So, since the "the fediverse needs to be open to new ideas" canard is going around again, let's just be clear. AI is not a new idea, it's the oldest idea in the tech industry.

It's the idea that capital can embrace, extend, and extinguish computing, the idea that industry is more important than labor, that the climate crisis is an externality not worth worrying about. AI is the idea that stocks matter more than people.

@xgranade @jwz Fundamentally the argument is "fedi must become exactly like every other space that is overwhelmed with slop". Like, name another network or website that is generally negative about LLMs. This is like arguing every restaurant should be McDonald's. Let fedi be different, please.

https://webcomicname.com/post/185588404109

@skyfaller @xgranade Everybody knows that all restaurants are Taco Bell.
Why Demolition Man Changed Taco Bell to Pizza Hut Outside America

American fans of cult-classic Demolition Man remember Taco Bell as the winner of the franchise wars, but that's not true everywhere.

CBR

@jwz @skyfaller @xgranade but I just woke up after being teleported into a Waffle House.

Does that mean I’m in an alternative reality/simulation?!

@xgranade I agree with your main point, but just to say, in terms of other internet spaces where they go hard on LLMs, I think some of these crazy kids on Lemmy are doing the Lord's work

https://lemmy.world/c/fuck_ai

and in general across other spaces on Lemmy which aren't explicitly about shitting on LLMs, from what I've seen, the takes seem sane the majority of the time.

But I think this fits your point actually: both spaces (Masto & Lemmy) have much less pressure to lick corporate boots, so people tend to get less caught up in this frenzy of claiming their allegiance to the Shiny New Tech Thing

Fuck AI - Lemmy.World

“We did it, Patrick! We made a technological breakthrough!” A place for all those who loathe AI to discuss things, post articles, and ridicule the AI hype. Proud supporter of working people. And proud booer of SXSW 2024. AI, in this case, refers to LLMs, GPT technology, and anything listed as “AI” meant to increase market valuations.

@jbc @xgranade fyi @kimcrawley
🎶 I believe that children are our future… 🎶
🥰
Bless those crazy kids and their #fuckai goodness :)
@skyfaller the existence of any space that does not reaffirm Received Truth is inherently a threat to it
@xgranade @jwz
@erisceleste @skyfaller @xgranade @jwz The guy that did it is on the core Mastodon team and said it was a slippery slope to not want people here and then tried to say this is why Black Twitter left. You can find him because I repplied to his thread sigh
@skyfaller @xgranade @jwz The Fediverse not being drenched in slop is definitely a feature, not a bug, in my book.