I was surprised when 4 minutes of whole-tone-ish 50s sci fi emerged. šŸ˜…

@Cognessence the ring motion detection sound fit in well too!

at a couple of points i was almost ready to start hearing hints of oscar peterson's version of maidens of cadiz but then you took it into a different direction, love it

@miunau Hah, yeah - the sound felt predestined!

Less so my mum walking around...the kind of walking that says, "I'm not saying anything, but am saying in my not-saying 'stop'..." šŸ˜…

Thank you for listening. šŸ™

@Cognessence Love this! And it works despite nothing falling at the end! :D
@changterhune thanks so much! But yes - the lack of flowers / candles etc. flying off the piano in disgust was almost disappointing at this stage. šŸ˜†

@changterhune We're still hoping you do a remix of the plant attack recording

@Cognessence

@Cognessence why is the door blocked by a lamp?
@sfn A really important question, David. It remains a vast mystery, and I don’t know the answer. :-(

@sfn Okay, I found out the answer to this from my wife: my mother lost the key to that door about 20 years ago. And thus, rather than doing something about the key, covered the pain of it by putting a lamp in front of it. So it would never be used again.

Quite a chilling tale, really.

@Cognessence lol u made it sound like a horror story

@sfn To me, denying a door its rights is a horror story.

I'm just feeling for the door, is all.

Too many doors remain shut. Their pain echoes throughout the ages...🚪 šŸ’”

@Cognessence
One thing I think your improvisations have in common with a lot of my music is that, while I wouldn’t call it jazz and don’t think it’s trying to be, the harmonies often taste jazz-fed in a way I like. (50s-ish whole-tone-ish = Monkish to my ears—at least the harmonies, not so much the gestures or rhythms.)

@mcmullin Thanks - that’s a really interesting and observant point, and the relationship to jazz is something I’ve often thought about. But how you’ve framed it (with a wording I’d not thought of at all) is so excellent: ā€œthe harmonies tasting jazz fed.ā€ Because like you, I feel no pull toward explicitly playing in that territory - and when people reference jazz pieces as a comparison my feeling is that the music isn’t really being ā€œheardā€. But yes; to say the tonal language carries no aspects of those influences would be a kind of wilful denial! šŸ˜…

It’s lovely too to hear that you improvise in these ā€œjazz fedā€ worlds. I imagine you’re also drawn to a sort of post-Romantic tonal dissolve that Impressionism drew from? (and jazz kind of later absorbed in its own way.) Probably what we gravitate toward is that less codified pool - where the harmony carries emotional ambiguity without the rhythmic and idiomatic commitments that give jazz its *particular* identity.

PS - not at all saying I enact the results successfully. The above is a later reading. The rest is dependent on the day, limits, joints and (im)patience of the person whose piano I’m borrowing. šŸ˜…

@Cognessence

If I had kept my trombone chops up, I would definitely play more in a jazz style—on the exploratory side, not necessarily straight-ahead, but with undisguised roots in jazz. And if I had jazz musicians wanting to play my compositions, I’d compose more jazz for them. But I mostly work with classical musicians, so I try to write to their strengths. Still, it all has some relationship to jazz, though it’s rarely explicit or on the surface.

@Cognessence

You’re right though that if it only draws on jazz harmony, without jazz inflection, phrasing and rhythmic idioms—and without improv—then it’s probably really closer to post-impressionist or free-atonal classical music. To me it feels like a big part of my musical language comes from jazz, but I wouldn’t expect jazz heads to think so.

David McMullin (@[email protected])

Secret tip: If you take almost any line in one of my ā€œclassicalā€ scores and play it with the feel, accents and inflections of post-bop jazz, it will work, and will sound closer to the way I hear it. https://musicians.today/@mcmullin/113686795827733483

Musicians Today