No Right Is Ever Safe – but Progress Is Possible

The outrageous assault on birthright citizenship should prompt us to reflect on the fragility of democratic progress - and our own responsibility to defend it.

Some thoughts from my new piece:

https://steady.page/en/democracyamericana/posts/0999474f-9069-4edc-8afa-14ba857741fa

No Right Is Ever Safe – but Progress Is Possible

The outrageous assault on birthright citizenship should prompt us to reflect on the fragility of democratic progress - and our own responsibility to defend it

Steady

“We shall repeal the twentieth century”: That is how self-identified “radical reactionary” Murray Rothbard described the Right’s vision in 1992.

That really is the core of Trumpism as a political project: Roll back whatever racial and social progress has been achieved over the past century and a half.

That’s also the context for the outlandish assault on birthright citizenship: No measure of social, political, and legal advancement of the past one hundred and fifty years – nothing the mainstream would broadly consider “progress” – is safe.
It’s not like we needed another reminder that all the rights and civil liberties that turned the United States into anything approaching a pluralistic democracy are at risk – or that taking refuge in the idea that “they wouldn’t go *that* far” is utterly foolish.
In 2022, the Roberts Court stripped roughly half the population of reproductive freedom and the right to bodily self-determination; and the Right has been massively successful at hollowing out both the 1964 Civil Rights Act as well as the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
The reactionary political project seeks to turn the clock back to *before* the Reconstruction Amendments – to re-orient government towards privileging the rights of those already at the top, to deprive government of any tool that could serve to level discriminatory hierarchies.
No measure of progress is safe. This is also how RFK’s crusade against the public health infrastructure ties into the Right’s broader project: “Make America Healthy Again” is an assault on modern medicine, modern science – on some of the pillars of modern society itself.

The realization of how fragile democratizing progress is should make us appreciate and celebrate it more, not less.

Only if we value the progress that has been achieved do we understand what we must defend.

The lesson from U.S. history, if there is one, is not that progress is impossible. There has been tremendous progress at times!

But we must not assume directionality in history. There is no arc, there is no linear progression, no utopian end goal we are somehow destined to reach.

That is why Reconstruction is such a key historical reference. America’s first attempt at biracial democracy was quickly drowned in ostensibly “race-neutral” laws and escalating white supremacist violence. It took a century to get the country back to that level of democracy.

We need to accept that things can change – in either direction: It really could get much, much worse. But it could also get better.

There is nothing inevitable about either doom or progress. We are neither fated nor guaranteed to experience the status quo for all eternity.

This realization is deeply unsettling: There is no moral arc of the universe, progress can always be reversed, victories are never guaranteed to last.

But it should also be empowering and, at the very least, create the sense of urgency that is needed to propel America forward.

Let us believe them when they say they want to “repeal the twentieth century.”

Whether or not enough people can be convinced to defend the vision of egalitarian pluralism with equal ferocity and conviction may well decide the fate of democracy.

@tzimmer_history

The American war of independence was a thing.

I would like to remind people that the 13 colonies waged a war of independence against the world‘s richest man at the time and his corporation the East India company.

Just saying

@GhostOnTheHalfShell

Yes, but surely the later Civil War was a desperate attempt by the (then) rich dudes to protect their new-found wealth, privilege, and ability to own and profit from slaves? Not so very far from where the US is now, methinks. Y'all may need to get around to finishing that off, probably with guillotines.

@tzimmer_history

@bytebro @tzimmer_history

Oh something like we’re going to party like it’s 1789

@tzimmer_history You missed "in America". Americans aren't the only people in the Fediverse.