THREAD The Great "Should We Even Be Going to Space" Debate One of the sizeable reactions to space missions is "We shouldn't even be going to space. Let's fix earth first. Priorities!" And when Artemis II circled the moon in April, it was no different. So today we ask: 1/20
One of the common assumptions made by detractors is that the vast costs and effort we put into space travel would be better spent on making earth cleaner and more equitable. But this misses a fundamental benefit of free inquiry and research impact: knowledge transfer across domains. 2/20
Let's make the same argument about F1 racing for a sec: "Just a bunch of rich athletes driving hypercars round closed tracks in upmarket locations for hours. Who cares? We should be supporting healthcare!" Except F1 did that already. 3/20
In 1999 hospital staff at Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) noticed that the most dangerous moment for children after cardiac surgery wasn't the op itself, but the handover from surgery to the ICU. They saw a Ferrari F1 pitstop on TV, realised it was the solution, and met the team. 4/20
Once GOSH had developed their F1-inspired handover protocol, the results were clear: Technical errors dropped from 5.42 to 3.15 per handover. Information omissions fell from 2.09 to 1.07. Overall handover quality improved by over 50%. onlinelibrary.wiley.... 5/20

Patient handover from surgery ...
Considerably north-west of GOSH is Birmingham Children's Hospital (which is in Birmingham btw). Their own staff had also noticed the technological innovations within the racing arena, particularly the 300+ real-time monitoring sensors which could predict an engine is about to fail. 6/20
They asked themselves: if McLaren can monitor an F1 car's 300+ sensors in real time and predict when an engine is about to fail, could the same approach predict when a child's condition is about to deteriorate? Spoiler alert: yes. www.nature.com/artic... 7/20

Wireless monitoring and real-t...
Wireless monitoring and real-time adaptive predictive indicator of deterioration - Scientific Reports

To assist in the early warning of deterioration in hospitalised children we studied the feasibility of collecting continuous wireless physiological data using Lifetouch (ECG-derived heart and respiratory rate) and WristOx2 (pulse-oximetry and derived pulse rate) sensors. We compared our bedside paediatric early warning (PEW) score and a machine learning automated approach: a Real-time Adaptive Predictive Indicator of Deterioration (RAPID) to identify children experiencing significant clinical deterioration. 982 patients contributed 7,073,486 min during 1,263 monitoring sessions. The proportion of intended monitoring time was 93% for Lifetouch and 55% for WristOx2. Valid clinical data was 63% of intended monitoring time for Lifetouch and 50% WristOx2. 29 patients experienced 36 clinically significant deteriorations. The RAPID Index detected significant deterioration more frequently (77% to 97%) and earlier than the PEW score ≥ 9/26. High sensitivity and negative predictive value for the RAPID Index was associated with low specificity and low positive predictive value. We conclude that it is feasible to collect clinically valid physiological data wirelessly for 50% of intended monitoring time. The RAPID Index identified more deterioration, before the PEW score, but has a low specificity. By using the RAPID Index with a PEW system some life-threatening events may be averted.

Nature
So yeah let's maybe keep F1. So what about Space? Well, firefighters for one are pretty happy with the fruits of space research. Both the fire retardant in their clothing and the oxygen tanks on their backs are direct cross-pollinations from space research. spinoff.nasa.gov/Spi... 8/20
Polymer Fabric Protects Firefighters, Military, and Civilians | NASA Spinoff

Astronaut G-suits that prevent them from blacking out have been adapted into the LifeWrap garment that reduces postpartum haemorrhage deaths by 50%. Costs $1 per use. Recommended by @[email protected] Massive impact of an unrelated research area. 70K women die from obstetric haemorrhage annually. 9/20
Keytruda is a vital cancer immunotherapy drug. Administration was until recently exclusively a 30-min IV infusion every 3 weeks. Merck wanted to create a subcutaneous injectable form but here on earth gravity doesn't let you grow protein crystals that fit in a needle. 10/20
Merck collaborated with the ISS to grow protein crystals in space uniformly, and then reverse engineered the compound so it can be replicated on the ground. a 30-min IV is now a 1-min injection. "We are star stuff, injecting more star stuff." - Carl Sagan (probably) www.nature.com/artic... 11/20

