There are a few really popular accounts here on the Fediverse that I muted some time ago. It’s not that I don’t understand why folks follow them, it’s more that I couldn’t understand why I felt like those accounts bothered me so much. I mean…it’s folks like Robert Reich and George Takei so it’s certainly not a content issue, and I love reading them under other circumstances.

It took me a while to tease it out and it ultimately comes down to the difference between the Fediverse and sites like Twitter.

When I had an account there I rarely posted anything and after a few attempts to participate in conversations, realized that I was whispering at a Throbbing Gristle concert and no one was hearing me.

So when you look at accounts like Robert Reich or George Takei, they’re not actually here, they’re just mirrors of content they write elsewhere. So even though I see people responding to those posts as if they’re writing to a specific person, they might as well be replying to a bot.

Take as a counterpoint folks like @RickiTarr or @TheBreadmonkey. Very popular accounts, thousands of followers, but they’re actually here, they’re a part of the ecosystem and will boost, reply, favorite, etc.

I love that about this wild, weird, little slice of internet. I think that’s why I muted folks like Robert Reich, they’re not actually here to interact, they’re ultimately not a part of the community. They’re just here so they can access us, not interact with us. That’s not why I’m here. If I reply to someone, I want to know there’s a high likelihood they see it, whether or not they choose to respond to it.
--
ETA: A few folks have pointed out that they've gotten replies from George Takei so it seems that this is more my personal experience there and there is at least a human on the other end of the posts which I'm glad to be wrong about as I adore George Takei.

@monkeyninja @RickiTarr @TheBreadmonkey I totally hear this, and would only add in the cases of people like Takei - and no shade on him personally, because I truly adore him as a creative and as a public figure and I support his work out there - but even on the other platforms I've never really believed it was actually him writing posts or participating in the discussions.

I'm on social media to connect with people. I've never been on social media to follow people's staffs.

@Rob_T_Firefly @RickiTarr @TheBreadmonkey That's true too, I hadn't thought of that. I think even if a staffer were replying to things that people wrote in response to those posts that I might still give it a pass because likewise, I adore George Takei. As I said to someone else, it feels performative...like taking a photo in front of the cartoon elephant and then going home to live in your mansion.
@monkeyninja @RickiTarr @TheBreadmonkey Here's a relevant clip of Brent Spiner talking about William Shatner's Twitter presence, scroll to 1:13 or so. https://youtu.be/LRCN9Toi-Ck
BRENT SPINER Remembers the Time ‘WILLIAM SHATNER’ Flipped Out On Him

YouTube

@Rob_T_Firefly @monkeyninja @RickiTarr

This is the actual William Shatner and I am FURIOUS about this