RE: https://dair-community.social/@emilymbender/116604745957981805

"links will become an afterthought" is not even coded language for "the rest of the internet is merely training data and we will own the entire means of accessing information online"

as Dr. Bender says upthread, the Rethinking Search paper just says this explicitly, also AMP, etc. I only mildly edited their figure here

The shift to "search journeys" is just another way of referring to "whole life immersive surveillance" where the intention is to slowly train you to expect more and more of your personal information to be visibly injected into search results as a surface for "personalization" and eventually move towards "zero-query search" where advertisements-i-mean-helpful-information are proactively volunteered to you.

this language appears in full form as early as 2018 and was chilling even then:

The zero-query search paradigm can be expressed with the slogan “the query is the user.” In practice, the context of the user is used to infer information needs. (Entity Oriented Search)

Who gives a single shit how good the "AI" can code when the purpose of "AI" is and always has been enclosure of all information in an ad-driven surveillance platform. If you love LLMs, this is the future you, yes you, are actively helping create.

There IS NO LLM USE not associated with the project to seize all information as a product. That is the WHOLE gamble being made that is driving all those billions into getting as many people as possible dependent on the most preposterously expensive and inefficient model of computing ever devised. It is only worth it if the upside is owning the whole economy.

Every step you take towards building LLMs into your daily habits and work ratchets the spring tighter on the mousetrap until, surprise! It clamps shut while your whole ass is wrapped around the cheese. Don't make me laugh with local models nonsense, if you think that those don't get deprecated the moment they pose the slightest whiff of a threat to the profit model - meta isn't releasing weights to be nice, it's to capture labor and control the tooling space. Don't be a sucker.

Don't reach for the easy dismissals - sure there are other tools in the category that aren't chatbots, there are assistive applications that are genuinely miraculous, and the rest. But the purpose of these technologies and their reality as products and mountains of capital doesn't have a nuanced "both sides" placation at the bottom of a thinkpiece: they are designed and built to own informational reality.
I got this reply but they deleted it before i got a chance

Oh wait no they just posted it and immediately blocked me but the post is still up. Well that's sad that that is what they chose to go with to block dunk me to their followers

Extremely funny that someone out there believes that

  • opposing a technology of control whose whole selling point is supposed to be "less work" is being lazy (?)
  • that by choosing to keep working in a way that is supposed to be harder means I cry about needing to work (??)
  • that by working hard lazily to survive at a university without advancing the push for dominance being pursued by the largest companies in a world I am endorsing corporate slavery
  • that they in fact have the moral high ground because they are using the corporate technology to cause me to be unemployed

And the correct moral choice is to oppose the bullshit that google and Microsoft use the AI for but completely separate that from the complementary but similarly motivated play made by corporate angel Meta and Moonshot and embrace the exact same thing wholeheartedly.

Its rare that someone says such an incredibly incoherent thing that you have to stop and untie the gift that they puked on your doorstep, but what the fuck did you just say to me listen here you little shit...

"You're fucking bucko'd kiddo" is now preventing me from sleeping
@jonny Are we just gonna overlook "trained in gorilla warfare"?
@cholling @jonny "Right. Bananas. How to defend yourself against a man armed with a banana. Now you, come at me with this banana. Catch! Now, it's quite simple to defend yourself against a man armed with a banana. First of all you force him to drop the banana; then, second, you eat the banana, thus disarming him. You have now rendered him 'elpless."
@jonny this dick has ZERO bite. Don't fret a minute. Solidarity jonny! 🖤✊

@jonny  

Well played sir. Now may you sleep well... 😵 💤

@jonny "you people" lol
@jonny that post is like encountering the juice at the bottom of the trash bin
@jonny its still there they mustve blocked you so turbocoward to boot
@jonny thanks for your service!
@jonny Is that what an AI-generated rant sounds like?

@pietkuip @jonny looks like a mashup of several copypasta. I recognize the navy seal one in there. I'm thinking troll.

Edit: I completely misread. Of course the hilarious troll was OP mocking the AI bro. I should read the posts more thoroughly

@jonny

That reply is a work of art, especially the assumption at the end that people have jobs for reasons other than "because I need to be paid so I can put food on the table and have a roof over my head"

@jonny that post wasn't deleted, you just got reply-and-blocked
@jonny The Navy Seal copypasta one is so funny
@impactology
I need to save it to my notes app so I can be quicker on the draw, this keeps happening
@jonny looking at their profile, it looks like they're harassing people who are critical of AI. Blocked and reported them
@jonny Incredibly telling that this person thinks people are “entitled” for thinking they “have the right to say ‘no’” and apparently delights in harming them for it.

@jonny Holy fuck that reply

Talk about obnoxiously entitled

@jonny Guess it's nice to see some aged copypasta from this professional troll.