US reputation hits 'depths not seen this century' – and 'may never recover'

https://lemmy.bestiver.se/post/1033937

US reputation hits 'depths not seen this century' – and 'may never recover' - Lemmy: Bestiverse

Comments [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47668536]

If the us doesn’t go through a Nuremberg trial without operation paperclip style saving nazis. Then no, the us won’t recover
What if we send our Nazis to the moon? What if we don’t give them a spaceship?
I’m alright with that
They are already planning to go to Mars.
Shoot trump into the sun and we’ll come to the negotiation table
Can we settle on a volcano? That’s much more cost effective and the outcome is pretty similar

something like this would be proper

www.youtube.com/watch?v=kq7DDk8eLs8

Disposal of organic waste in Erta Ale Volcano lava lake causes violent eruption

YouTube

Why do people keep saying this nonsense?!

The delta V required to put him in the sun is insane. He only needs to be put into earth orbit or slightly outside that in a vague heliocentric orbit and we can call it a day.

Literally just make sure he hits exit velocity, then it’s in God’s hands. Also how I play Kerbal Space Program.
If we slingshot him off the moon then Mars then jupiter we can probably save delta v and get him into the sun cheap, just expensive in time
No. Too easy. Pit him in a pillory on the National Mall, sell tomatos for a dollar. With the proceeds we could also get rid of taxes the Libertarian idiots bitch endlessly about.
Lock him up in a cell with only incoming news, no outgoing tweets or interviews. That’ll break him.
I am hoping it can go a loooot lower!
The “speak softly” era of American diplomacy is over, but the big stick is still bigger than ever. There is effectively a zero chance of anyone being willing to go toe to toe with the big stick. Although its possible the current leadership runs itself out of resources to wield the big stick against a large enough coalition of other countries. That part remains to be seen while we waste time fighting Iran for no reason
Big talk after losing to Afghanistan, and its not like moral and equipment issues have improved. The us is failing as military power in front of our eyes.

That big stick only worked 50 years ago.

And thanks to donald duck we’re all rearming. I mean it’s not rocket science.

That comments section is such a shitfest I might as well address some points…

People often prioritize “reputation” over other things, as if it is politically actionable or tangible. […]

Another word for “reputation” in this context is “soft power”. Basically, other states are not willing to play along USA, unless forced to. It’s exactly as “actionable” and “tangible” as the ability to force others to do your bidding (hard power).

As such the news should be read as “USA’s soft power is nowadays used toilet paper”.

The problem is that even if the US elects some nice centrist democrats for the 14 years every country is going to be thinking “What if they elect Trump v2?”

The so-called “centrist” democrats are not a relief from the problem. They are part of the problem. As I mentioned in another thread, Trump is not the cause of USA’s decadence, that idiot is at most a symptom. And perhaps a catalyser, since he’s a bit too stupid to hide what preceding presidents were already doing (such as trying to topple governments because they were defending the local interests instead of the cockroaches’. Cue to Allende).

So even if the population of USA elects those so-called “centrists”, any action they take will be seen as a continuation of the Trump regime. It’s over.

Regarding the democrats, I’m not so sure. I mean, yeah, they absolutely are part of the problem, but real politik-wise, I think the rest of the world wants to get back to “business as usual” as fast as possible. The “long term” reputation will still be stained, sure, but democrats will be treated like sensible people if they manage to get the US back to the negotiating table, for however long that may last.

Two different things, I think.

The United States as a rational actor conducting business as usual? That just requires rational people in charge, even if they’re centrist Dems.

The United States as the “leader of the free world”? That idea is as dead as democracy.

And hell, looking back at the America-led 20th century, Trump is doing the world a favor in the long run.

America is displaying an extreme mental illness epidemic. It isn’t just the nazi party and fanatics either. Americas Liberals are also mentally ill; supporting genocide but can’t achieve universal health care, maternity leave, child care, cheap higher education, etc, etc… all of these things indicate extreme corruption and sociopathy permeating American society and politics.

This isn’t something that the world will forget in 4-8. Even if Democrats were to win in a landslide, and prosecuted thousands of republicans and business leaders for their crimes and corruption — all spending the rest of their lives in prison — the world would keep America at arms length for multiple decades.

That’s because you had goodwill, and now it’s used up.

I mean we (I’m in the EU) do/did business with China and Russia (autocratic dictatorships), but that’s it. USA will have to play by the rules now, no more handouts.

