#ScribesAndMakers Feb. 6: Our featured creator makes graphic novels. As a reader, which do you think is more important in a graphic novel, art or words?
Both are essential.
There's more to writing than words. Art can convey plenty, but you have to write that art. There's also more to words than text. I've done webcomics. Typesetting is an art in its own right; sound effects would lose all their impact if they were just put in the same comic font as everything else; bubbles can express emotion.
And, of course, absolutely no one is going to read a graphic novel if the writing is garbage, whether that's done in words or not. People will get bored of the art, the same way they'll be left confused or unsatisfied if the art is garbage. A graphic novel has the air of expectation hanging around it. A manufactured legitimacy, sure, but no one's buying xkcd off newsstands.
The idea that a good finished product isn't a gestalt for which the removal of any component leaves the rest lesser is short-sighted.




