📣 Germany's close to reversing its opposition to mass surveillance & private message scanning, & backing the Chat Control bill. This could end private comms-& Signal-in the EU.

Time's short and they're counting on obscurity: please let German politicians know how horrifying their reversal would be.

@Mer__edith 🤦🏽‍♀️we know where the mind of the gov is😭
@Mer__edith There's a website that makes it easy to let them know what you think of it: https://fightchatcontrol.de/
Fight Chat Control - Protect Digital Privacy in the EU

Learn about the EU Chat Control proposal and contact your representatives to protect digital privacy and encryption.

@Mer__edith We're working on it ​

@Mer__edith

That sure means that the end-to-end encryption principle cease to exist and people needing secure and unbreakable comms will resort to e2e software written themselves or most likely, find an open source to modify it to their needs.

The problems governments want to solve isn't going away, It only gets totally out of sight. What a horrible dilemma. Sometimes I feel the EU parliament is filled with complete idiots.

@Mer__edith maybe the main thing to remind politicians is that it means *their* conversations become more vulnerable...

@b3lt3r

If the current proposal* is formulated in any way near the previous attempts you would find that they clearly understand encryption being so important for privacy that they have made themselves exemptions to the proposal. They are talking about your conversations, not their own.

* = I haven’t actually read the current proposal in detail

@Mer__edith

@m @Mer__edith I've no doubt there would be exemptions planned but of course it gets complicated when one end is exempted but the other isn't. The non-exempt end sees both sides of the conversation so the exempt is exposed. I'm sure the automation would be told to ignore it but the attack vector is opened to other parties. Whenever there is a vector it will, at some point, be exploited.

@b3lt3r

I honestly, sadly, do not think they understand that. Most of them do not know what they are about to do, and/or the implications of it.

Also, if others take the same route as Signal intends to do (just for clarification: which is a stance I applaud) there will be no one else to have a chat with for the politicians either, encrypted or not, unless they conjure up their own service. But that would also remove the “one end is un-encrypted” dilemma.

@Mer__edith

@Mer__edith Why? Why would people be in favour of this? It's like the whole world is deciding that freedom is over-rated.
@JustinMac84 @Mer__edith people don't have to be in favor of it if the government is acting in its own interests.
@eroc1990 @Mer__edith Governments have to do what won't get them outsted. For a Government to back this, it means that they are confident their populous won't make their lives uncomfortable for doing so!
@Mer__edith this bill makes the GDPR pointless then

@Mer__edith

https://fair.tube/w/72DCPMByyS1hoSg7gQFHXw
Here a good video explanation of the Max Plank Institute on how the technology of Chat Control works and what this would mean for digital communication within Europe.

Chat Control & Client-Side-Scanning - Video by the Max Planck Institute for Security and Privacy

PeerTube
( @Mer__edith It wouldn’t end private comms, it’d just simply make them illegal. Let go of the statist worldview )
@Mer__edith there's no letting them know, because they know already. They want this. And they don't want it despite of those consequences, but because of them.
@Mer__edith I already sent messages to everyone on the fight chat control website lists. I really hope this does not happen 😔
@Mer__edith
... and they are not just destroying German privacy but that of all Europeans. So no matter where in the EU you are from. Let your voice be heared!
@Mer__edith There are good legitimate reasons for the availability of private and secure messaging - financial, commercial and personal security.
@Mer__edith it is not only Germany...
@Mer__edith Seems like germany is back to opposing. https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/citizen-protest-halts-chat-control-breyer-celebrates-major-victory-for-digital-privacy/ At least for now… Couldn’t find a better source.
Citizen Protest Halts Chat Control; Breyer Celebrates Major Victory for Digital Privacy

In a major breakthrough for the digital rights movement, the German government has refused to back the EU's controversial Chat Control regulation yesterday after facing massive public pressure. The government did not take a position on the proposal. This blocks the required majority in the EU Counci

Patrick Breyer