Regulator 'dropped the ball' by dismissing complaints about gynaecologist's practices, expert says

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-02-24/endometriosis-surgeon-simon-gordon-ahpra-complaints-four-corners/106376338

> Australia's medical regulator, AHPRA, faces criticism for failing to act on complaints from patients about surgeries by Melbourne gynaecologist Simon Gordon. 

'Your word against his': Women's complaints against surgeon dismissed by regulator

Australia's medical regulator, AHPRA, faces criticism for failing to act on complaints from patients about surgeries by Melbourne gynaecologist Simon Gordon. 

This is absurd????
"The professor said when a senior colleague of theirs had tried to approach AHPRA about Dr Gordon in the past the colleague had been told AHPRA did not want doctor-led complaints and that the complaints had to come from the patients, so the professor advised Claire and Sophie to contact the regulator directly."

"She then spoke with an AHPRA investigator and Claire said she was told that it was rare for the regulator to seek independent expert advice and that they usually just relied on the explanation from the doctor."

JFC.

@3TomatoesShort

Senior #AHPRA need to explain the huge gap between community (and professional) expectations of rigorous investigation and the "wet paper bag" investigations that AHPRA is delivering.

Good looking bios.
Quality of investigations?
Board:
#GillCallister PSM
#ArieFreiberg
#LyntonNorris
#JeffreyMoffet
#CarmenParter
#AndrewBrown
#PatriciaDavidson
#TanyaMcGregor
#LeanneOShannessy PSM

Management
#JustinUntersteiner CEO

#APS #AustralianPublicService #AusPol
https://www.ahpra.gov.au/About-Ahpra/Who-We-Are/Ahpra-Board/Member-Profiles.aspx#

@skua @3TomatoesShort i reported an Occupational Practioner who worked in the rubber industry, and english wasn't a language she was strong in. Needless to say she had difficulty understanding neuro diversity, workplace expectation and medication which assist me functioning day to day.
When i reported that i had an unfair assessment, along with a note from my phsyciatrist outlining how she didnt grasp the nuance. They sided with the practitioner.

@Gh0stlyM0use @3TomatoesShort

AHPRA looking very ineffective there.
Competency in communication is essential.
That AHPRA is letting communication incompetency past is dangerous and harmful.

Wonder where they were when the following was happening?
(Post on unnecessary endometriosis surgeries on women in Victoria.)
#AusPol #Victoria #FourCorners #FourCornersABC
https://aus.social/@glent/116122860936585026

Glen T, heated, not stirred (@[email protected])

The closing quote from Victoria's Premier is to the point. 10.12 AEDT Victoria government says new guidelines coming for endometriosis diagnosis Benita Kolovos Guardian Australia The Victorian premier, Jacinta Allan, has announced the government will standardise the guidelines for diagnosing endometriosis, with ultrasounds to become the 'first step' in identifying the condition. The announcement follows a [Australian ABC TV] Four Corners report on Monday night into allegations of unnecessary endometriosis surgeries on women. Allan said she was 'sickened' by the allegations and referred them to Victoria police: "Without commenting on the specific case, let me be clear – performing unnecessary surgery is a crime, removing a woman’s organs without a clinical need is a crime, and assisting in that conduct is a crime." She said Safer Care Victoria – the state’s health watchdog – will sit on the review ordered by Epworth 'to ensure it is rigorous, transparent and focused on patient safety'. Safer Care Victoria will also publish clinical guidelines, making it clear that a less invasive ultrasound should be the first step for diagnosing endometriosis across Victoria. Allan said an invasive laparoscopy was often being used as the first diagnostic tool, 'despite growing evidence that it is not always necessary.' She said that the government would also provide additional training to help doctors recognise and appropriately treat endometriosis. She added that she was exploring the introduction of a 'pink tick' to indicate which clinicians have completed the training. "It’s extraordinary that I should even need to propose such a thing, because women’s care is core business. But I am determined to restore confidence in a system that all women rely on."

Aus.Social
@skua @3TomatoesShort And people suffering from endo have enough shit to jump through to get a diagnosis and appropriate care. Its a horrible situation all round.
@Gh0stlyM0use
@skua
I'm sorry :(
I'm failing to see the point of them at all, if there is no requirement for them to seek independent advice from qualified experts, rather than just saying to the person being investigated "are you sure you didn't do anything wrong?" 😶
@3TomatoesShort @skua they go through the notes reports, etc. But it's a self-serving system at the end of the day designed to protect the practitioners, not the patient... oops sorry meant to say client.

@3TomatoesShort @Gh0stlyM0use
AIUI:
AHPRA do check that registered practitioners can fill out forms in a timely manner and will enforce requirements for things like adequate patient history and treatment recording.

[grimmace] Is that the minimum standard that the community wants from registered health professionals?

No, we want much, much more.

AHPRA seems to be giving consumers false confidence. And to be letting practitioners run amok.
#AusPol #PublicHealth #HealthRegulation

@skua @3TomatoesShort I love how we are now consumers and not patients. It really lets you know what the priorities are.
@Gh0stlyM0use @3TomatoesShort
It ties in, I think, with the concept of Patient Led Medicine. Which sounds all very nice until you wonder if Passenger Led Aircraft Piloting is really what you want or if you think that the expert people with high quality training and decades of experience are better at flying airplanes.
#PatientLedMedicine
@skua
@Gh0stlyM0use
Yeah that does not sound great - when you are unwell, why would you want to be the one *leading* your healthcare? It's hard enough just to deal with symptoms and daily life!

@3TomatoesShort @Gh0stlyM0use

How to do Patient Led Medicine:

Oncologist: What do you want to do?

Patient: We'll both take ketamine and then choreograph dances around how the fundamental interconnectedness of everything relates to human consciousness, death and all my desires.

#DirkGently #SvladCjelli #PatientLedMedicine

@skua @3TomatoesShort it should be 'patient first.' I feel the word 'lead' was possibly not the best one for the situation.
@Gh0stlyM0use
@skua
I have heard patient-centred before, but that also raises my cynicism, as I feel like that should just be the norm, not some special thing to aim for.

@3TomatoesShort @Gh0stlyM0use
In many ways it should be the norm.
But seems some Victorian obstetricians might have had higher priorities.
I do wonder how much of the "consumers", "patient led" & "patient centered" is aimed at the doctors, trying to get through centuries of "the divine right of doctors".

And there is also funding, budget allocations and staffing that bear directly on who or what is actually being centred.