Touchscreen keyboards in place of physical keyboards were a mistake.
I mean, sure, you could carry around a bluetooth keyboard with you that would work on damn near anything, but we already had it good over a decade ago. ​
Concept - Phone screens and their aspect ratios don't need to match what's used in popular media, especially if it accommodates something as useful as a physical keyboard.
But also, the UI needs to not be crowded as fuck

We had a decent compromise with the BlackBerry Passport, but BBOS was already on its way out. The keyboard doubling as touch-sensitive so it could be used as a cursor was pretty cool, though!

@maddy They do, they really really do.

There are currently at least two non portrait keyboard phones in existence, and a third one on its way. I've had more than one recent non portrait keyboard phone.

It's a huge pain. Android design guidelines say applications need to cater for different aspect ratios. The reality is it doesn't work. Too many applications are designed to expect a portrait orientation, and the 'mini mode' to squeeze portrait into a non portrait phone for misbehaving apps never entirely works either.

Tried it for years, gave up. Now on a Pixel 9 with a Clicks keyboard case which isn't ideal, but I have zero display and compatibility issues.

@maddy bring back slide out keyboards!
@Chloe @maddy The Nokia N900 was the best phone I ever had! It could have used an extra row though, but I'd take its dinky 3 rows over no rows, thankyouverymuch.
@ozzelot Ooh, that looks like a neat device!
@maddy It ran maemo, a debian-based OS. I did some linux learning on it when nothing else was nearby. There was hope in the thing, squandered by the already clearly winning goopple duopoly, but hope nonetheless.
@maddy I guess Microsoft was a little bit of a player around the time I used my N900 the most (2012 - 13), but come on, WP had it way rough.
@ozzelot Really cool that it was its own sorta thing while Android was just starting to find its footing!
Windows Phone would've been cool if they didn't totally give up (and some of the larger app developers didn't collude to avoid the platform), but also, Microsoft - eww!

@maddy The N900 came from a somewhat long line of Nokia Internet Tablets and was the first and last phone to run Maemo*, the N9 and N950 ran Meego. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nokia_Internet_Tablet&useskin=vector

*not counting Maemo Leste, which is still in active development today

Nokia Internet Tablet - Wikipedia

@Chloe I feel like the BlackBerry Torch pulled this off particularly well!
@maddy really i just want a galaxy s but modern
@maddy was my first smartphone, actually
@Chloe I can't remember which came first, but I had a BlackBerry Tour and a Motorola Q as my first smartphones.

Holy fuck the Moto was clunky (early Windows Mobile x_x)
@Chloe @maddy this was peak phone design
@ShadowInTheVoid @Chloe @maddy I agree, despite the screen being a bit small. 1
@maddy I was hoping by now (somehow??) we'd have like haptic touch buttons where the on-screen buttons are physically raised so that you could feel them
@JoshJers I feel like the engineering and risk of wear that would involve would be absurd, but that would be cool (and probably a lot better than what we have now)!
@maddy oh for sure, there are reasons that it's *not* a thing but dammit I would love it if it were 😁
@maddy My apartment building replaced all the locks with key pads a few years ago. The problem? They’re capacitive touch key pads. It’s so easy to accidentally brush against the wrong number, and the numbers don’t even light up reliably!
@maddy the last slide-out I had was this older Motorola thing. it was disappointing sadly. build quality was poor. slider felt jiggly. they didn't care and were racing to the price floor.
@maddy Yes. Though touchscreens themselves can be very useful.