Pembrolizumab microgravity cry...
Pembrolizumab microgravity crystallization experimentation - npj Microgravity

Crystallization processes have been widely used in the pharmaceutical industry for the manufacture, storage, and delivery of small-molecule and small protein therapeutics. However, the identification of crystallization processes for biologics, particularly monoclonal antibodies, has been prohibitive due to the size and the flexibility of their overall structure. There remains a challenge and an opportunity to utilize the benefits of crystallization of biologics. The research laboratories of Merck Sharp & Dome Corp. (MSD) in collaboration with the International Space Station (ISS) National Laboratory performed crystallization experiments with pembrolizumab (Keytruda®) on the SpaceX-Commercial Resupply Services-10 mission to the ISS. By leveraging microgravity effects such as reduced sedimentation and minimal convection currents, conditions producing crystalline suspensions of homogeneous monomodal particle size distribution (39 μm) in high yield were identified. In contrast, the control ground experiments produced crystalline suspensions with a heterogeneous bimodal distribution of 13 and 102 μm particles. In addition, the flight crystalline suspensions were less viscous and sedimented more uniformly than the comparable ground-based crystalline suspensions. These results have been applied to the production of crystalline suspensions on earth, using rotational mixers to reduce sedimentation and temperature gradients to induce and control crystallization. Using these techniques, we have been able to produce uniform crystalline suspensions (1–5 μm) with acceptable viscosity (<12 cP), rheological, and syringeability properties suitable for the preparation of an injectable formulation. The results of these studies may help widen the drug delivery options to improve the safety, adherence, and quality of life for patients and caregivers.

Nature
Hey, are YOU a fan of taking photos of your family on holiday? That smartphone camera works because of CMOS sensors, another invention of Space origin. And clean water? Count me a fan. Silver ionisation water purification is also a boon of the so-called boondoggle projects of space. 12/20
The infra-red in-ear thermometer, remote patient vitals sensors, robotic arms that perform previously impossible brain surgery; ALL come from humanity's quest for the stars. Canadarm, the robotic arm attached to the ISS, is even featured on Canada's money! 13/20
Inventions and their technological applications to human society don't all emanate from predictable domains. This is why back in 2024 we defended the Ig Nobel Prize awardees somewhat. We don't know what zany off-the wall idea might be relevant in a different field. bsky.app/profile/alt... 14/20

RE: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:lf4a2b6djtuv5l3lz7ffsyv4/post/3l6o6ndu3h32q
Don't fall for the argument that money spent on space missions would be taken away from social programs and we should choose between them. You can demand both. But there's one more important reason we shouldn't abandon space as an entire field of research priority: 15/20
In 1959 John Wyndham published "The Outward Urge", a novel describing multiple generations of the Troon family as they traverse space. The title is addressed in the first few pages of the first chapter. This title has since been used by Richard Dawkins for humanity's innate need to explore. 16/20
Space travel is very likely an unavoidable, and vitally necessary, part of humanity. In addition to advancing disparate unrelated fields, it is quite simply what The Outward Urge demands of us. That's why most of humanity does cheer on the many space missions around the world. 17/20
We often bemoan the lack of global perspective that elected leaders and industry titans can exhibit. Humanity's frame of reference before the 20th century was the ground and the sea. And it shows. But when among the stars, many describe a cognitive shift called The Overview Effect 18/20
This cognitive rewiring brought about by JUST a shift in perspective is likely one of the evolutionary gifts humanity has inherited. We have to fit ton our environment. For that to be normalised, the Overview Effect needs to be endemic in human culture. And for that we need space travel. 19/20
Gene Roddenberry called it the Final Frontier. Wyndham described the need to ride the spiral outward and an "urge". Do not give up this dream lightly. Current and future generations do and will benefit greatly, while being inspired in the process. #DefendResearch Ever Outward. 20/20