Does anybody have (good) experience with learning languages via self-study/online?

I've previously tried Duolingo but didn't really like it, and it's gamification. I could give it another try.

But I don't know if there are any other trustworthy online resources (I don't mind paying fees if it's trustworthy).

I've never been good with learning other languages, so I don't think picking up books will be enough, but it might be the way to go instead of online resources.

#learning #language #selfstudy

@alsvha I've found https://www.languagetransfer.org/ quite interesting. It's a bit esoteric the website and not that well "productized" but it's free. 😄 If those available languages are a match, then try it out!
Language Transfer

Language Transfer
@henrik Thanks for the link - I will take a look. German was one of the possible languages I was thinking of, and can see it on their list.
@henrik @alsvha I was just checking the thread to see if anyone had recommended Language Transfer yet. The way it works maps well to how my brain handles languages and language learning, so I really enjoy it.

@alsvha my very limited experience trying to learn some basic Russian: Duolingo is utterly useless, Babel is ok. It has way less gamification and actually explains things to you.

I think at some point you need to try to talk to native speakers. I have heard good things (but not tried myself) about italki for this, in case native speakers are not around you.

@lucha Thanks - I'll try to take a look at those two.

And yeah, huge difference with the actual native speaking, but gotta start somewhere :D

@alsvha I saw that you’ve gotten into K-pop. If you’d like to focus on Korean, I found the “Quick Korean” YouTube channel helpful. Its content consists of four courses taught by the Cyber University of Korea. The first is available in multiple languages, but the other three are in Korean only (though subtitles can be enabled). The easiest way to find them is to go to the channel’s playlists and look for 바른 한국어. Searching for that will also pull up the channel directly.

If gamification is helpful, I would recommend LingoDeer for its focus on grammar. Some languages, like Korean, have more content than others, but the foundation I’ve gotten from the courses I’ve gone through has been enough to either give me the confidence to use a language outright on something like HelloTalk or to facilitate my search for books or other resources.

@KGRedrum KPop/Music was one of the reasons it could be interesting to learn a bit of the Korean language yes.

I'll check out the youtube you mention and see - sounds like a chill way into something.

Thanks for your experiences and the inspiration :)

@alsvha

Search in youtube for: Easy <language you're interested in>

E.g. Easy Brazilian Portuguese

(but something like Duolingo might be useful to learn the basics first)

@sibrosan Thanks. That might be an easy way to start up something.
I'll see what I find :)
@alsvha from my personal experience, the best approach to begin learning is to find a grammar manual to study the basic rules and a flashcards app to learn and practice vocabulary

@clabru Thanks for your comment.
I can see that it might be a way, but I'm generally not good with grammar, so it might be a harsh introduction and something I'd build on if gaining a basic understanding.

A flashcard-type app for basic vocabulary is likely more my route.
I'll search some youtube and similar. :)

@alsvha

If you're looking for a more general language learning app, Babbel could be a good an alternative to Duolingo, but with less gamification. The company is based in Berlin and employs thousands of people.

Since I read in another comment that you would like to learn German, you could try the free version of Lingoni first (lingoni.com/). The founder has a YouTube channel where she provides free lessons and explains concepts really well: youtube.com/@lingoniGERMAN. If you subscribe to language teachers like her (she has build her own platform later and hired other teachers), you won't be giving your money to corporations that are investing heavily in AI to replace language teachers. 😀

lingoni – The best online language courses from A1-B2

@veroandi
Babbel does seem interesting.

Will check out your other links as well. (And I would not be opposed to support non-AI :D)
Thank you.

@alsvha i have been having a lot of success with https://www.lingq.com

it's not very gamified. no 'lessons' as such. you just get real text, read it with dictionary popup, review words if you want or just keep reading. start out with basic intro texts, but you can import any article, pdf, ebook, youtube video (if it has subtitles) - meaning you can read material that is of interest to you personally, not only arbitrary lesson text.

it has helped me anyway.

LingQ

Learning Languages Online

@picard Thanks for the link and experience. I'll add it to the ones to check out :)
@alsvha you're very welcome
@alsvha It would probably be easier to recommend something if you mention which language(s) you are interested in as most good learning resources focus on a limited number of languages.
@trezzer yeah, you're right.
I just don't really have a "plan" yet, but was thinking of German (for usefulness), or something for me exotic (and mostly just for fun) like Korean or Thai :)

@alsvha yes, I've learnt German to around a B1-B2 level.

I finished the German course on Duolingo, but that was before the AI slop came.

Pick and choose from the following:
Busuu (freemium app with structured course)
Language Transfer (free audio course)
Coffee Break German (freemium audio course)
Easy German (YouTube videos with bilingual subtitles, podcast in German) - this is the best resource IMHO. You can get transcripts and worksheets as a paid member.

Viel Glück!

@alsvha also, the books "Fluent in 3 months" and "Fluent forever" have some good general tips on language learning. "Language Hacking: German" has some quick tips on grammar etc.
@alsvha I went to the library and checked out a book with CD.
@Tamtam Hmm - good idea - might check if I can reserve/book something from my local.
@alsvha read children’s stories/picture books/comics with a translation dictionary, watch shows/movies with subtitles, listen to the news in your target language

@sidereal I'm trying to watch stuff (even trying Netflix again for that reason) - and I listen to music.

Hoping to pick up some - at least - audio queues from it as I get more familiar with the alphabet :D

@alsvha I have used ASSIMIL for a few languages and really like it. I have only used their book+audio sets, but they now have apps with the same content. If I were to start a new language now, I'd probably try the app version.

@alsvha Depends on what language you want to learn, but I think the Coffee Break people have a great format between podcasts/videos you can do for free, and then paid versions give you access to word lists and other guidance.

There's probably even more available now. My description is based on embracing them in the early days nearly 20 yrs ago.

https://coffeebreaklanguages.com/

Introducing Coffee Break Languages

Learn a language in just 15 minutes a day with Coffee Break Languages! Enjoy our relaxed, engaging method that feels like chatting with a friend.

Coffee Break Languages

@alsvha The Easy German channel is very appealing and apparently they also have value-added language learning options.

I'm not sure how many other languages there are, but I found an Easy Greek channel as well.

https://www.youtube.com/@EasyGerman

Easy German

Learn German with 🎥 videos, 🎙️ podcasts, 📝 exercises, 🗣️ conversation calls and more! VIDEOS We produce videos from the streets of Berlin and beyond for beginners, intermediate and advanced learners. Our videos have subtitles in German and English so you can follow along and deepen your learning experience. 🔎 PODCAST In the Easy German Podcast Cari and Manuel discuss every day life in Germany. Most podcast episodes are audio only. Special episodes are produced as a video and can be found here on YouTube. Search for "Easy German" on your favorite podcast app or go to http://www.easygerman.fm to find all episodes! 📲 MEMBERSHIP Check out our brand new membership platform! As an Easy German member you can practice your written and spoken German in our Discord community, access transcripts, download videos and make real progress with our interactive exercises! 👩🏻‍💻 All links are below 👇 😃

YouTube

@meganL Thanks for the link.

I'm current trying to dabble into Korean, but I'll bookmark that link cause it looks interesting.