What questions would you ask a 108-year-old woman?

https://sh.itjust.works/post/29560819

What questions would you ask a 108-year-old woman? - sh.itjust.works

My great-grandma is 108. I’m thinking of documenting her life in writing. She’s had an extremely interesting one. She was born in Berlin to a wealthy family, had a long-term affair with an older, married man from ~ the age of 17 who went missing in 1945. In the 1950s she married an American (my great-grandpa) and moved to the US. Little backstory. Looking forward to the question suggestions.

“How is modern times different than you predicted or hoped it would be?”

“What changed that you wished didn’t; what hasn’t changed that you wished did change?”

She has seen the world change so much during her lifetime, definitely ask her about how that feels

had a long-term affair with an older, married man from ~ the age of 17 who went missing in 1945.

Literally everything about THAT, what the fuck?

Did he have a mustache?
was he a mediocre painter?
I assume 1945 is war-related? Was he…on the other side of things?

Was he a baddie?

Are we the baddies?

Considering she was in Berlin, it’s pretty safe to say… Yes.
No, he had a starring role in Only Fools and Horses and this was his time travelling spin off.

My firmer SOs grand father went missing in 1945 (IIRC, maybe 1944), it took him 11 years to escape the Soviet gulag and walk all the way home to France.

She waited.

Holy shit, ALSO a story worth telling!

This is so hard to imagine in a modern world with instant communication and the ability to travel huge distances relatively easily.

Can you even try to imagine your SO disappearing one day, always just thinking “wonder where they are of if they’re alive”, the 11 years later they’re at your door like “sorry I’m late, what’s for supper?”

Do you know if he was able to get any correspondence out during his trek back? Maybe he was able to get a letter sent out in one of the cities he passed through?

  • Tell me about some of your favourite people when you were a child.

  • Do you remember any interesting sounds from your youth?

  • What was it like learning english? How did you start?

  • What were your first impressions when arriving in the USA?

These are all just conversation starters of course. You have to be ready to jump on the thread of a story she really wants to tell and pull on it to get more details and viewpoints.

Using sensory anchors like sounds or smells will really get your questions closer to memory triggers. “What did your favourite bakery smell like?” And then stuff will come up, like shortages or foreign treats, and that’s maybe a good story to follow.

Basically whenever possible, encourage her to “tell me about” life back then, and follow up with short questions asking for clarification or details.

Do you have a favourite song or band?
If she keeps following the news, how does she feel the current rise of political extremism compared to all the other crisis she has gone through, such as WW2 and the Cold War? Does it feel worse or does it feel less significant?

Damn, that means she was born in 1916. How has she perceived the failing of the Weimar Republic and the rising of the Nazis? Did she know any jews who “went missing” after 1933? How did she survive the bombings?

!TRIGGER WARNING!

Was she a victim of soviet war crimes during or after the battle of Berlin?

Not trolling, I would just be genuinely curious. I’m german and I missed the chance to ask my grandpa (born 1925, died before I was interrested in stuff like that), who was in the Wehrmacht on the western front, about how he perceived this and the war itself.

Somewhat off topic, it’s my understanding that they didn’t (usually) go missing. The term was “deported”, so it happened in broad daylight. Of course, what happened after wasn’t so widely known.
You know what? You’re absolutely right. “Went missing” is 100% the wrong term for this. It actually sounds too soft for what actually happened.
It’s a very “we don’t talk about it” situation. My great grandma’s family were very against the Nazis, moving to Switzerland in the 1930s after they took power. She refused to go with them because she wanted to be with her partner, who was extremely ingrained with the system. From their departure to Switzerland and the end of the war, they were no contact. When the war started the man moved his family and my great grandma to his estate around Konstanz, where they lived an isolated life with everything they needed; the area was also essentially unscathed. So no bombings to survive. From what my other relatives told me, she didn’t support what was happening, but her partner came before her morals.
“What’s something in your life you feel you haven’t gotten to talk about enough?”
This might be best in thread. If it hits her the right way, she might reveal something she kept secret her whole life
She would have been an adult by the start of the second world war, so, what were her thoughts of those times? What did she think about the rise of the Nazis then compared with today?
What was the industrial revolution like?

How does she feel about the current political climate as compared to that of her youth in Germany?

Before the war, did she or her family support the Nazis? I know a lot of people supposedly viewed it as, for want of a better term, a necessary temporary solution to the problems Germany was facing. Where did her family and she land on that? Did they support him during the war?

Before the war, Germany was a hotspot for queer folk, and from what I understand it was a pretty open secret, and outright public in a lot of areas and circles. How does she feel about trans issues and gay issues now? What about women’s rights?

Less political questions:

if she could bring back anything that no longer exists, what would it be? Could be a custom, a technology, a food, anything.

If you or her are comfortable discussing sex, I’ve found that people of that generation, when I’ve been able to talk to them or read interviews, have some really fantastic stories about illicit affairs that can give you a lot of background/cultural information by way of what was verboten and the ways they got around it. Did she have any other affairs or trysts?

What’s the worst thing about life today compared to life when she was young?

