Okay, finally tried some Becky Chambers, in the form of Monk and Robot, and I was willing to go along with it until the robot showed up and now I know why some of my friends hate her writing.

Writing utopias is difficult because they are very revealing of your personal politics, and something about this particular book also feels very patronizing.

@thedeadparrot join usssssssssssssssss (the haters)

@the_wanlorn i loathed the book so so much when i got to the end of it.

i had avoided her because i thought i would be amongst the haters, but some of my friends adored some of her stuff and i figured i should give it a chance.

alas, my first instinct was right.

@thedeadparrot I've only read the planet one and by the time I was at the end I was so mad that I had read the whole thing that I nearly combusted.

@the_wanlorn oooh, do tell. i definitely avoided that one because (a) full novel and (b) lots of people who dislike her writing disliked that one specifically.

i was wondering if her later ones had gotten better and it was just a fluke, but now i want to know if your dislike of it lines up with my dislike of this one and it's just that it's a thread through all of her writing.

@thedeadparrot So I don't like seek out reivews or anything so I don't know if this is something other people have talked about, but the thing that bothered me the most is there is Racist Guy in the main cast. And at the end of the book Racist Guy Gets What's Coming To Him. And like. I feel like it was supposed to be cathartic or whatever, but it just made me go oh this tells me all I need to know about your politics and no thank you.

Also it was very... idk tumblr utopia everyone in the main cast is queer and gets along nothing truly bad every happens etc? Which, tbh, I love when the cast can carry it, but uh. lmao.

@the_wanlorn @thedeadparrot I got very annoyed by how frictionless the found family was. Like, no one is ever "new girl doesn't shut up enough" or "he always rinses but doesn't scrub when it's he's on kitchen assignment"? People mostly get along, but the experience of getting along is a solid 15% being very annoyed.
@Betty @the_wanlorn hoo boy. i can see why this would be so grating. even the cozy mystery series i just read manages this level of verisimilitude!
@Betty @the_wanlorn @thedeadparrot this all annoyed me and on top of that my biggest peeve was it felt like what they told (Racist Wrong, Gender Nonbinary, Queer Good) utterly failed to understand how that differed from what the text actually showed in places
@Betty @thedeadparrot RIGHT like there was just NO conflict within the group and outside conflict was so like. Oh god I know what it reminded me of. It was one of those Moral Tales, you know????