Should the original poster be able to remove replies to their post?

#EvanPoll #poll

Strong yes
31.8%
Qualified yes
36.5%
Qualified no
19.6%
Strong no
12.1%
Poll ended at .

So, I'm a strong yes.

Every ActivityPub post has a `replies` collection that contains all the replies to the post. The definitive version lives on the original poster's server.

The OP should be able to either approve replies before they're added to this collection, or remove them from the collection if they're added automatically.

The UI for ActivityPub apps should use this `replies` collection when showing the replies to a post. (Many of them currently just search for replies locally.)

@evan

Federating the _list_ of replies from the poster's instance isn't currently done, is it?

Doing that would address (maybe?) one of the (least toxic) causes of the reply-guy phenomenon — that small instances often don't have a complete cache of all the replies to a post on another instance

@trochee

Yes, the `replies` property is a standard property.

https://www.w3.org/TR/activitystreams-vocabulary/#dfn-replies

Activity Vocabulary

@evan

From the horse's mouth!

So, (1) servers respecting `replies` in display, would help with the "I can't see others' replies"?

@evan

And (2) an ability to remove entries from the `replies` property, combined with (1), would approach what kissane was suggesting?

@trochee I didn't read @kissane 's posts that carefully. What do you think? Does it meet her needs?