Some indie devs have really bad takes on the Stop Killing Games thing, sheesh

"How am I going to comply if I make an MMO as a solo indie??"

Well 1. I have bad news for your odds of making an MMO lmao and 2. why are you so concerned that dropping the non 3rd party proprietary parts of your source code into a repository somewhere with a no-warranty license would bankrupt you? 🙄

If you can't even do that much wait til I tell you about your obligations under the GDPR and or the DMCA as a live service provider, which are far more onerous than simply "please have some kind of end-of-life service sunset plan"
And let's not even get into players using your "I'm just a little guy" indie live service game to coordinate crimes. Yes, that does happen
Hate to say it but running a live service game already requires putting on the big boy pants and if you're not ready for something as mild as "please have a sunsetting plan" then you're definitely not ready for the realities of running a live service game
Also I find it hard to believe that indies who achieve something as grand and community oriented as a live service game wouldn't be exactly the type of people to find some way to keep it playable in some form or another once they couldn't support it any longer themselves
@eniko in fact, indies usually try to release open servers along with their open games
@efi yeah turns out its a lot easier to sidestep all the legal liability if someone else runs the server
@eniko oof, eniko, plz, minecraft was already bleeding (lol)
@eniko the cost here isn't about success, it's about when the game fails. It's an extra risk on top of your existing highly likely outcome of failure. If you're successful it doesn't matter you can just keep supporting the game.

@eniko I really can't think of any indie that took the form of a "live service" game, really. Not in the traditional sense anyway. I seen some that got updates over the years or like, a dev added something yeaaars later but thats it

(No man's sky doesn't count)

@eniko reminds me of City of Heroes.

Game closed down, so the community figured out the server software and began running open servers.

And the company went after them. For daring to run free instances of a codebase that the owner had given up on.

A deal was originally reached, but the company did not make it easy.

The very small team releases like 2 updates a year, but the game still has a decently sized community; much of the content is user generated.

@eniko

I think I know who this is referring to, and my understanding is that he was a developer on a live-service game at one point. he's still full of shit, though.

aside: he did a game on Steam that used the achievements system to save, which is just bonkers.

@VulpineAmethyst it's only partly about him. people on bluesky are having opinions

@VulpineAmethyst @eniko Are we obfuscating his name for any specific reason? And yeah, it's a ridiculous anti-piracy measure. So just... No multiple save slots, eh? What happens when you want to replay the game, AFAIK there's no way to reset your steam trophies. Also his game hasn't left early access for like five years.

There are things I respect about the dude but his clownery has reached circus overwhelming levels. Let's not forget the parody streamer game lawsuit.

@mdstevens0612 @eniko

not that I expect him to be one of them, but there are people who name-search themselves to pick fights. hell, someone even paid $10 to go on SomethingAwful to pick a fight.

anyway, nah. I don't think he deserves the name recognition, is all. die in obscurity, etc.

@VulpineAmethyst @mdstevens0612 is he even on fedi?

@eniko @mdstevens0612

no clue, tbh. he does seem like the type to pick fights, tho.

@mdstevens0612 Him calling his game "unpirateable" for using Steam achievements to track progress was hilarious. He either had no idea that Goldberg Emulator exists, or was praying very hard that none of his fans would ever come to learn of it. That's not even mentioning how it just harms replayability.
His new "anti-piracy" tactic for his Undertale ripoff appears to just be to never finish developing the game lol.
@molytov I won't speak to the game's quality, I don't know and doubt I'll ever play it, but this is one of those over-engineered solutions that *feels* clever but just punishes paying customers, like most DRM. And I get it, piracy sucks for indie devs, especially when your asking price is already low, but maaaaaan... Tattoo "Keep it simple, silly" onto the forehead of every bedroom coder, we'd over-engineer boiling water if left to our own devices.
@eniko .. servers costs .. "someone has to pay for them" .. subscriptions .. and before you know you have to deal with DLCs .. "updates" .. "loot boxes" .. "cosmetics" .. "in game economy" and stuff like that ? ( plus a lot of people moaning about this & that ) 😅 ?

@eniko Random story but I brought this 'indie game dev quirk' with some people in the film industry and they referred to it as a leap of fools.

Very similar to the leap of faith, but its more plunging a project to its death out of stubbornness than it is making a risky but calculated decision.

It seems it happens in the indie film industry as well, where someone comes in with a lofty plan that anyone experienced will just look at them like this 😬

I guess I can't even think of how many times I've seen an indie Dev say "We're going to make XYZ better than any AAA game ever could!" And just leap for it... As they careen themselves right off that cliff.
‘Martyrdom or Bust:’ Texas Man Caught Plotting Terror Attack Through Roblox Chats

According to the FBI, a Texas man talked about killing christians on Roblox and searched for ‘are suicide attacks haram in islam’ on his iPhone.

404 Media
@eniko

Or using an online game aimed at children for adult-only roleplay (the specific one I had in mind only recently made changes to combat that, requiring connecting google account and having a report system, because before it didn't require any account at all to connect to online play, so even apart from just not having enough moderation, it was impossible to prevent anything, and there were always a couple of such servers in public)
@eniko Not just coordinate, commit. Like money laundering.

@eniko Like, there should be a named theorem for this: Any game that has all of:

1. In-game trade/commerce.
2. Any way to buy in-game currency with real-world currency.
3. People who want to play.

is inherently a money laundering platform.

@eniko Since someone asked then deleted the post, here's how you get your money out: item 3 makes it so you can sell in-game currency out-of-game way below face value (normal practice when laundering) to people who just want it for use in the game.
@dalias so you buy in game money with real money, then sell it for real money out of game at a discount?
@eniko After plausibly exchanging it around in the game across a multitude of mixer accounts so it's not trackable. I mean in theory it would be trackable, if the devs realized they had a money exchange platform subject to anti money laundering laws and not just a game. But...