Proton is generally regarded as a secure email service and this might be true regarding encryption and data storage. But now Proton has collaborated with the FBI and handed over payment data to identify the owner of an email account.

And guess what … The owner of the account was not a paedophile or a terrorist, it was an activists connected to the protest movement „Stop Cop City“

Of course, Proton acted accordingly to Swiss law but considering that this not a single case and Proton is always promoting their location in Switzerland as trustworthy, I would recommend to use something else, probably not even email.

But if you’re using it, follow some basic rules:

1. No recovery data like email or phone numbers.

2. Use a VPN (keep in mind that the VPN provider knows who you are and that a VPN might not be as secure as you think)

3. Don’t use banking accounts for payment. If possible, use Monero or Cash.

4. Don’t use your secret email for anything else. The more often you use it, the more traces you leave.

5. Consider using a messenger for sensitive communication. My personal recommendation is Molly.

@Tutanota How often per year do you get these requests from authorities and how often do you follow them?

#protonmail #stopcopcity #privacy #surveillancestate #digitalrights #activism

https://www.heise.de/en/news/Proton-FBI-user-identification-shakes-Swiss-data-protection-11203086.html

Proton: FBI user identification shakes Swiss data protection

US investigators obtained payment data from a Proton account via legal assistance. Service points to strict Swiss legal regulations.

heise online
@NebulaTide proton is better than google, but they are not ideal as one would lead you to believe

@NebulaTide @Tutanota people should finally stop fantasies about software XYZ would be more secure/private than another, just because it's hosted or owned by a swiss company.

Swiss is historically known for protection wealthy tax avoiding individuals, not for protecting your peasant data or standing in for digital freedoms.

@NebulaTide Have we completely forgotten the Proton CEO's praise of US Republican party and giving IP addresses to the French police? https://techstory.in/proton-mail-faces-backlash-over-claims-of-political-neutrality-amid-ceos-praise-for-republican-party/
Proton Mail Faces Backlash Over Claims of Political Neutrality - TechStory

Proton Mail is in the center of controversy after its CEO, made statements on social media that appeared to favor the Republican Party,

TechStory

@NebulaTide The Proton case shows the payment layer is the Achilles heel of most privacy setups. Even end-to-end encrypted email leaks identity if you paid with a credit card.

The fix is simple in principle: pay with Monero. No name, no billing address, no link to your bank. Proton accepts it. Mullvad accepts it. Tutanota accepts it. Most people just never use it.

thaddeus e. grugq on Twitter

“I’m gonna tell you a secret about “logless VPNs” — they don’t exist. Noone is going to risk jail for your $5/mo https://t.co/Q2aOQJkG4g”

Twitter