Got into an interesting discussion on what matters in communication.

Nuance gets missed a lot when people tell half-truths. For instance, an astonishing amount of folks say they want gas as their heating system because of power outages.

Most gas-fired systems still need electricity to operate. Which, anyone who has lived with one during a power outage, already knows.

That half-truth is that a gas-fired system can more easily be supplied with emergency power. But most people don't have that.

So does the point even deserve to be made?

Truly, I think it doesn't.

The loss of any primary system becomes an emergency in extreme cold. And you'd be better-off to prepare for that.

A gas-fired heating system is not preparation for that. It makes one consideration easier, sure. But first and foremost people need to make that consideration - which most don't.

And there are plenty of backup options. I, for one, would rather have some propane on-hand for a portable heater when shit hits fan.

@TechConnectify It's like your "but sometimes" video!

Is it possible to hand-light a gas stove when the electricity is out? Yes.

Why are you planning for the 0.5% use case? This is a house, not a space ship.

@preinheimer @TechConnectify 246 people died in Texas a couple of years ago when they found themselves smack in the middle of that 0.5% case. 🤷‍♂️

@timjclevenger @preinheimer And that was a tragedy which would have been prevented if any of the following occurred:

1. Texas would grow the fuck up and connect their grid to the rest of the country
2. Emergency preparedness was front-and-center in peoples' minds, both on individuals levels and in the minds of the powers-that-be
3. Sensible building standards were created and actually enforced to reduce energy needs and also extend the time homes stay warm without power

@TechConnectify @timjclevenger @preinheimer FWIW, we had an ice storm that knocked out power here in Montreal at the start of April last year. We were without power (read: without our heat pumps, and baseboard heaters) for ~40h. It was below 0°C outside for much of that.

After the first day, I ran the generator to power the fridges and recharge our backup batteries.

I showered after ~30h, and we washed some dishes. Still had tank hot water.

It was fine.

@sean @TechConnectify @timjclevenger @preinheimer

It's worth very little. You'd die of heatstroke in a Texas summer, and Texans don't have insulation like you do. They don't have baseboard heaters. They don't have heat pumps. They don't have basements.

They don't have wool clothes. They don't have clothes in sizes meant to accommodate a lot of layers. They don't have what you'd think of as winter coats at all. You can barely find them at all.

What did you add, exactly?

@caffetiel @sean @TechConnectify @timjclevenger @preinheimer I think what he added is insulation and this is something that is missing in TX. It doesn't matter if it's hot or cold, insulation helps your house to stay at the temperature you want.
I'm always amazed that people in those hot places say they don't need insulation and then have to spend lots of money on cooling their buildings.
@TechConnectify @preinheimer Agreed although I don't know how much an individual or family in an apartment can control for that. Many apartments are poorly insulated and renters aren't allowed generators or pressurized tanks. Even people who had generators were SOL unless they were willing to store an uncomfortable amount of gasoline as roads were impassable and gas stations lost power. Fortunately we were pretty well insulated and had a big store of blankets and canned food. I now own a set of tire chains even though they're illegal to use here. (They'll have to catch me first)
@TechConnectify @timjclevenger @preinheimer
Sure, but 1 and 3 are beyond the power of individual citizens to fix.Those who live in places where 1 and 3 aren't taken care of can't plan on society level emergency planning, either. If they want to maximize their chances of surviving the next disaster, they need to plan on surviving without any government help.
@preinheimer @TechConnectify
A 0.5% use case is still about 2 days per year, which seems worth preparing for. That's especially true if that rare case is as easy to plan for as keeping a book of matches in your kitchen.
Preparing to be self-sufficient in a disaster is also important because bad events tend to correlate. For example, checking into a motel if your power goes out might work for a transformer failure but won't if the grid is overstressed by a blizzard.