Jesus Michał "Le Sigh" 🏔 (he)Mar 21

My first instaban for #slop PR to #Gentoo.

Normally, we warn people first, but here it's clearly an untested (and obviously broken) slop contribution by non-Gentoo user trying to push their software all over the place.

https://github.com/gentoo/guru/pull/450

#NoAI #NoLLM

app-misc/tangi: add Tangi local AI assistant with RAG by mreinrt · Pull Request #450 · gentoo/guru

Add Tangi - hardware-aware local AI assistant with RAG for codebases This PR adds: app-misc/tangi: Tangi v1.0.0 dev-python/llama-cpp-python: 0.3.16 (with OpenBLAS support) Tangi is a local AI ass...

GitHub
Show threadJayF
@mgorny regardless of the quality of the pr, it's extremely irresponsible to put llm generated changes to a repository without checking if they permit them. With Gentoo being one of the first large open source projects to ban LLM contributions, I find it hard to believe that the human who pointed that bot at us and the model itself was completely unaware of that policy.
Mar 21 at 1:02pmWeb
Show threadJayFMar 21
@mgorny I know you and I don't agree generally on use of these tools and projects that permit them, but we can all agree that people who don't give enough of a damn to look at the basic rules of something they are contributing to are committing harm.
Show threadJesus Michał "Le Sigh" 🏔 (he)Mar 21
@jay, maybe they wanted to gloat "Hey, I managed to get slop into Gentoo!"
Show threadJayFMar 21
@mgorny eh. I read it more as the typical entitled "I did free work" PR, where folks who don't understand open source think dropping PRs with code nobody asked for makes them a hero. Community first, code changes second.