Would she ever want to return to live in Germany if she were able to spend s significant amount of time there?

Favorite movie star of her youth?

Personally I’d love to talk about what her hobbies were or simply how living would have been different. That setting though definitely makes for some interesting questions.

She could have been insulated from the war or just tried to ignore it but it’d be neat to ask what the opinions in her community were about it (or her own!). Also what changed in her lifestyle as a result of the start of the war and the end of it.

She was pretty insulated during WW2. Her family relocated to Switzerland after the Nazis took power as they didn’t support them; she chose to stay in Germany due to her partner. Her partner moved her and his family to his estate on the German side of Lake Constance, area which was virtually unscathed during the war. Was no contact with her family during this period. Talking about the man, his activities and that part of her life is a pretty “we don’t talk about Bruno” situation.

Talking about the man, his activities and that part of her life is a pretty “we don’t talk about Bruno” situation.

This is basically like someone shouting ‘he was a nazi!’ at the top of their lungs.

I’d ask what some of her favourite moments were.

I found with my grandparents that they’d focus on the smaller things as they aged. Sure, they could talk about the major events but they actually liked talking about the little things.

My grandmother (who is best described as an eccentric matriarch) would tell stories about how she changed her general store to one ~10 km further away because the closer one “didn’t serve poor people” (she’d tell the full story of why every time).

She died at ~77. I can only imagine what moments she’d have in her heart if she had lived to 108.

An 108 year old women and top voted question is about a relationship. Lol.
Well it did specify the gender, and there has been a truckload of changes for the fair one. Like the right to divorce, having a bank account and many more.
In addition to asking questions, I'd ask her what kind of wisdom she would like to share. And what she thinks is important in life.
Certainly not “So how old are you?”
Ask her, in depth, what changes she has seen, socially.
There was a cars game I got off TikTok that was just prompts for this sort of thing. The creator has moved off TikTok and has his own website now. tales.com/products/life-story-interview-kit
Life Story Interview Kit

And now it's a fucking product. Of course it is.
So don’t buy it come up with your own ideas.
I’m sure the creator needs to eat at some point during his own lifetime.
I would ask about impactful technology advancements. Telephone? Automatic transmission cars? Electrical and Internet infrastructure bringing them to every house? Ask for stories from the time she first got access to them.
Her favourite stuff, like movies, music, etc

In recording oral history I find that not asking too particular questions is often best, you want to lead them into freely drive into their memories and come into the mood of remembering things by themselves.

One way that has worked for me was to ask about the layout of they parental house, not because that is particular knowledge you want to record, but because it is a way for them to feel back at home and remember stuff.

Oh and please record it and, given permission ofc, hand the recording in to a nearby archive. Recorded oral history is a scarce good and can mean the world for people researching stuff you’ve not even thought about.

I would ask all about what she remembered leading up to WW2 and the aftermath in 1945. We can read thousands of WW2 history books but the difference is that we KNOW how it turned out. I want to know how people felt when they had no idea how things would unfold and turn out in the end

My grandma was born in WV 1919. I asked her a lot over the years (she passed in 2015)

Your great grandma may be different… but keep in mind, she’s human. And if she’s anything like my grandma, she will lie, or more charitably have some false recreations of certain memories.

So asking round about questions to get more details about certain things can sometimes get some interesting truths exposed without her realizing it.

Do not point out inconsistencies in an accusing way!!!

Remember not everything is the actual truth, even if she’s being honest. We are human and our memories are swiss cheese on good days. None of us remember everything with 100% accuracy.

Oh, and ask about her favorite music through the years, or favorite foods. Sometimes sounds, tastes l, and smells can trigger memories!

“What is your favorite color and food?”
  • what did she find strange about America when she arrived here?
  • what did she do for fun?
  • does she recall any experiences her parents/ grandparents told to her about their lives?
  • what was her favorite meal/ treat as a kid?
  • what is the most scandalous story she heard from a friend or family member?
  • did she or anyone in the family sing or play an instrument? What did they play?

Story Corps has a list of questions that would be helpful, and if you were interested in recording the audio of the interview their platform would be a good resource:

https://storycorps.org/participate/great-questions/

Great Questions - StoryCorps

After 17 years of listening, we know what makes a great conversation: Ask great questions. Here are some of our suggestions for getting a good conversation going. We encourage you to use the ones you like and to come up with your own.

StoryCorps
You’d better do it RIGHT NOW.
Do it as soon as possible, this is an opportunity that literally only comes around once per lifetime. Also, if she consents, try to record audio of her talking so that later generations can hear her and all the nuances of how she tells the stories.

The last time I spoke with my Paternal Grandmother was her 103rd birthday. She died about 2 months later.

She had completely lost her short term memory, but was otherwise still cognizant and her long term memory was perfectly intact. She was born in 1901 and died in 2004, so she saw a LOT of history. Three of her sons fought in World War 2 and one did not come back. She saw aviation go from sticks and canvas biplanes to jets.

So that is what I asked her about. Things that happened in her life in the distant past and if her mind started following a string of memories, I shut up and just listened. There are things I know about my family that I doubt my Dad, who died this past February, even knew.