Hugo Awards Disqualification Statement

Glasgow 2024, A Worldcon for our Futures, released the following statement today: In the course of tallying the votes on the final ballot for the 2024 Hugo Awards, the Glasgow 2024 Hugo Administratโ€ฆ

Locus Online

@Locusmag Doesn't seem to be any way to not "accept" all the cookies. You can't even read the cookie policy without accepting them, sight unseen, first! FFS!!

So I didn't read the article. These days anything without an immediately obvious "reject all" button doesn't get read.

@TimWardCam @Locusmag

This moose bit the bullet and accepted the cookies (I will now need to try and see what was set).

Gist of article: "377 votes for a single finalist were disallowed because they were clearly the result of an organised and paid-for ballot rigging campaign. As a result that finalist ("Finalist A") has not won anything. No other information will be made available for confidentiality reasons."

Looks like the Hugo committee have things well in hand.

3:O)>

@TimWardCam @Locusmag

File770 has the full statement without forcing you to accept Google's cookies.

@Cadbury_Moose @TimWardCam @Locusmag the interesting thing to me is that it might have worked if the perpetrator wasn't so lazy in randomly generating names.

@Sablebadger @TimWardCam @Locusmag

Possibly, but I wouldn't bet on that. Following the "Sad Puppy Affair" there was a large amount of interest taken in ballot analysis with a view to detecting vote-rigging attempts in the future, and I suspect the screening and statistical profiling of voting patterns have only improved since then. (Last Year's problems were somewhat further up the scale: it's difficult to defend against state or country-level actors, especially if they get to the staff.)

@Cadbury_Moose @TimWardCam @Locusmag good points. I'm all in favor of fair voting, abs yeah the whole sad puppy incident was a dark chapter.
Glasgow 2024 Hugo Awards Statement โ€“ 22nd July 2024 | Glasgow 2024

22 July, 2024

Glasgow 2024, a Worldcon for Our Futures

@kianryan @Locusmag

Ta.

Yes, independent auditing of ballots can sometimes be useful (I've done that job for a local group).

@Locusmag Wow, impressive. You have a cookie banner that prevents scrolling, and it is on all pages including the cookie policy. Who even comes up with this stuff?