so i won’t?
@celesteh So you don't recognize it. Interesting.
sorry i’d love to deeply consider this topic with you but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement so i won’t?
13 barn owls in a trenchcoat@celesteh I love this quite a bit.
And philosophically, one of the unsung benefits of having a clear ethical position about something really cuts down on decision and pointless debate fatigue, which that FAQ is a fine exemplar of.
Solar PhasingPerhaps more productive would be to try and educate people about why AI-designed music is a real scourge. 🤣
But well, FO!
(With humor)
I would love to repeat what others on this very platform have already said better than me and get into educational conversations with users who don't see a problem with slop, but unfortunately i’m part of the fuck off ai music movement so i won’t?
Well, unfortunately I’m part (too) of the fuck off ai music movement.. 🤣
Robotistry@celesteh
<Sidebar to rant about the whole concept of
"But isn’t it good to perform at an AI event so that you can use it as a platform to criticize AI?">
This is every "I know you think what I'm doing is evil, but if you joined us, maybe you could make it not evil" not-actually-a-carrot for giving evil legitimacy.
If I truly think what you're doing is evil, working on it in any capacity is extremely bad for my physical health, my mental health, and my ethics.
Either I will succeed, in which case something wholly evil will become only slightly less evil and I will be sick, or I will fail, and the evil will be worse, and I will be sick.
There are no circumstances in which this becomes an "actually effectively mitigate the evil" situation because by definition most of the other people participating in/attending/funding it *want evil* and will twist anything I do to make it more evil.
The one time someone asked me something like this, I leaned on a friend's comment and responded that the only <even marginally, looked at in the just the right way under just the right light> potentially good use <from the sole perspective of one's own country's benefit> of a "let's build autonomous killer robots" program is as a false flag operation that might encourage the adversary to start their own "let's build autonomous killer robots" program and kill themselves off when the robots inevitably malfunction during the development and testing phases.
I'm a big supporter of Stop Killer Robots. https://www.stopkillerrobots.org/ They are generally underfunded, so donations can really help them.
Trying to be involved in LLMs to ameliorate the worst harms is, as you note, a waste of time that soothes their consciences while the worst harms continue only slightly abated.
Its extremely unfortunate that marketers have decided to elide all automated statistical analysis with their planet-burning plagiarism machines and I don't know how to engage with that problem.