I am fully here for the move to RGB LEDs on network switch status ports. it's one of those features that sounds like gamer gimmick bullshit but is actually super useful.

@gsuberland hard nope on that: utter shit UX for people who are #colourblind.

There are three guys with CVD in my network team, a statistical anomaly for sure, but 1 in 12 men are colourblind, and 1 in 200 women.

@WiteWulf I'm aware of the stats having rather heavily studied human visual perception. achromatopsia is extraordinarily rare, so CVD-safe colour sets are entirely doable here, especially given that the subset of CVD that makes up 70% of CVD prevalence is served with a single common distinguishable colour chart. the feature itself is fine, it just needs to be used in a way that's inclusive.

@gsuberland fair point well made, but I've yet to see it done well/inclusively on any equipment that uses, specifically, LEDs to indicate status.

Manufacturers typically just don't care enough, and accessibility gets value-engineered out of the final product.

There's something weird (that you likely know far more about than me) about LEDs that make colours far less distinguishable than white light through a filter. To me there are two colours of LED: [red|green|amber|yellow] and blue.

@WiteWulf true, but the point of RGB here is that it's adjustable to any colour by whoever configures the switch.

RGB LEDs are narrowband (in the case of direct emitters approaching three Gaussian monochromatic sources). you get less radiant flux between the peaks so when you have anomalous trichromacy you aren't getting as much information as you would with a broad spectrum light source of the same colour. the effect will still be apparent for dichromats but to a lesser extent.

@gsuberland ah, this is along the same lines as why purple (which I can't distinguish from blue) isn't a real colour, right?

https://www.sunglassscience.com/post/purple-it-doesn-t-exist-how-do-we-see-it

Purple: It doesn't exist. How do we see it?

I first came across this topic when I was looking into how rose lenses work and why they are so contrast-enhancing in some environments, but downright useless in others.What I discovered is that magenta, rose, purple, etc. do not exist at all.Magenta is an ‘extra-spectral color’, meaning that it is not found in the visible spectrum of light, which is why it is not in a rainbow.You can “see” an object when light reflected from an object enters your eyes and strikes the photoreceptors inside them.

Sunglass Science
@WiteWulf that's actually a super misleading popsci nonsense thing. purple is a colour, just the same as brown, black, white, or grey. it's just not a colour you can express as a single wavelength (monochromatic source). and even then that's doing a disservice to the extreme complexity of our visual systems and the qualities of human perception.
@gsuberland whatever, purple literally doesn't exist to me, it's purported being is a lie 😂
@WiteWulf yeah fair :P