I post these dailies to the /r/ArtJournaling subreddit and normally people are VERY into them. This one created a minor shitstorm and they criticized me for ruining the environment, even blocked me. The comments got turned off by a moderator.

I forgot how emotional and black-and-white thinking some parts of the internet are. Kind of makes me not want to post there anymore.

@marcel For some context: OpenAI is the largest of ALL of Trump's donors. Anthropic even is complicit in war crimes: the psychopaths in the US department of war gave Claude all the information they have about Iran and asked Claude where it "thinks" they should drop their bomb. Claude replied "there" and the USA dropped their bomb "there". Turns out "there" was an elementary school and they killed 165 little girls. Perplexity powers "Truth" Social for Trump. Microsoft (Copilot) and Google (Gemini) are enabling a genocide in Gaza that productivity-minded people prefer to ignore.

LLMs and "AI" agents are inherently a fascist technology, in addition to destroying our inhabitable spaces. By paying for these tools, vibe coders are literally funding fascism. AI companies are monsters that literally want to end our lives in exchange for money. This is a dealbreaker for rational people. So this has nothing to do with people being "emotional" and that they should read some book about stoicism and learn to control their emotions. There just is no more need to discuss nuance when the technology on its face is already so obviously a fascist technology.

While for some, LLMs are just a fun toy or useful tool, especially the gay and trans people are currently murdered by what LLM companies represent. This is why there is no middle ground where funding the companies behind LLMs is acceptable. That's one explanation why they blocked you. Not because they never read Cal Newport, but because your use of "AI" is literally a threat to their survival. And yours too.

@davidculley @marcel you really need to add ”American“ in front of your sentences calling all AI companies fascist. Maybe some more countries too. Just pretending there are no alternatives actually helps them, you could name a few alternatives, such as Mistral and Infomaniak.
@stairjoke “American”? Like the whole continent?
@raphaelfyi no, as in the often used American for US. Duh… like that wasn’t obvious and you’re actually confused. I used American, to link it to to the defaultism of the OP.

@stairjoke What @raphaelfyi is getting at: There is more to the two American continents than the USA.

The people from Peru, Chile, Brazil, Colombia, Panama, Argentina, Mexico, Canada, etc. would like very much if you didn't equate them with the USA.

Thus the "US-American".

@stairjoke Democracy requires regulation and bureaucracy. These things can be overdone and often are overdone in grotesque ways, but a minimum level of them is nevertheless required to prevent enemies of democracy from undermining democracy and hijacking it.

Proponents of "AI" are saying all this bureaucracy is inefficient and needs to be cut. And to be replaced by a LLM. Who needs rules for democratic governance anymore when you can just ask the machine god what it thinks? After all, LLMs don't have an ideology, unlike humans, right? They were trained on data instead of emotions and just tell you what the hard data says, without ideology. Right? Wrong! The vast training corpi of LARGE language models are full of biases and ideologies. You cannot avoid it in corpi that large. And fascists are using this technology to come up with anything, to create a mythical past to which we need to return. Like the story of the "First Reich" and "Second Reich" that Goebbels sold to Germans and which resulted in the Third Reich.

You could argue that fascists eat bread, so aren't bread making machines inherently fascist? No. LLMs though are used to devalue all labor and deskill laborers, and to concentrate power in the hands of the few who have the vast resources required to train the LLMs, which goes completely against democracy.

In their world, nobody has power anymore and everyone needs to rent from them if they need labor to be done. Sam Altman said this himself.

Doing away with democratic processes and governance and accountability in the name of "efficiency". Make everyone addicted to LLMs. And then have figures like Elon Musk or whoever change the parameters to produce child porn or fascist indoctrination.

This doesn't change when you replace the specific LLM providers I mentioned with others (even non-US ones).

Wenzel, your view alas is very naive.

By the way, OpenClawd of which even its creator says maybe it was a mistake to create it, was created by an Austrian guy, Peter Steinberger. It's not an "American" phenomenon.

@marcel For your next book, may I suggest "Resisting AI" by Dan MacQuillan? Then you will have a better understanding of why you received a shitstorm.

One of the end goals of LLMs is to make computer hardware so expensive that no consumer will be able to own a computer anymore. Noticed the RAM and SSD prices?

Then AWS can sell you rented access to the computers in the cloud.

It's all about taking things AWAY from you/us. Yet somehow people still talk about how this is "democratizing knowledge/art/skill".

https://climatejustice.social/@terminaltilt/115896899179047548

Terminal Tilt (@[email protected])

Jeff Bezos is saying the quiet part out loud. They want to kill local computing. You will own nothing and be happy. You will rent your computing power from the cloud. You pay a subscription for the privilege of using a computer. AI demand is artificially spiking DRAM prices and Big Tech is pushing "AI PCs," the squeeze is on to force us into a rental model. Reject this future. :NoAI: Keep your hardware local. Run #Linux. :tux: Own your data. The "cloud" is just a landlord for your data. #NoAi #FOSS #OpenSource #Privacy #SelfHost #SelfHosting #BigTech #RightToRepair #RAM #Amazon #EatTheRich https://www.windowscentral.com/artificial-intelligence/jeff-bezos-says-the-quiet-part-out-loud-bezos-envisions-that-youll-give-up-your-pc-for-an-ai-cloud-version

Climate Justice Social

@marcel
lol here is leagues much more 'emotional and black-and-white' by that particular metric.

the truth is that this is just the world now, it's how a *lot* of people genuinely feel about AI there is no cleanly waving them away as unreasonable and emotional. well anyway I like your posts here, but be prepared for minor or major shitstorm anytime AI comes up.

@R3yScale thank you for explaining Mastodon to me! Here's something you might not now: I can block and mute people on Mastodon. That's not possible in Reddit threads.

@marcel
Cool, I guess you could block and mute half the fediverse if that's what you'd rather.

Or they've already done it to you and I'm just now realising why, every day's a learning day!

@R3yScale No need, I got a nice little corner of level-headed people going on over here. Thank you for your concern, though!
@marcel
you're one boost away from disaster but anyway I'm taking my emotional and black-&-white (read: concerned with basic human decency and vocal about it) ass out of your corner lol