I don't trust people who don't like cats.
(Before I get a lot of arguments here, not liking cats is not the same as avoiding them because you're allergic).
I don't trust people who don't like cats because the reason almost always boils down to some variation of cats not being obedient and unfailingly fawning. It feels like a personality litmus test if your requirement for enjoying a creature is that it must always obey you and adore you.
(And before I get a lot of other arguments, being neutral on cats is not the same as not liking cats. I specifically mean people who say, "I don't like cats")