Realpolitik-wise, when a state falls down, the others take turns kicking its teeth. And given Trump shredded any soft power USA had, the democrat in question will have two choices: either keep USA tumbling down into irrelevance, or act like the same Trump and use hard power. Because no, that soft power won’t be coming back, other states are simply too suspicious.

Or at least that’s what I predict, I may be wrong.

since he’s a bit too stupid to hide what preceding presidents were already doing

At least the bush administration had the decency to fabricate some evidence.

May never recover? 80 years ago, Germany was split in two and the depths of the holocaust were still sinking into the worldwide consciousness. Given enough time, it absolutely can recover. Probably not in my lifetime, but eventually it might. Or maybe it’ll end up like Yugoslavia, the Soviet Union, or the nation of Taiwan. Wait, that last one hasn’t happened yet… forget I said anything.
There was also a sham of Nuremberg trial, probably changing the outlook towards the German populace.

My man, the Earth has like 20-30 years of habitabiloty left max, and we are not really doing enough and we only started doing it all 30-40 years too late.

The US doesn’t have 80 years to recover thanks to the Climate Crisis.

Fitting that the US is the biggest historical polluter.
Immediately followed by our own military as the second. If you cared to even separate us.

Humanity has survived several mass extinction events. Short of something on the far end of cataclysmic (i.e. “no complex life survives”) humanity will endure. We’re highly adaptable and can eat anything.

That doesn’t mean that most of us will survive, or those that do are going to be having a good time.

The last mass extinction was 65 million years ago and humans are like 0.2 million years old

Late Pleistocene extinctions – 13-50 thousand years ago.

Youngest Toba Eruption – 74 thousand years ago. Almost all of humanity died, with an estimated surviving population of 3 to 10 thousand.

Late Pleistocene extinctions - Wikipedia

Our ancestors survived the last extinction event, you may mean.

Only because they were tiny rodent creatures. We don’t have that luxury.

Late Pleistocene extinctions - Wikipedia

America as the world has known it is dead - there will be no mid terms.

What remains to be seen if how violent the collapse will be. The USSR’s death was pretty anti-climactic, I suspect it will be the same for the US - history doesn’t repeat, but it does rhyme

So the reputation of the post collapse factions/states/republics/dumpster bins etc will be what follows

…and No, we don’t want any states joining Confederation.

YOU are the problem now. If we tell them that we expect the worst from them, and we expect them to do nothing about it, and we expect them to disappoint us AGAIN, that’s exactly what they’ll do. They are politicians, they are inherently lazy, and if you give them permission to fail, they absolutely will, and go back to their insider trading.

We have to stop these sorts of posts, and make them see nothing but righteous indignant fury, and make them understand that we are angry at BOTH parties, and we are more than willing to take out our fury on both of them.

Politicians act out of fear, even more than greed. We have to make them fear us, in every way there is. They need to hear us DEMAND they will do what they are told, or else.

Put your outrage into posts that encourage the citizens, and frighten the politicians.

The revolution doesn’t start until the internet comments are just right.
Right, that was the point. /S

I am the problem?

If you are American, YOU are the problem. You either voted for this baby raping, pencil dicked, power bottom for potus, or you didnt fight hard enough to stop it.

I am not American, thankfully and proudly.

Good luck in your civil war.

Canadians and Thinking Their Shit Doesn’t Stink, more at 11 Tom.
Marg bar Amrika!
Probably the only good thing Trump has done. He ripped off the mask that America was wearing, and showed everybody their true self.
I wish it wasn’t true, but the more I read about the US the worse it gets, all the way back to its golden days and beyond.
It is way worse than even you think it is.
I’m quite aware lol
Sure you are wink
Wait, why wouldn’t I be?

Oh, I am just being silly. I have studied human rights my entire adult life and I only know a fraction of what the US has done and will do.

It would take more than my lifetime to just recite all the lives destroyed and atrocities committed by the US.

Ahh, that makes sense. Yeah, I just recently finished a book on the US military, and holy shit. I knew the gist of their crimes, but knowing the details really puts things in perspective.

My latest kick is environmental crimes and all man is it bad. Leaded gas alone has killed hundreds of millions of people. Not to mention every single human on the planet poisoned with both forever chemicals and plastics.

From participating in multiple genocides to the two greatest murders of civilian in a single day the US knows no modern equal.

Iran winning the war just shows how weak US really is. Best of all, Trump as being a big loser as he is still trying to sell it as he made something big for his country. In reality, however , Iran will get to collect money for every ship going through (up to 70 billion a year), the economy will takes years to recover, the oil facilities will take months to crank up again, the amount of money he spent doing nothing will burden Americans for generations. What a way to be a loser, small hands.